Support our Nation today - please donate here
News

Devolution plans ‘about giving power from Westminster to local leaders’ – No 10

16 Dec 2024 6 minute read
Labour Party Party leader Sir Keir Starmer and deputy leader, Angela Rayner arrive at the Labour Party Conference in Liverpool. Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire

Downing Street has said devolution plans in England aim to give more powers to local leaders amid fears that scrapping district councils could deprive people of local representation.

A redesign of local governments, expected to see district councils scrapped and more elected regional mayors brought in, has sparked fears that powers will be taken away from local communities.

Some local authorities will close under Government plans for devolution which are due to be published in a White Paper on Monday.

“Waste”

No 10 said the plans were about “giving power from Westminster to local leaders” but also about tackling the “waste” from multiple layers of government.

Angela Rayner, the Housing, Communities and Local Government Secretary, has promised to make devolution the “default setting” under the plans.

The proposals include creating so-called strategic authorities across England to bring together councils in areas where people live and work.

The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government said this would help “to avoid duplication and give our cities and regions a bigger voice”.

A network of councils warned that plans to reorganise local authorities could create “mega councils”, while a think tank raised concerns about the risk of creating “mini Whitehalls” by focusing on strategic authorities and abolishing district councils.

“Inefficiencies”

Downing Street said the changes would give more powers to local areas, improve accountability and tackle waste.

“The plans that we’re setting out today are all about giving power from Westminster to local leaders to make sure that they’ve got the levers they need to drive growth, but it’s also about having the right structures at a local level in place that means that local areas are delivering services that people care about in an efficient manner,” the Prime Minister’s official spokesman said.

The devolution plans aim to tackle inefficiencies that result in multiple layers of government in some areas, he added.

“This will improve accountability. It will tackle waste. It will respond to an appetite for simpler structure, and it will result in better outcomes,” he said.

Local government minister Jim McMahon said that merging councils could save £2 billion as he confirmed in his morning media round that some local authorities would be closed or merged under the reorganisation.

There would be a statutory consultation before any authorities were changed, he said.

“If it’s a choice between £2 billion in the running cost of an organisation or £2 billion on frontline neighbourhood services, I would say that most of the public want that investment in the front line,” he told Good Morning Britain.

In areas with two-tier local governments, county council areas are subdivided into independent district councils. There are 164 district councils in England.

Concern

The District Councils Network warned of the risk of removing localised decision making.

“We’re concerned that any creation of mega councils will prove the opposite of devolution, taking powers away from local communities, depriving tens of millions of people of genuinely localised decision making and representation,” councillor Hannah Dalton, vice chairwoman of the network, said.

She said there was little evidence that such reorganisations had saved money in the past.

Simon Kaye, policy director at think tank Reform, said the White Paper was a “welcome start” but that strategic authorities needed wider powers, including the ability to raise taxes.

He added: “There is also a risk that plans to abolish district councils will leave local neighbourhoods feeling even more neglected. The result of reforms cannot be simply the creation of ‘mini Whitehalls’ at a regional level – communities need a real say.”

Mr McMahon said some local elections planned for May could be postponed for councils undergoing a process of reorganisation.

Local ballots scheduled for that month would only be delayed at the request of councils that wanted to reorganise under devolution plans “to the most ambitious timetable”, Downing Street said.

The assumption was that all elections would go ahead, Sir Keir Starmer’s spokesman said, but could not give a deadline for when councils would need to decide whether to hold a local election.

The devolution plans are to be unveiled after ministers warned they would be prepared to step in if proposals to build more prisons, wind turbines and homes met opposition at a local level.

The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government said Labour’s devolution policy would allow regional leaders to “guide” development projects “across areas, housing, transport and skills”.

England’s regions would be “centre stage” in the Government’s mission to grow the economy and build 1.5 million homes, Ms Rayner was expected to say in a speech on Monday to regional leaders.

Mr McMahon was asked about fears that urban mayors could force building targets on rural areas or that local people would be under-represented without district councils.

“The population still exists, communities still exist, and a council will still exist to run those services,” he told Good Morning Britain.

