Support our Nation today - please donate here
Opinion

Labour offers hope to rural communities in Wales

31 Aug 2024 4 minute read
Henry Tufnell and Chris Bryant with Labour’s election battle bus

Henry Tufnell MP

The general election saw an unprecedented swing in support for the Labour Party from rural and coastal communities.

In my constituency of Mid and South Pembrokeshire in west Wales, parts of the county had not had a Labour MP for nearly 20 years and this story was reflected in many constituencies right across the country.

I am often asked how much this was driven by wanting to give the Tories a kicking rather than any formal embrace of the Labour Party project. Speaking with my Labour colleagues and anecdotal evidence from thousands of door-step conversations it undoubtedly played a role, but what was often overlooked was the economic vision for the future of the country provided by Labour – “Securonomics”.

Shift

Rachel Reeves’ plan to make, buy, and sell more in Britain presented a marked shift in economic outlook, particularly when compared to a Conservative Party that had failed to implement any coherent industrial strategy for 14 years.

In our former industrial heartlands and coastal towns these kinds of decisions make or kill off communities. The impact of Thatcher’s brutal approach to the miners in the 1980s and the absence of an economic strategy for those communities once the mining industry disappeared are still being felt to this day.

In Pembrokeshire we are particularly exposed to these decisions; with no university, and with energy, agriculture and tourism as our main economic drivers – 20% of the UK’s energy comes through the Port of Milford Haven, while agriculture and tourism provide 5.4% and 17% of local employment respectively. Therefore, an economic strategy centred on Artificial Intelligence and Bio Tech will not solve the problem of one in four children living in poverty in Pembrokeshire.

Regional inequality

Attempts to address regional inequality are clearly not unique to Labour. The 2019 Conservative government had their own attempt through the “Levelling Up” agenda. The scheme ultimately ended in failure because of the difficulty in holding together such a wide political coalition – personified in the differences between [former West Midlands Mayor] Andy Street and [Tees Valley Mayor] Ben Houchen or the traditional Tory voters in the leafy shires and the 2019 Red Wall contingent.

We are not immune to these schisms in a Parliamentary Labour Party that numbers 412, but the difference is that our remedy to these issues is structural with a desire to profoundly shift our economic agenda, rather than a redirection of cash through schemes that too often lacked a real long-term vision of how to achieve a positive economic feedback loop.

Labour’s Green Prosperity Plan to cut energy bills, deliver energy security and create good well-paid jobs while tackling the Climate Crisis represents a clean break after decades of neglect due to the absence of that viable industrial strategy on a UK-level. The creation of GB Energy backed with £8bn of public money, working in partnership with the Crown Estate will seek to leverage a further £60bn of investment from the private sector.

Offshore wind

The partnership will support the development of projects across a range of technologies, including offshore wind and newer technologies such as carbon capture and hydrogen. These projects are vital to us in Pembrokeshire to capitalise on being the closest port to the Celtic Sea development for floating offshore wind, and as we look to decarbonise across the energy sector with our oil refinery, two liquefied natural gas terminals and power station.

The future looks bright, with a mandate from the electorate and a clear route to implementation. However, organisations such as the Crown Estate must recognise their duty to help deliver this wider economic project and not simply focus on maximising their return on investment, particularly when 12% of their profits goes directly to the Crown rather than the public purse.

For example, in the case of floating offshore wind in the Celtic Sea, there must be binding commitments to the wider economic and social benefits for local communities or else we will end up back in the same economic model of the last 30 years where building takes place in China, and we merely assemble and service from ports like Pembroke Dock and Port Talbot.

After years of being left behind and forgotten about, it is time that communities like mine are given back their voice.

 Henry Tufnell is the Labour MP for Mid and South Pembrokeshire


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
18 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Annibendod
Annibendod
13 days ago

Specifics please Henry, specifics. What projects are coming to Pembrokeshire? Name them. And you mention the Crown Estate … Wales’ resources exploited and the profits siphoned off to Westminster. You should be busting a gut to have them devolved to the Senedd so we have parity with Scotland. No mention of that in this pro Labour puff piece. This is the problem with Labour. The structural inequalities of the UK disproportionately disadvatage Wales. Radical reforms are needed to the constitutional, political and economic models that the State operates. Labour are simply not interested in making those changes. Instead we get… Read more »

Valley girl
Valley girl
13 days ago
Reply to  Annibendod

Pembrokeshire will be even poorer as the MOD will object to planning for on or offshore wind turbines as this is classed as interference if the DARC 30 RADAR project is allowed to go ahead in Newgale. Consultation 12 and 13. I bet Henry won’t be attending.

Hywel
Hywel
13 days ago

GB Energy sounds like another Westminster excuse to asset strip Wales, taking the profit away whilst covering our country in industrial sized windfarms, Henry. Wales’s future lies in a Welsh takeover of the Crown Estate, as in Scotland and NI; push Ynni Cymru, with our own Sovereign Fund taking the profit from more offshore and fewer onshore wind farms which blight our landscape, and redistributing it in Wales to clear away child poverty, social inequality and generate a happier society. There is only one way to do this – independence – we just need to believe in ourselves – we’re… Read more »

John Ellis
John Ellis
13 days ago

‘I am often asked how much this was driven by wanting to give the Tories a kicking rather than any formal embrace of the Labour Party project.’ Opinion pollsters have the professional ‘wherewithal to assess this question with a degree of authority and any individual can only take a speculative punt at it based on personal impression. But my personal impression is that the outcome of the Westminster election back in early July was very considerably shaped by the desire ‘to give the Tories a kicking’ after a uniquely disastrous and depressing tenure of office, rather than by any enthusiastic… Read more »

Last edited 13 days ago by John Ellis
Annibendod
Annibendod
13 days ago
Reply to  John Ellis

The other big point is that they have 2/3 of the MP’s on 1/3 of the vote … 1/4 of the electorate! Now if anything demonstrates why we need rid of this undemocratic electoral system that is shared only with Belarus of all the European states, it is this. Yet another example of the dysfunctional UK. A mandateless majoritarian government yet again.

