Andrew RT Davies slammed for ‘abhorrent’ social media post
Emily Price
A former Welsh Government minister has branded Conservative MS Andrew RT Davies “utterly abhorrent and completely irresponsible” for sharing a misleading video of school girls online.
Former Counsel General Mick Antoniw called for the recently ousted leader to “realise what an appalling thing” he had done and give a “full apology”.
Mr Antoniw’s comments came after Mr Davies was reported to the Senedd’s standard’s commissioner over a video he shared on X featuring young school girls from Brynteg School in Bridgend.
The South Wales Central MS claimed the girls were being used as “propaganda” by the Welsh Government’s Nation of Sanctuary plan – an initiative to help refugees and asylum seekers integrate into Welsh communities.
In an X post, Mr Davies said: “Under this ideologically motivated project, Labour wanted to pay ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS £1,600 a month. Unacceptable.”
Abuse
It later transpired that the video of the children had been filmed over a year ago as part of a project to welcome families fleeing the conflict in Ukraine.
The footage was withdrawn in 2023 after the school and pupils concerned suffered extensive online abuse.
The video resurfaced on X at the weekend from a far-right account named Cillian, who said the Welsh Refugee Council was using 12-year-old girls in ads to “entice migrant men to come to Wales”.
The post was then amplified by Mr Davies as well as billionaire X owner Elon Musk and political journalist Isabel Oakeshott.
The video was later earmarked by an X community note as “potentially misleading” after concerns were raised that it had been edited to remove male school children and omit details of the welcome project relating to Ukrainian refugees.
Nation.Cymru found that the footage had been taken from a group of videos made by both girls and boys which are still stored on Google drive.
Mr Davies says the fact the video could have been edited is a “side issue”.
In a post to X, he said: “I don’t know if it was edited. If it was, that’s a side issue. The Welsh Refugee Council went into the school and used children for its propaganda. That’s very wrong and should not have happened.”
Complaint
The council says it is pursuing a complaint against the Tory politician with the Senedd’s standards commissioner – an independent person who investigates grievances about the conduct of MSs.
Former trustee of Welsh Refugee Council and Pontypridd MS Mick Antoniw expressed his solidarity with staff at the charity and called for an apology from Mr Davies.
Mr Antoniw is of Ukrainian descent on his father’s side and speaks the language.
He recently appeared in a programme on a Ukrainian television channel alongside Labour backbencher Alun Davies which documented their journey to personally deliver vital aid to the war torn nation.
In a statement posted to Facebook, he said: “As the son of a refugee, and former trustee of the Welsh Refugee Council, I read this report with sadness, anger and digust.
“It seems that Andrew RT Davies, a former political leader in our Senedd, has lowered himself (further) to posting misleading and highly offensive comments about the nature of a video made by schoolchildren who simply wanted to share a message of compassion toward refugees and signpost support available to them.
“On his Twitter/ X account, Mr. Davies not only makes the false claims that children were being used for ‘propaganda’, and that ‘Labour wanted to pay illegal immigrants £1600 a month’ , but he has also re-posted the video in question (which features the schoolchildren he claims to care about) from a far-right X.com account riddled with racism and conspiracy theories. Nobody who really cared about the safety of young people would do such a thing.
“It’s no surprise to me that this has attracted the attention of an individual as vile as Elon Musk, who has also made shameful comments about the nature of this video on the social media platform he owns (and has wrecked), but it is reprehensible for a serving member of our Senedd to deliberately sow division and hatred.
“This is utterly abhorrent and completely irresponsible behaviour, which makes the lives of people who have fled their country of origin to seek peace and sanctuary, and those who help them, more difficult and dangerous.
“I very much hope that he will come to realise what an appalling thing he has done and give a full apology.
“I want to express my solidarity with all staff at the Welsh Refugee Council and everyone who works with refugees, as well as to everyone who has fled their country seeking peace and safety here in Wales, which, despite people like Andrew RT Davies, is a Nation of Sanctuary.”
The Welsh Conservatives were invited to comment but did not respond.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Elon Musk 🤝🏽 Andrew RT Davies
Sharing a racist coloniser mindset
Saying we should be nice to children escaping a warzone is now “propaganda” in the world of RT Davies.
Just when you think ARTD can’t stoop any lower, he does. 🙄 I hope the standards commissioner hammers him, by forcing him to apologise and suspending him for the maximum amount of time.
You’d think that his public acknowledgement that support from his own Senedd colleagues had become too inadequate for him to continue as their leader would have taught him greater ‘custody of the lips’.
But seemingly not. Recently I heard him brusquely deny any imputation that he’s considering defecting to Reform, but this latest unconsidered outburst suggests that might well be his ultimate trajectory.
Based on what happened today in the Senedd, the Tories are just playing musical chairs with their group leadership. 🙄😒
Indeed. It’s really hard to take them seriously as an opposition. Surely they must have at least the odd MS with the ability to reach out to appeal to voters beyond the hardened Tory voter tribe, which has consistently proved to be small enough across the 25 years of devolution to ruke itself out of government. Maybe Russell George, for instance, might be a better leader? Though I really regretted the retirement of David Melding, who always seemed to me to be very much the sort of Tory politician who, many decades ago back in the ’60s, made me view… Read more »
What kind of mind immediately associates a video of young schoolgirls being lovely human beings with being “bait” used to tempt predatory paedophiles? If his mind works like that I think there is real cause for concern.
Given the accusations made against him, you could well have a point.
The right wing don’t care what they’re saying now, they just wish to motivate their voters to be active online and turn out to vote.
I think it is time for him to apologise, resign and leave politics now.
And why exactly hasn’t he been sacked??
It would appear that after Mr Millar’s performance in the Senedd this day, they have orders from Badenoch. They are going to be 100% disingenuous and use it to attack the labour party. The cons are in hock to Musk and anyone else that will attack on their behalf, the William Joyce approach. I expect Mr Millar sees no issue here now because of orders received. Sending decency to the gutter.
I see he is still on his bandwagon (see tweets). I see Mr Millar is giving this idiot leeway. Werlsh cons culpable as well now, as a group. He spouts off over grooming gangs, quite rightly a terrible thing but this is his (and Tory Party) bandwagon for no other reason than attacking Labour. In trying to engage on musks hate platform in this, he must know that this will result it abuse aimed at the kids in that video (see his halal comments around the riots, stop the boats, support for braverman….). There is no way a normal person… Read more »
Who on earth votes for this nasty little man??