Andrew RT Davies doubles down on dog-free zone claims as community group suffers torrent of racist abuse
Emily Price
Andrew RT Davies has doubled down on comments he made about anti-racist dog free zones despite the organisation at the heart of the story telling him its members have been subject to a “barrage” of racist abuse and hate mail.
This week several national news outlets reported that dogs would be banned from the Welsh countryside under new plans to make green spaces more inclusive of ethnic minorities.
The claims were amplified by the leader of the Senedd Conservatives who shared news articles on his social media channels and appeared as a guest to talk about the issue on GB News.
The story stemmed from a government commissioned report by Climate Cymru BAME which sought to understand the relationship between ethnic minority communities and environmental matters.
‘Cherrypicked’
Climate Cymru says one line from the report was “cherrypicked” by some tabloids and politicians “out of context, misrepresented and used as clickbait to drive engagement.”
The Welsh Government says the comment highlighted by the media was “feedback” and “not Welsh Government proposals”.
An email exchange shown to Nation Cymru has revealed how the head of Climate Cymru, Sam Ward, contacted Mr Davies pleading with him to stop adding weight to the claims because it was causing “suffering” to the BAME communities involved.
‘Upset’
Mr Ward wrote: “I am writing on behalf of community members who are upset. There has been quite a bit of misunderstanding on the issue which I have seen on your social media accounts and doing media interviews. Let me offer this explanation and background and I hope it can be considered moving forward to minimise the damage done to this community group and individuals involved.
“Climate Cymru Ethnic Minorities (formerly BAME) Group is a small, self-formed community group. The Welsh Government asked for views from ethnic minority community members on racism in Wales and this group held conversations with wider community members and submitted comments from the discussions as part of the nationwide conversation.
“When discussing their experience of barriers to being in the outdoors one of the community members suggested: ‘Create urban farming (allotments) and dog-free areas in local green spaces’.
“Children’s playgrounds are an example of this. This comment was not a central part of either the conversation or their overall feedback. This was just one comment of many from this community conversation submission and is not Welsh Government policy.
“It has been taken out of context, cherry picked, misrepresented and used as clickbait. The original Daily Mail article, seemingly based on this single line, claimed that dogs have been banned from the Welsh Countryside, which is factually incorrect. The headline has now been changed but remains misleading; no one has suggested dogs are racist or that they will be banned from the countryside.
‘Hate mail’
Mr Ward continued: “The community members (many of whom are dog lovers!) and small staff team have been the brunt of considerable criticism and influx of hate mail and messages. The coverage uses the misleading headlines to encourage pushback on measures to address racism and undermines trust from this community trying to participate in the democratic process.
“We are frustrated at the media landscape honing in on this when what we would really like them and the Welsh Conservatives to focus on holding the government to account on the real issues that communities in the UK are facing.
“Millions of people across the UK are in fuel poverty and the cost of living crisis remains central to people’s lives. The fossil fuel companies make billions of pounds whilst millions live in cold damp homes and air pollution kills more than 28,000 in the UK each year (1400+ in Wales).
“Racism remains an issue that causes division and suffering for many in our communities and I know you don’t want that. This community is hurting. We would appreciate removal of social media posts to date and please make no more social media posts or media appearances on this topic.”
Mr Davies responded to the email doubling down on his stance and arguing that nothing he had said on the issue was “untrue”.
He wrote: “Dear Sam, Thank you for your email. I note your comments. To be clear, I make no apologies for scrutinising the Welsh Government’s ‘Anti-Racist Wales Action Plan’.
“It is divisive and ideologically motivated, and as you will see from the media coverage over the past 24 hours, extremely counterproductive. For these reasons, I do not believe the report should have been commissioned.
“While I cannot speak for others, I am not aware of anything I have said on the matter that is untrue. As such, I will not be removing the posts, and will continue to comment on it. If there is anything else I can assist with, please let me know.”
‘Woke’
The most senior Tory in Wales then shared a further article to X, with the headline “Woke madness as govt-funded study says dogs should be banned from countryside over risk of offending minorities.”
Climate Cymru also wrote to Tory MS James Evans asking that he remove a Daily Mail article which he shared on X – but Mr Evans did not respond.
The Welsh Government says the suggestion there are plans to ban dogs from the countryside is “inaccurate and a complete misrepresentation” of the report.
Climate Cymru’s leader says he has also become a target for racist abuse despite being Caucasian after the Daily Mail published photos of him with a “summer tan”.
He said some social media users incorrectly suggested that he was from Pakistan – an assumption which has since spread online leading to him receiving emails and messages branding him a “F**king *aki.”
