Support our Nation today - please donate here
News

David TC Davies accused of ‘failing in his duties’ on disused coal tips monitoring

01 Dec 2023 4 minute read
Welsh Secretary David TC Davies. Photo Jonathan Brady PA Images

Emily Price

Secretary of State for Wales David TC Davies is facing mounting criticism after it was revealed he failed to sign up to a joint letter with the Welsh Government regarding disused coal tips.

Last month the Welsh Government published the updated number of disused coal tips across Wales (2566) and the locations of all 350 tips with the potential to impact public safety.

Regular inspections monitor any maintenance works that may be required, and the Welsh Government has made available £44.4 million to local councils to carry out works on both public and privately owned tips.

During FMQs this week, Mark Drakeford accused the Conservative MP for Monmouth of not being a voice for Wales on issues such as money from HS2 and cash to make coal tips safe.

Committee

The First Minister said: “Had he been prepared to add his voice instead of refusing to sign letters alongside me as he agreed in the last meeting of the coal tip safety committee, maybe we would have had that money, but we don’t have a voice for us speaking up for Wales.”

Delyth Jewell MS, Plaid Cymru Spokesperson on Climate Change told Nation.Cymru she had queried why Mr Davies had not co-signed a letter regarding coal tip inspections and maintenance with the First Minister.

She said she was told that Secretary of State for Wales had co-chaired the coal tip safety summit for some considerable time.

The Plaid Cymru MS also said she received a letter sent by the First Minister to MSs and MPs which stated: “For the record, I should add that the original intention was for this letter to be sent jointly with the Secretary of State for Wales, as agreed and recorded at the coal tip summit, but he now prefers not to add his name.”

Ms Jewell said: “I am disappointed that the Secretary of State for Wales decided not to add his name to the Welsh Government’s recent letter, as had been agreed and recorded at the coal tip summit.

“Coal tips, of course, are a legacy of our nation’s industrial history – which predates devolution. The UK Government must bear some of these costs.

“With the likelihood that the costs will increase with the impact of climate change, and the potential to further destabilise these tips, it’s clear that this is far more than a safety issue: it is a matter of historical, social and climate justice.”

Duties

Plaid Cymru’s Westminster Leader Liz Saville Roberts MP has tabled a written question to the Secretary of State for Wales asking why he has not signed the joint letter from the Welsh Government.

Liz Saville Roberts said: “This is a clear failure by the Secretary of State to fulfil the duties expected of his office. What is the point of the office of the Secretary of State for Wales if he cannot stand up for Wales?

“The Secretary of State for Wales is once again showing that he is Westminster’s man in Wales, rather than Wales’s man in Westminster.

“This is yet another example of a broken Westminster system not working for Wales.”

Dangerous

During PMQs this week, Rishi Sunak was asked to fund the removal of potentially dangerous coal tips in Wales but instead shifted the topic to electrifying the North Wales Main Line.

Responding to Plaid Cymru’s comments, Mr Davies said: “As Welsh Secretary my number one priority is to stand up for the interests of Wales.

“Under the UK Conservative Government, Wales has received more than £1 billion in Levelling Up investment, in addition to other investments including £790 million in City and Growth Deals.

“As Plaid Cymru knows perfectly well, coal tips is a devolved matter, meaning it is the full responsibility of the Labour Welsh Government. Yet in response to Storm Dennis the Welsh Government received £31 million, of which £9 million was to repair vulnerable coal tips.

“In a recent meeting with the First Minister, I clearly said that I would await to see the content of the proposed letter. It may be the accepted norm for some governments and political parties to sign blank cheques without first knowing the details – but that is not what I do.

“My other role as Welsh Secretary is to hold the Labour Welsh Government – currently propped up by Plaid Cymru – to account.

“If Plaid Cymru thinks there needs to be more money for coal tips, then they need to re-think their support for the Welsh Government’s £120-million spending spree on creating more Members of the Senedd and £33 million on imposing a 20mph default speed limit.”


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
11 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dai Ponty
Dai Ponty
2 months ago

His Job as Welsh Sec in the London based government Tory Scum Party is to represent Wales he has never done anything other than knock Wales but he is a Member of Tory Party which is a English Nationalist Party and he only sees Wales as County of England if he is Welsh he is a Traitor to his country a Quisling like some people on here

Linda Jones
Linda Jones
2 months ago
Reply to  Dai Ponty

Mr Davies is English, born in Newham I believe.

Steve Duggan
Steve Duggan
2 months ago

Mr Davies is an extremely poor Secretary of State for Wales, always has been. When has he ever stood up for Wales? He sides with his master’s in Westminster constantly. It’s time the position was scrapped it doesn’t truly represent us.

Linda Jones
Linda Jones
2 months ago
Reply to  Steve Duggan

Unfortunately, with the exception of Plaid Cymru, all political parties in Wales are ruled from Westminster. Lapdogs

Annibendod
Annibendod
2 months ago

This individual has no moral authority to dictate to Wales’ Government how it should spend our money when his party has not won a national election in our nation since the inception of democracy! No mandate, no right to govern us … yet there he is sticking his oar in our business. Shameless.

Lord Custard
Lord Custard
2 months ago

The Tories spread the cost of decommissioning nuclear power plants across the UK. They should do the same with fixing the coal tips!

Peter
Peter
2 months ago

When documents signed at the beginning of Devolution, it was agreed by all involved that The new Welsh Government would have sole responsibility over certain matters. Transport, Education, NHS, etc, one of these matters was total responsibility for Welsh coal mines, working or redundant. For that sole responsibility the Senedd would receive a certain sum of money to run and pay for those responsibilities. A formula that was agreed at the time between Westminster and Wales. It appears now after some 25 years that the Welsh Government ( with money wasted on their pet projects ) continually request money from… Read more »

Pete Cuthbert
Pete Cuthbert
2 months ago
Reply to  Peter

One needs to remember that the London Tory Government’s Market Fundamentalist agenda has ensured that the regions and devolved governments get less and less money every year. This is an important plank of their policy so that they can blame local politicians when the money locally runs out. Whether the Government in Wales is ineffective is a moot point, but schemes like spreading representative democracy across Wales is an important democratic step forward. However, I appreciate that Tories hate democracy because it put their power at risk.

Steve Duggan
Steve Duggan
2 months ago
Reply to  Peter

Still there is no getting around the fact that the issue has gotten worse and the primary cause of the issue was coal extraction by the British government. Yes, the Welsh government is bound to contribute but the vast bulk of the cost has to be met by Westminster. Sadly, it will not do so until there is another disaster. It just shows the neglect and contempt for it has for us.

Frank
Frank
2 months ago

What a waste of air, space and wages this joke of a secretary is. Complete embarrassment. We’ve had some useless characters in the past but this one takes first prize.

Rob
Rob
2 months ago

Scrap the position of Welsh, Scottish and Northern Ireland secretary. They are unelected and accountable to the Prime Minister and not the people of Wales.
They are not Wales voice in Whitehall, but rather Whitehall’s voice over Wales.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.