The changes were about “simplifying the system so that the accountability is strong”, he said, not to “diminish” the work that district councils and county councils had done in the past.

The County Councils Network said most of its members “recognise the need to embrace the benefits of mayoral devolution”.

The Conservatives accused the Labour Government of plans to “strip councils of their powers to make choices and to impose reorganisation from Westminster without local consent”.

A party spokesman said: “The Conservatives delivered over one million new homes in the last parliament, and whilst we recognise the need to build more, these must be in the right places.

“This new announcement will do nothing to solve that, and instead open up another front on Labour’s assault on the countryside.”

Westminster City Council said the White Paper would pave the way for mayors and transport authorities to get the powers to regulate e-bikes.

“It took 10 years to win the argument to devolve the power to regulate pedicabs, so I am glad this White Paper paves the way for mayors and transport authorities to get the powers they need to implement a sensible scheme for e-bikes rather sooner,” the council’s leader said.

The Local Government Association (LGA) said its members were “open to change” but that local government reorganisation should be a matter for councils and local areas to decide, adding that “devolution is not an end in itself” and cannot distract from severe funding pressures on local services.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

15 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jack
Jack
15 hours ago

Silly idea. ‘Devolution’ should only apply to ‘national’ bodies like Scotland and Wales. By applying it to bits of England the impact will be to lessen the meaning of the term and so lessen the importance of ‘devolved’ governments. For example, the argument that Wales should have the same powers as devolved Scotland will become lost when other devolved bodies, say a random bit of Essex, does not have the same powers as Wales and argues to have the powers of Wales. And so on. And I totally disagree with regional Mayors. We don’t have a Presidential system in this… Read more »

Bill
Bill
14 hours ago
Reply to  Jack

“..applying it to bits of England the impact will be to lessen the meaning of the term”

The term ‘England’ was only temporary anyway. A short-lived coalition of the willing to defeat the Danes.

Rob
Rob
13 hours ago
Reply to  Jack

That’s because Essex is a county and not a country. Its status is no different to that of Pembrokeshire, Gwynedd, Devon, Aberdeenshire or Wiltshire.

Wales, England and Scotland are countries not counties.

Egbert Atheltor
Egbert Atheltor
13 hours ago
Reply to  Rob

Wessex and Northumberland plus a few others are Anglo Saxon Kingdoms that may appreciate devolution.

Rob
Rob
11 hours ago

and the same may be true for Cornwall. But unless they breakaway from England then they are not countries and you cannot compare them to Wales or Scotland. Its like comparing Belgium with a region of France.

Last edited 11 hours ago by Rob
Adrian
Adrian
13 hours ago
Reply to  Jack

….and it’s hardly been a resounding success in Wales or Scotland has it?

robin campbell
robin campbell
12 hours ago
Reply to  Adrian

not while we’ve got a begging bowl culture as if we should be grateful to the UK government for our existence.

Rob
Rob
12 hours ago
Reply to  Adrian

blame Labour, not devolution

Owain Morgan
Owain Morgan
8 hours ago
Reply to  Rob

Blame the Tories and the rest of the British Establishment while you’re at it.

Rhosddu
Rhosddu
12 hours ago
Reply to  Jack

Nobody will be under the illusion that the devolving of a modicum of power to a county in England will be of the same stripe as devolution with a capital D, as it were, to a national parliament such as the Senedd or Holyrood. Any proposal in any member country of the UK that decentralises political power away from Westminster is likely to benefit the country or English region in question.

Erisian
Erisian
14 hours ago

Does Starmer mean England or “England-and-Wales” ?
Given how often the two are conflated, I think you might have made this clear.

Llyn
Llyn
14 hours ago

Will the Conservative Party be demanding a referendum, or does that only apply when powers are devolved to the Welsh Parliament?

Billy James
Billy James
13 hours ago

Even more politicians on £100,000 + salaries with their deputies not far behind in the pay stakes…

Llyn
Llyn
11 hours ago
Reply to  Billy James

The sees a whole tier of government disappearing so what evidence do you have that this will seeore politicians?

hdavies15
hdavies15
25 minutes ago
Reply to  Llyn

It’s the only growth industry in a post Reeves’ Budget UK.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.