John Ellis
John Ellis
13 days ago
Reply to  Annibendod

I agree.

But as there’s no political party with a will to change it – or at least any that the UK electorate seems disposed to vote into office – we are where we are.

Richard Davies
Richard Davies
13 days ago
Reply to  John Ellis

Across the uk as a whole labour lost support rather than increase.

In 2019 labour obtained 10,269,051 votes in total and this year 9,708,716 in total.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_United_Kingdom_general_election

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_United_Kingdom_general_election

It is only because of the undemocratic “first past the post” electoral system used for uk general elections can such iniquities occur!

Look at the constituency of keir starmer, in 2019 he got 36,641 votes but in 2024 only 18,884 votes, a reduction of 17,757.

https://members.parliament.uk/constituency/3536/election/397

https://electionresults.parliament.uk/elections/3540

John Ellis
John Ellis
13 days ago
Reply to  Richard Davies

You and I have apparently been viewing different statistics because those which I saw posited a small increase in the overall Labour vote over that which the party gained at the previous Westminster election in 2019 – the point being made, however, that the purported increase in the Labour vote was wholly disproportion to the number of seats which Labour gained.

But I suppose that differences both in calculation and in conclusions consequently drawn will inevitably vary between different psephologists. That’s generally the way with experts! But however the figures are read, the distorting nature of FPTP remains a constant.

Adrian Bamford
Adrian Bamford
13 days ago

We will not be ‘making more’. Net Zero will continue to effectively de-industrialise the UK as energy costs continue to spiral. Tata steel has now gone, and we’ve just closed our last fertiliser plant: it’s just too expensive to manufacture in the UK. The most recent Digest of UK Energy Supply shows that we are continuing to import more and more energy, including electricity, so more renewables aren’t making things better, or cheaper. Why are they pushing this? Look at the ministers & civil servants involved: you’ll be hard pushed to find anyone with a STEM qualification, or any experience… Read more »

Mab Meirion
Mab Meirion
13 days ago

Clark of Kent comes in for criticism from Owen Jones in the G for his appetite for presents, freebies or subtle bribes as he worries…

The Fat Shanks Effect…carbolic soap and a stiff brush needed but a healthy die-off rate now considered normal by our law makers…

Jonathan Edwards
Jonathan Edwards
13 days ago

Went to Withybush this morning to Wynnstays to buy an agri-thing, on HT’s patch. He comes from a family of Gloucestershire landowners. His Dad was president of the Country Land and Business Association for heaven’s sake. You’d think the MP for ‘down below’ in Pembs would have some great policy for Welsh farmers. But he is a Labour MP so we won’t hold our breath…

Valley girl
Valley girl
13 days ago

HT is a barrister and Pembs was t his first choice seat. He is only here as a career move and a very easy seat. Shame the Welsh are so gullible.

Brychan
Brychan
13 days ago

There is nothing to substantiate his claim that “swing in support for the Labour Party from rural and coastal communities”. In his own seat, Labour underperformed but this may be because he was parachuted in from England and secured a nomination because his mam had a holiday home there. In fact, both the neighbouring constituencies, Ceredigion and Caerfyrddin there was a swing to Plaid Cymru, the latter with Labour loosing what was predicted a Labour seat. Labour are starting to believe their own propaganda. How many pensioners in Pembrokeshire will freeze this winter because the cuckoo has arrived?

Old Curmudgeon
Old Curmudgeon
13 days ago

I wonder if voting for Westminster government is different as the Conservatives had been making a bad effort for a long time. In Wales we have had Labour in for a long time making a bad effort at governing. It will be interesting to see how Plaid fare ‘ particularly when compared to a welsh Labour Party that had failed to implement any coherent industrial strategy for years.’

Jack
Jack
13 days ago

I always have trouble when politicans claim ‘swings to’ – many results are ‘swings away.’ Given the Tories had imploded no-one really could vote for them in a marked way at the last election. That left, in Wales, a choice of Labour or PC. PC, for many, is merely a single issue ‘speak Welsh and save the world’ party which meant the choice in the last election for many was vote Labour or don’t vote. Given theremoval of the winter heat allowance I woner how many who voted for Labour would vote for them if a new election was tomorrow.… Read more »

CapM
CapM
12 days ago
Reply to  Jack

 “PC, for many, is merely a single issue ‘speak Welsh and save the world’ party”

You’re having trouble counting that’s two issues.

hdavies15
hdavies15
12 days ago
Reply to  CapM

No,no. He meant that speaking Welsh saves the world! Good punchline for Cymdeithas if not Plaid

Valley girl
Valley girl
13 days ago

The MOD is looking to build 30 RADAR defence system in Newgale, Pembs: if this goes ahead the MOD like it has done throughout UK will object to any planning for wind turbines on or offshore as it is classed as interference: I am certain this will conflict with Wales’ renewable energy project and Future generations Act and if this project is allowed to go ahead will result in Pembs becoming eve. Poorer. Henry refuses to give his stance on whether he supports the Radar project or not and I suspect he will be long gone once he gets bored… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.