Mr Ward said: “The whole thing has been toxic and hopelessly misrepresenting the situation. Racism is an important issue that needs to be addressed, all citizens, but especailly communities affected need to able to share their experience and views – that shouldn’t be controversial or criticised.
“Nobody has claimed dogs or their owners are racist, or asked for them to be banned from the countryside and the Welsh Government have made it clear that dog-free zones suggestion just one of many comments from communities expressing their views and not a Welsh Government policy. It is clear that some people are being deliberatively misleading for personal gain and clicks.”
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
It is an odd comment in reply to a discussion about racism. There are advantages to dog free areas out of doors notably playing fields where fouling is a nasty problem both with dog and cat faeces. It is a non sequitur as far as a discussion on racism is concerned. With respect to allotments there should be reasonable provision by all councils and access should be granted on an agreed basis without regard to ethnicity or gender. It seems to me although I haven’t been able to read the document that the usual drift away from the main point… Read more »
I doubt they meant dog free areas specifically were going to tackle racism. It was probably an idea for creating new green spaces in/for communities like ethnic minorities who don’t have as much access to nature – the dog free thing was just an add-on to the increasing allotments idea
So many right wing outlets have taken it too far. And why don’t they link to the initial report? (It’s here, by the way). You are pretty much on the right lines, though.
Depressing that ART Davies is once again using the Trump playbook. What happened to respectable Conservative politicians.
They got kicked out by Johnson over an attempt not to go for a no deal Brexit at any cost, remember?
Under Johnson they were all either booted out or opted to stand down in despair.
Johnny Shell Shock! but don’t show this cretin any sympathy whatsoever if Ms Dodds has to go then by God this clumsy fool needs to…
ART”I am not racist but”D seems awfully good at stoking hate (see halal debacle). I assume this is the default tory approach then in Wales, vote Tory, get hate. Paint targets on peoples backs.
This his advisor doing this or was it Cap’n Tubthumpers idea.
No surprises from dog whistler Davies. Creating a culture war where there is none. I’m used to hearing farmers complaining about out of control dogs with livestock, and rightly so. No culture war there Andrew?
Why can’t the Welsh Tories come up with a better leader than this blathering brain-dead muppet? It isn’t as if they couldn’t scrape together an alternative out of their ranks – someone with a bit more political nous. I regret the departure of David Melding, but what’s done is done. Maybe Russell George, who strikes me as a fairly rational and sensible politician, might take on the role? Any government needs to have a sensible and thoughtful opposition to help keep it honest, and right now it’s the Tories who have the numbers in the Senedd to fulfil that role.… Read more »
It’s clear that Andrew RT Davies is a racist. Should he be able to continue targeting ordinary people from his well paid position? He is bringing Welsh democracy into disrepute and putting ordinary people in danger. He’s a disgrace!
Time the police had a word or three with him!
The nasty party at it again. And a sign our toxic tabloid media is pushing people to socially conservative views based on NOTHING. Again, the Welsh Conservatives showing they have no ideas for making people’s lives better – they just want to distract and stir up hate to get power. I hope most people can see through these bad faith headlines and smear tactics. Climate Cymru are decent people with a lot of well-researched, thoughtful policy suggestions.
Strange that Sam Ward who’s spent most of his career promoting his white mates flying out to do paddle boarding in Africa as MD of Kayak the Nile Ltd, arrives in Llanberis, and suddenly finds the earpiece of the Labour Welsh Government under the flag of Climate BAME.
Time to stop reporting this deplorable man, who will say anything to ensure the continued oxygen of attention.
I think most of us have long since reached the point where we resent his continued access to the oxygen of oxygen*.
*© Linda Smith
not a new tactic. I’ve seen similar done to a traveller community, where they were encouraged, during a local consultation, to provide a wishlist of all the things their ideal site would have. some of the worst elements of the Welsh local press got hold of it, and deliberately and maliciously misrepresented the wishlist as a list of demands. This is very much the same tactic, and it’s so depressing to see people fall for this kind of thing again and again, without questioning it. Artoo “blanket” davis is a sad, pathetic, inconsequential little man, with absolutely nothing to contribute,… Read more »
A Tory stirring up racism, hatred and using lies to stir up the hard of thinking??
Well, there’s a first.
Nation Cymru, why do you keep giving this absolute nobody news time? Some things are best just fading away.
I would like to see all beaches in Wales dog free. There is nothing more annoying than a constantly yapping dog that the owner is obviously deaf to, to ruin your day. Take them to a dog park where they belong & keep beaches quiet & dog faeces free.