England and Scotland urged to follow Wales on free primary school breakfast provision
The UK and Scottish governments are being urged to follow Wales’ example and place a duty on local authorities to fund free primary school breakfasts each school day.
Education charity Magic Breakfast said its research exposed a “patchwork” of provision, leading some children starting class too hungry to learn.
Wales is the only UK nation that places a duty on a local authority to provide free primary school breakfast each school day, according to a new report published today. The Welsh Government introduced its Free Breakfast Initiative in primary schools in 2004.
The Welsh Government is also moving to introduce universal free school meals at primary schools as part of a cooperation agreement with Plaid Cymru.
“41% of schools in Scotland, 27% of schools in Northern Ireland, 18% of schools in England and 7% of schools in Wales have no breakfast provision,” the report states.
“The higher level of breakfast provision in Wales highlights the important role governments can play in increasing levels of school breakfast provision.”
The report however also saw the need for improvement in Wales, saying that while council areas had to fund free breakfast provision there was no legal requirement for individual schools to operate a free breakfast service, and no requirement to fund secondary school breakfasts.
Magic Breakfast called for an urgent £75 million funding boost for school breakfasts in England, and similar investments from the Scottish Government to level up education and reach those children and young people at risk of hunger.
Ruth Perry, head of school at Newall Green Primary School in Wythenshawe, Manchester, said: “There is a cost-of-living crisis affecting parents and if we didn’t have a Magic Breakfast in the morning, some children would be starting class hungry.
“Instead, pupils begin the day with a free, healthy breakfast and are better prepared to learn. My staff and I have seen the difference it can make.”
Lindsey MacDonald, chief executive of Magic Breakfast, said: “Our Hidden Hunger report exposes the lottery of school breakfast funding and provision in the UK and the impact that this has on children’s learning and life chances.
“As pupils struggle to catch up on lost learning and the cost-of-living crisis takes hold, Magic Breakfast is asking the Scottish and UK governments to implement meaningful funding for breakfast food, staffing, and support.
“This has been proven to drastically improve long term opportunities for future generations and increase the economic health of our nation.”
The report used data held by local authorities across the country, via a series of Freedom of Information requests, alongside survey data provided directly from schools.
Alison Garnham, chief executive of Child Poverty Action Group, commented: “Parents tell us breakfast clubs can be an essential means of family support, and a lifeline in hard times, but the research is clear, far too many children in poverty simply can’t access and benefit from these clubs – with serious consequences for their school day.
“Schools, local authorities and governments must work together to ensure that breakfast provision is available freely to any child that needs it, wherever they go to school.”
Paul Whiteman, general secretary of school leaders’ union NAHT, said: “We agree that more funding is urgently needed to combat child hunger and that improving breakfast club provision for pupils could be an important part of that effort.
“Hunger is a real concern for school staff who regularly see children arriving in the morning without having eaten, and therefore not ready to learn. These concerns have only been exacerbated by the pandemic and the financial impact it has had on many families. We know that some children rely on school for their only certain meal of the day.
“Many schools already run breakfast clubs for their pupils and often look to target that support for the pupils that need it most. But there are huge challenges facing schools in providing enough places. Capacity, staffing, availability of space and school transport are all issues, and the government needs to recognise that these all come at an additional cost.”
A UK Government Department for Education spokesperson said: “We are committed to supporting children and young people from disadvantaged backgrounds to access nutritious school food. That’s why we are investing up to £24 million in the National School Breakfast Programme, which will reach up to 2,500 schools.
“We have recently expanded eligibility of the programme to reach more schools and children in disadvantaged areas, as well as expanding eligibility to free school meals more than any other government in recent decades.”
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
The policy of free primary school breakfast should be adopted by both Scotland & England as it’s not only an aid to learning but sadly in some cases a meal a child wouldn’t normally have for various reasons.
I can recall in the 70s fellow pupils attending school literally starving due to poverty, and in some cases neglect. And there was a cynical policy in those days of giving free school meal tickets to that were a different colour to the normal tickets stigmatising the children who qualified. Thankfully this policy isn’t the same. All receive breakfast whatever means.
Must have gone to school at the same time. What always shocked me was that there seemed to be nothing in place over the holidays.
As you know the Pre-Devolution era of the 1970s was a time where Whitehall controlled our school system and when the Conservatives stopped milk for children. I remember it well. Hence the saying. Maggie Thatcher, milk snatcher. But Labour were as culpable. I found the six week period over the summer holidays initially a release but it must have been hell for those children living in poverty or suffering neglect, especially regarding food. Can’t imagine what they went through until the holidays ended in September and they returned to back to school. Personally speaking. Thankfully my parents were hardworking decent… Read more »
Westminster would never follow good ideas from Cymru. Boris will no doubt react with a Great British Free Breakfast provision which involves councils having to pay private companies to give minimum viable high fat low quality nutritional paste and then recovering the costs directly from the parents.