Welsh Reform councillor mocked after ‘car crash’ interview
Emily Price
A Conservative Senedd Member has ripped into a Reform councillor after a “car crash” interview discussing what Nigel Farage’s party can offer Wales.
Torfaen Councillor David Thomas was mocked by Shadow Counsel General Tom Giffard after he appeared to stumble over answers during a recent BBC Radio Wales Breakfast interview.
Thomas – a former Labour member who represents the Cwmbran ward of Llantarnam – was one of three independent councillors that formed Reform UK’s first council group in August last year.
He has since become a prominent figure within the party – although he told Nation.Cymru he is not planning to stand at the upcoming Senedd election.
Thomas – who had a key role in Reform’s recent Runcorn and Helsby by-election win, also told us he is undecided on whether he will stand again at the next Welsh local election set to take place in May 2027.
We asked, if this were the case, why did he appear on the BBC radio programme, to which he replied: “I was the only one available.”
‘Painful’
During the “painful” exchange with BBC presenter James Williams on Wednesday (May 7), the Reform politician was pressed to give details of what his party will offer Welsh voters at the 2026 election.
It came after a new YouGov poll for ITV Cymru Wales and Cardiff University revealed that support for Labour has slumped to its lowest since the start of devolution.
The poll predicted a large increase in Plaid Cymru’s vote share whilst Reform support is also expected to surge with the new proportional voting system making it easier for the party to gain more seats in Wales than they did at the general election.
Reform UK doesn’t yet have an official Welsh leader and is currently fronted by Clacton MP Nigel Farage.
In the Senedd last week, First Minister Eluned Morgan accused Reform of offering only “simplistic responses” and “no real answer to Wales’ problems.”
The BBC asked David Thomas what he made of the FM’s comments
Speaking on Radio Wales Breakfast, he said: “Simplistic answers? Well it’s quite simple really. It’s all about cutting the waste within the Senedd and our way forward for the party and the future of Wales is cutting waste within local government, within local councils…”
Presenter James Williams interrupted the Reform councillor asking him to explain what he meant by “waste”.
Thomas responded: “Well, procurement. The way councils are run. Where they are buying their stuff for the councils, the way they are employing different contractors.
“We are going to radically go through how councils operate and where they spend their money. When councils say to you, they haven’t got any money – that’s not true.
“Councils always have money, it’s just where they choose to spend that money. And this is something our party is going to be looking at, and will solve the problem going forward, giving people what they want.”
Cuts
Thomas was also quizzed on Nigel Farage’s pledge to cut income tax in every bracket by one or two pence if his party wins the next general election,
Asked what difference a 2p cut across the board would make to the Welsh coffers, the Reform councillor appeared unable to answer the question.
He said: “Once we go through and put on display all our policies moving forward for the Senedd election, you will see exactly how we plan to do what we are saying we are going to do to put money back into peoples pockets.”
On turning around the Welsh NHS – arguably the number one priority for voters – Thomas said his party would “reform every department in the NHS”.
He said: “We will be looking to go through every single department and clearing out the waste, sorting out the procurement there and ensuring that the NHS is running, you know, in a much more efficient way than it is now.”
‘Painful’
Sharing a clip of the interview on social media, South Wales West MS Tom Giffard branded it a “car crash”.
Speaking to Nation.Cymru, he said: “Reform in Wales simply haven’t got a clue. Listening to one of their most prominent candidates try to answer detailed and specific questions was painful listening.
“It is becoming clearer by the day that as much as Reform are able to point out problems and shout slogans, they don’t have a single plan about what they’d actually do if they got any power in Wales.
“There’s no doubt that after 26 years of a Welsh Labour Government that Wales needs change. But people considering voting for Reform will start to ask themselves how long they’re willing to tolerate a party without a single solution to deliver it.
“Meanwhile, the Welsh Conservatives are setting out our plan to Fix Wales. Last week alone, we detailed our proposals for a 1% cut in income tax for people across Wales and scrapping business rates completely for small businesses, to give our economy the turbocharge it needs.”
Responding to the Tory’s comments, David Thomas said: “Tom Giffard represents a party that was in power in Westminster for 14 years and what do we have to show for it? Stagnant growth, high taxes, crumbling public services, and a failure to stand up to Labour’s failures in Wales.
