Concern as private children’s homes shun children from Wales over not-for-profit plans
Richard Youle, local democracy reporter
Some private children’s residential homes are backing out from accepting children from Wales because the Welsh Government wants to eliminate profit from the system, a council officer said.
Chris Griffiths said the Welsh Government’s profit elimination plans were being “driven at pace”, and that new private providers would have to have not-for-profit status when registering a residential home from April 1 next year.
Mr Griffiths, Swansea’s principal officer for residential services, said existing providers would have to be not-for-profit by April 2027.
“This is already having a massive impact and immediate impact on what is already a challenging placement market,” he said at a child and family services scrutiny meeting.
Mr Griffiths said some providers were pausing or even withdrawing placement offers for Welsh children.
Research has indicated that young people in care don’t like being placed in settings which make a profit out of them. Welsh ministers are consulting on legislation which would eliminate the profit element from both residential care and fostering services.
Scrutiny panel member Cllr Cheryl Philpott said she could understand why young people who considered they were “being used basically as a cash cow” would feel this way.
Swansea Council has around 30 children and young people placed in residential care homes, three of whom are currently outside Wales. Around 10 are in Swansea, with the remainder in other parts of Wales. Councils have a duty to ensure placements are within their boundaries, unless it was not reasonably practical to do so or there were over-riding reasons for placing a child out of the area.
Swansea Council has four children’s residential care homes and is looking to expand that provision, although Mr Griffiths said this took time.
He added that it was a challenge to recruit staff to look after children and young people in such homes and that agency workers have had to be brought in to supplement its own staff. Agency workers, he added, tended to earn £3-4 per hour more, although the council was looking to re-grade the vacant posts to make them more competitive.
The meeting also heard the council was using private companies to look after some of its children in Swansea, but they were described as small local businesses rather than private equity firms.
Cllr Kevin Griffiths wanted to know if residential homes away from Swansea which looked after Swansea children were regulated and of the same standard as the ones used within its boundaries.
He was advised that they were regulated, and that a Swansea Council officer visited them quarterly, on top of any inspections from regulators.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
How disgusting of these homes wanting to profit from kids who’ve had difficult starts in life. People really are vile
It’s not disgusting – the practice is called capitalism or Toryism.
How many vulnerable children do you look after? Do you expect any of the hard working Foster Parents or social workers to do their work for free? Of course not. Looking after vulnerable and often traumatized children and young people is expensive and the initial investments in terms of building appropriate homes is enormous. If the Governments wants to take away an organisation’s ability to recoup such an investment, then the consequences are obvious to anyone with a basic understanding of maths.
There is no difference between care homes making money from the children and some people who adopt children just for money. Either the Welsh government will have to pay for the care homes, paid for from their magic money tree, or Welsh children will end up in English care homes.