Support our Nation today - please donate here
News

Councillor facing calls to quit after accusing Welsh Secretary of ‘whipping up anti-traveller feeling’

24 Aug 2023 5 minute read
Left: David TC Davies image by Victoria Jones. Right: Cllr Sara Burch

Twm OwenLocal Democracy Reporter

A senior councillor could face an investigation after she accused the Welsh secretary and another councillor of “whipping up anti-traveller feeling”.

Monmouthshire County Council has confirmed it has received “several complaints” over a social media comment made by Cllr Sara Burch, who is the Labour cabinet member with responsibility for the council’s ongoing search to find potential Gypsy Travller sites in the county.

Cllr Burch, the Labour cabinet member for inclusive and active communities whose responsibilities include housing, has said she “regrets” the statement, which she had posted to social media site Twitter, now known as X.

She had shared the comment with a post from the Travelling Ahead campaign group commemorating the Nazi holocaust of Roma and Sinti people.

A screen shot of post on X, by Cllr Sara Burch that is subject to complaints.

Deleted

In the now deleted post Cllr Burch accused Monmouth Conservative MP, and Welsh secretary, David TC Davies, and the leader of the council’s independent group, Magor West member Frances Taylor, of stocking anti-traveller prejudice.

It was posted as Cllr Taylor chaired a public meeting at Magor Baptist Church on August 2, attended by Mr Davies, called to discuss the county council’s ongoing consideration of a site Magor, at Langley Close and Dancing Hill in nearby Undy, as potential Gypsy Traveller sites. The cabinet is due to decide in September if it should put the sites forward for a public consultation on whether they should be listed in the replacement local development plan as suitable for potential Gypsy Traveller sites.

Sharing the tweet from Travelling Ahead Cymru, which marked August 2 as the anniversary of the murder of thousands of Roma and Sinti people held at the Auschwitz Concentration Camp, Cllr Burch added her own comments, stating: “Shameful that on this day @Frances4Magor and @DavidTCDavies were out whipping up anti-traveller feeling in #magorwithundy in advance of consultation about future sites.”

Mr Davies, who earlier this month learned he would face no police action over leaflets he had distributed during an earlier stage of the council’s consultation on potential Gypsy Traveller sites, defended the meeting.

He said: “If Cllr Burch had bothered to attend the meeting herself she would have found it to have been full of local people expressing legitimate concerns. There was certainly no ‘hate speech’.”

Complaints

Monmouthshire council’s Conservative group leader, Cllr Richard John, has called for Cllr Burch to either resign or be sacked from the Labour-led cabinet over what he called “baseless and malicious accusations”.

He said: “To link attendance at a public meeting with the extermination of thousands of Roma gypsies during the Holocaust is horrific, but to do so purely for narrow partisan interests is despicable.

“This tweet was grossly offensive and I think Cllr Burch’s position as a cabinet member leading the process of identifying Gypsy and Traveller sites is completely untenable. I think she should resign from her role or be sacked by her group leader and have the Labour whip withdrawn pending an investigation.”

Cllr John, who had also attended the public meeting, said the debate was led in a “professional and sensitive way”. The councillor, who earlier in the process had spoken against the possibility of sites in his Mitchell Troy and Trellech ward being included in the council’s plans, said the search for possible sites should be “conducted in a calm, measured and respectful way and focused on the suitability of sites, access and environmental concerns rather than prejudices”.

A spokesman for Monmouthshire County Council confirmed it had received “several complaints” about Cllr Burch’s post but said it cannot investigate members’ conduct and is instead referring people to the Public Service Ombudsman for Wales.

The spokesman said: “Several complaints have been received from members of the public about the social media post.

“The council cannot investigate complaints from members of the public about the actions/conduct of councillors.

“Complainants have been advised to forward their concerns directly to the Public Services Ombudsman for Wales who can act on such matters.”

Process

A spokeswoman for the Public Service Ombudsman for Wales said there is no current investigation and said: “We do not have an open investigation against Cllr Burch at this time.”

In a statement Cllr Burch, who represents the Cantref, Abergavenny ward, said: “I regret the tweet and have deleted it.

“As formal complaints have been made about it I face a due complaints process.

“Work is continuing on the selection of sites for public consultation as set out in my statement to cabinet and following the recommendations of the scrutiny committee.”

At the end of July Cllr Burch told the cabinet work to consider the two sites in Undy is ongoing, with a decision on whether to put the sites forward for public consultation due in September, while a council scutiny committee had recommended none of the sites that had been under consideration were suitable and the council short start over in its search.

The Local Democracy Reporting Service has contacted Cllr Taylor for comment.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Fi yn unig
Fi yn unig
7 months ago

TC has got away with leafleting to anger and by saying there was certainly no hate speech appears to be acting in a defensive way almost like he has something to hide. Meanwhile, Councillor Burch has correctly pointed out what he was doing and is now expected to retract and resign. This new right wing ‘free speech’ phenomenon is owned entirely by them and their rules dictate that everyone elses’ must be shut down.

Hogyn y Gogledd
Hogyn y Gogledd
7 months ago

Just go through the text of any leaflet which mentions “Travellers” or “Gypsies”, and substitute the word “Jews”.

I think you will quickly notice that which is racist.

Councillor Burch might not be my political friend, but DTC Davies is clearly my political enemy.

Leigh Richards
Leigh Richards
7 months ago

So a Councillor calls out prominent Welsh tories for dog whistle racism and yet she’s the one who’s facing calls to quit? Honestly you couldnt make it up.

Arthur Owen
Arthur Owen
7 months ago

I thought Dai TC loved this kind of forthright political debate.And indeed,perhaps he does.

Jeff
Jeff
7 months ago

Interesting. Con Group leader (and Cons) OK with the terrible comments on the leaflets but not OK with it being taken to task?

Fi yn unig
Fi yn unig
7 months ago
Reply to  Jeff

Exactly. ‘We, the far right racists own the new free speech phenomenon that you lefties are entirely excluded from’. Their grave error is calling us lefties. Their self bestowed ownership of the narrative has led them into a dead end. When they turn around to face the truth, they will find themselves on the wrong side of decency versus evil.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.