Support our Nation today - please donate here

Drakeford calls for UK Government contribution to make dangerous coal tips safe

07 Nov 2023 3 minute read
Landslide at Llanwonno Tip in Tylorstown. Picture from RCT Council.

Chris Haines, ICNN Senedd reporter

The First Minister has called on the UK Government to pay for high-risk coal tips in Wales to be made safe.

Hefin David asked Mark Drakeford for an update on measures to safely restore coal tips during first minister’s questions on Tuesday November 7.

Dr David told the Senedd that three council-owned tips in his Caerphilly constituency are categorised as the highest risk.

“They’re not at risk of any imminent danger,” he stressed. “But they do need frequent inspection and the local authority has assured me that’s happening.”

The Labour backbencher asked how Welsh Government plans for a disused tip safety bill will support councils to remediate and restore at-risk coal tips.

Mark Drakeford told Senedd members that 40% of all disused coal tips in the UK are in Wales, with more than 2,500 due to the country’s industrial heritage.

Confirming that legislation will be brought forward next year, the first minister said: “The bill will set up a world-first new system of oversight of disused tips here in Wales, making the system fit for an era of climate change.

“Alongside that, and not dependent upon the bill itself, we go on investing £44 million provided to local authorities for the maintenance and remediation of coal tips.”

‘Living in fear’

Natasha Asghar, for the Conservatives, told the chamber that people near coal tips have been living in fear since a landslip in Tylorstown during a storm in 2020.

The South Wales East MS said the Welsh Government has received millions of pounds from the UK Government.

Mr Drakeford disputed the claim, saying: “The Welsh Government has not received millions of pounds for the UK Government for remediation – nothing of the sort.

“In fact, we remain in discussions with the UK Government about the contribution that we believe should rightly come to Wales for what is a legacy industry

“The difficulties that we are having to put right well predate devolution….

“We’ve made no progress at all with the UK Government with that argument so far, but we certainly continue to make it.”

Delyth Jewell, the Plaid Cymru MS for South Wales East, said the psychological toll of worrying about tips slipping in heavy rain weighs heavily on many people.

The party’s shadow minister for climate change and deputy leader said: “These coal tips are a legacy of the negligence and disdain of Westminster governments for our valleys – they need to pay to clear them.”


Mr Drakeford agreed, saying: “There is an obligation on the UK Government to assist in putting right the wrongs of the past.

“We don’t expect them to do it alone; the Welsh Government is already, as I said, making available £44.4m for these purposes.

“What we look to the Treasury to agree is a long-term programme, funded over a decade.

“We’re not expecting huge amounts of money in any one year, but, cumulatively, over a decade, we could begin with those tips where the risk is greatest.”

Asked by Dr David about the role of private companies, which may be able to remediate tips at a lower cost, Mr Drakeford said ministers do not have any objection.

He said private companies will need to follow the same processes as other organisations seeking to carry out remediation work, such as making a planning application.

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
23 days ago

I hope the government will make near to 100% contribution considering the coal was stolen.

Wynford Jones
Wynford Jones
23 days ago
Reply to  Frank

I hope that you mean the Westminster government. If so, I agree with you. It’s long overdue.

23 days ago
Reply to  Wynford Jones

Yes Wynford, I did mean Westminster.

Y Cymro
Y Cymro
23 days ago

Whitehall takes from Wales it never gives. First Minister Mark Drakeford must realise this and not be so bloody naive. Our innocient children in 1966 paid the ultimate price with Whitehall’s resource rape and no one responsible in government has ever been charged with any crime. There are literally hundreds of highly dangerous slurry heaps tettering above our valley communities awaiting the day when the hillsides vomit their contents once again drowning all in its path. Both the English Tories , and yes , their brother in arms, Labour care not. Remember, Tony Blair & Gordon Brown were in power… Read more »

Last edited 23 days ago by Y Cymro
23 days ago

These tips were created by a Westminster controlled and owned nationalised coal industry, ie the NCB, therefore they have a responsibility to clean up the mess, as it was they who profited from the coal that was extracted. I do not hold out any hope of them doing so, it always has been and will be , take but not give.

16 days ago
Reply to  Gareth

STUPID ill informed BS.

23 days ago

Where did the MS for London mayor get the numbers from?
It would be interesting to see the path the loot may or may not have taken.

Richard Davies
Richard Davies
22 days ago

Mark Drakeford is obviously correct, the coal waste tips pre-date devolution by many decades. Everyone in Wales knows how deadly they can be. It is about time westminster coughed up 100% of the cost to remove this stain on our beautiful country!

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.