Support our Nation today - please donate here

Braveheart’s Mel Gibson ‘helping to fuel calls for Scottish independence’ claims Tory MP

27 Oct 2022 5 minute read
Photo Scott Neeson is marked CC BY-SA 3.0

Calls for Scottish independence are being driven by “the likes of Mel Gibson”, MPs have heard.

The Hollywood actor starred in and directed the 1995 historical film epic Braveheart, retelling the story of William Wallace, a leader in the first war of Scottish independence in the late middle ages.

Conservative MP Giles Watling (Clacton) suggested Gibson was among those helping to put the Union at risk, adding there should not be another referendum before 2039.

The legality of whether the Scottish Parliament can legislate for a second referendum is currently being considered by the Supreme Court.

But Scotland’s First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has said in the event the Supreme Court rules against the Scottish Government over the proposed vote next October, then she will treat the next general election as a “de facto” referendum.

The UK Government has continually argued the 2014 independence vote was “once in a generation”.

Speaking at Cabinet Office questions, Mr Watling said he has been “fortunate enough to work in all four corners of this great Union”.


Mr Watling, previously an actor best-known for the sitcom Bread, told the Commons: “We have fought shoulder to shoulder for freedom and democracy all over the world, not least at Waterloo and the landing beaches of Normandy.

“Does he agree it would be foolish to let this great and successful Union fall apart on a whim, with the aid of the likes of Mel Gibson et cetera?

“Should there not be a legislative timeframe, say 25 years, before another referendum can be held?”

Cabinet Office minister Brendan Clarke-Smith replied: “People across Scotland want both of their Governments to be working together and focusing their attention and resources on the issues that matter to them and not talking about yet another independence referendum.”

The SNP said Prime Minister Rishi Sunak must “respect the mandate” the Scottish people gave last year.

SNP Cabinet Office spokesman Brendan O’Hara said the responsibility for the Union has become a “hot potato and something (to) be passed from department to department”.

He added: “My suggestion would be to the new Secretary of State that he uses this new responsibility to encourage the Prime Minister to respect the mandate that the Scottish people gave last year when they elected the pro-independence majority government with a commitment to holding a referendum.

“And would he agree, as my honourable friend has said, that a Prime Minister who was rejected by his own party members, but who was subsequently put into office, unelected by the members behind him, for them to then deny the wishes of the Scottish people in a free and fair election is an absolute disgrace?”


Mr Clarke-Smith replied: “There is still the mandate in Scotland from the independence referendum, we are very firm on that. And we will continue to support that and prioritise for the Scottish people and not to play politics and navel-gazing at this point in time.”

Labour also said the Government is treating the Union like a “departmental tennis ball”.

Shadow Cabinet Office minister Fleur Anderson said the Union “has gone to the Department for Levelling Up, it’s come back to the Cabinet Office, then it has gone back to the Department for Levelling Up and now we hear, it’s potentially staying there”.

She went on: “Does that really say priority for the Union? The former prime minister didn’t call the First Ministers of Scotland and Wales all the time she was in office and that says a lot.

“Will the minister please explain to the people of Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland why this Tory Government treats our Union like a departmental tennis ball?”

Mr Clarke-Smith said Mr Sunak telephoned the leaders of the Scottish and Welsh devolved governments “on his very first night in office”, adding: “In terms of departmental work, of course, the Cabinet Office is very important that we deal with constitutional elements of that.”


The SNP’s push for independence was later questioned by Penny Mordaunt, as she asked SNP Commons leader Deidre Brock how an independent Scotland would join the EU given it would have to adopt the euro.

At business questions, Ms Brock said: “If the new PM can claim yesterday a mandate to govern based on the Tory 2019 manifesto, why won’t he recognise the even clearer mandate for an independence referendum as laid out in multiple SNP manifestos and voted for by a clear majority of Scottish voters as legitimate?”

Ms Mordaunt said the Government does not acknowledge the mandate to have a second Scottish independence referendum “because, as I say every week, we have had one”.

She added: “But I know this is what I say to the honourable lady every week, so let me give her another reason.

“Because we learned today that for there to be an independent Scotland in Europe, Scotland would have to join the euro and if she can tell us how she intends to do that, then I’ll be happy to take her question again.”

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
George Atkinson
George Atkinson
1 year ago

He is citing a 30 year old film. Totally out of touch with the reality of the situation. Clown.

Y Tywysog Lloegr a Moscow
Y Tywysog Lloegr a Moscow
1 year ago

He had to go back 28 YEARS to claim a poor fillum made by an Australian is “fuelling” calls for Scottish freedom?
No wonder there’s so few Tories in Scotland.

Cathy Jones
Cathy Jones
1 year ago

A thirty-year-old massively inaccurate film by an Australian is the reason Scottish people want Independence?!!! Who the in the name of Pan’s pipes votes for these utter clowns?!

Dai Rob
Dai Rob
1 year ago

MP for Clacton, Essex.

1 year ago

Totally untrue about Scotland needing to use the Euro. That was taken from the newspaper that could not name anyone in the EU who was supposed to have said Scotland needs to agree to use the Euro before they can join. Just more Tory lies for the deluded to believe.

The Original Mark
The Original Mark
1 year ago
Reply to  Paul

Unfortunately, it’s not exactly a lie, but it isn’t the truth either, To quote,

“Politically, there would be substantial pressure on new member states to join the euro, not least as they would have joined the EU knowing eurozone membership was an expectation. Having said that, once countries have become EU member states there is no mechanism to force them to join the euro nor to sanction them if they fail to do so”.

So you could add Yet on the end?

1 year ago

It’s a weak union built on sand if Mel Gibson is succeeding in fatally undermining the UK!

Fi yn unig
Fi yn unig
1 year ago

He must have just found this movie on Netflix and thought he was watching a live event. This is the ‘calibre’ now folks I’m afraid. Dear oh dear oh dear.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.