“The Welsh Conservatives have had more than a decade to hold Labour to account in Cardiff Bay and they’ve failed. Now they want people to believe they’ve suddenly found the answers. Voters aren’t buying it.
“While the Conservatives cling to reheated ideas, Reform UK is building a bold, credible plan for real change. In the months ahead, we’ll be unveiling ambitious policies to fix the problems facing our communities from restoring common sense in public life to delivering economic growth and putting Welsh people first.
“Wales is broken, not just by Labour’s incompetence, but by a weak Conservative opposition too. Wales needs Reform.”
Tirade
Thomas later launched an online tirade against the Welsh Conservative Senedd Member accusing him of “doing what the Tories do best, lying to the public.”
Hitting back, Giffard posted several news articles featuring Thomas including claims that the councillor had cut the ribbon of a new Lidl supermarket despite not being invited to do so, and an allegation that he had attempted to rejoin the Labour Party before joining Reform.
Alongside the screen grabs, Giffard said: “Imagine being accused of dishonesty by this bloke.”
Thomas responded saying all the news stories were a “pack of lies”.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Farages manifesto has been seen and measured. He will out tank lizz truss attempt to bankrupt the UK, and his “councillors” are not allowed to deviate and he is losing them in England.
reform do not have policies. Only a wrecking ball. The stupidity of doge in the US is not reported enough, they have not found waste, cut many thousands of jobs and created public danger.
reform are a danger to your lives.
Let’s be frank. Reform UK offer Wales nothing4They have no policies, leader or substance. Apparently they want to stop waste in the Senedd and NHS. Pretty vague lacking detail. Who can recall Reform UK’s previous incarnations, Ukip & Brexit Party. As AMs in the then Welsh Assembly were paid £60+ per annum for doing absolutely nothing. Anyway, where were the likes of Russian spy Nathan Gill when he should have been scrutinising the Welsh Government and bothering to turn up for important votes & debates in the chamber but opted to travel to Brussels instead at great public expense and… Read more »
Their stop waste model is what musk is doing. It is incoherent blather. Musk is wrecking the US, on of the big reasons his cars are targeted and sales plummeting. Only the face of this action in the UK will be reform. Farage will jump ship and create another grift. Yes there will be waste in many systems, there always is. But maybe look at the 20+ councillors they have lost since election(at this date), that will cost the council tax payer a big chunk as they run re elections, just after the elections. And the prize grifter that want… Read more »
The trouble is Reform are riding high without a Welsh leader and real Welsh orientated policies, struggling people are desperate. The country’s only hope is that the majority of seats go to Plaid. There’s a good chance – it’s all to fight for.
True. Reform do not have a leader in Wales but he’s not going to just sit behind Millar for much longer is he?
More blue-on-blue please.
While a bit inevitable, given the circumstances, it is not desirable. Wales doesn’t have a credible centre-right option, which is of significant concern.
Perhaps the current Senedd group will jump ship to Reform allowing the Welsh Cons to welcome back the centre right moderates purged in 2019 under orders from Johnson.
You can now also include Labour after Starmers Island of Strangers remark
Ouch!
The missing question here is, who is going to pay for sourcing all these waste saving cuts? Is it going to be done in house, or will Reform create a department at the Senedd and in any councils it runs? Most likely they’ll have to employ “consultants”. And we all know how much they can cost.
Maybe they’ll copy their American “friends” and create the Department Of Senedd Efficiency. I’m sure Farage will love to deliver a sound bite about giving a DOSE of reform to Wales, or some such nonsense.
Clap springs to mind.
Is he one of Hope Not Hate’s boys in disguise?
The offer to Wales from Reform UK is well known but sadly their councillor will not spell it out as it will betray its’ transparent horror which could put off a voter or two. The ‘waste’ cutting exercise will include privatising the NHS, removing free prescriptions in the process, funnelling all money to private billionaires and away from us, the people, then hatred, division, false blaming, general intolerance, othering, racism, fascism, Muskism, Trumpism, riots, destruction, total lawlessness, ignorance, arrogance etc etc etc. Watch some old progs on the National Front and BNP and tell me what the difference is.
I think England should keep them on their side of the border. Keep this filth out of Wales.
They’re both scumbags as far as I’m concerned. Both lower than vermin.