Support our Nation today - please donate here
News

England is ‘out of step’ with Wales on Covid rules, public health expert suggests

29 Dec 2021 3 minute read
Prime Minister Boris Johnson (left) in yesterday’s speech broadcast on BBC One. Mark Drakeford (right), picture by the Welsh Government.

A public health expert has suggested that it is England that is “out of step” with Wales on Covid rules.

Professor Andrew Watterson, of the faculty of health sciences at the University of Stirling, has criticised Boris Johnson’s government for not tightening restrictions despite coronavirus case rates surging in the country.

The scientist pointed to England having the highest seven-day positivity rate of any country in the UK and said “one would have expected a more precautionary and preventative approach”.

He also suggested that the governments of Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland tightened restrictions because they have looked at the “evidence”.

After he was asked what he thought of the Government’s approach, the professor laughed and said: “The Government in England, you mean?”

He added: “They really are out of step. If we’re looking at evidence about transmission, which is clearly what Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland did, they’ve come to very different conclusions about what the risks are and what the figures are telling us.

“England has the highest seven-day positivity rate just before Christmas across the whole of the UK. And therefore one would have expected a more precautionary and preventative approach.

“But that’s not what we have seen. So I think there’s a real mismatch between some of the data … and what is happening in terms of policy and prevention.”

‘Hospitalisations’

The interviewer then suggested that the surge in Omicron causes is not leading to the same number of hospitalisations as other waves of Covid, adding: “Hence, perhaps, their reluctance to take measures that would be very restrictive on day-to-day life and economically, if it’s not merited by the hospitalisation numbers.

The professor replied: “Yes. But the hospitalisation numbers are rising. And there is the issue then about how Omicron might affect the various people who provide the service. So it’s not just hospitalisation. It’s about the people there who are going to care for those who are ill.”

He added that a large number of people self-isolating is causing problems for the haulage sector, transport industry, retail and as well as other areas.

When it was suggested to him that divergence between England and the other nations might cause people in Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland to be less compliant, the professor argued the opposite may also be true.

“People in England may say well why in the other three countries are they taking these actions.

“But mixed messaging is a really big issue. What we’ve heard from the Government in England is ‘well be careful and open a few windows’. Well that’s not very good messaging … so I think there’s a real problem across the UK now about muddled messaging primarily created, I think, in England.”


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Steve Duggan
Steve Duggan
7 months ago

I fear come January Omicron is going to explode, particularly in England. What happens in England affects Wales – the border is porous, there will be more hospitalisations and deaths here too as a result. If the situation really does get out of control across the border – we must shut it! Lives first.

j humphrys
j humphrys
7 months ago

You can see the BBC interview on Maximillian Rosepierre’s You Tube site.
Worth watching, as are the comments from English people.

George
George
7 months ago

At the moment England’s gamble appears to be paying off because of the protection of the vaccine with hospital admissions being considered manageable. I hope people in England realise there was a big gamble taken with their health when scientists and health workers were asking for risk to be managed instead but that they also realise, on basis that opposite outcome is horrific, we’re all hoping that no harm comes from that gamble.

Y Cymro
Y Cymro
7 months ago

It’s well known the Tories are allowing England to celebrate New Year’s Eve mainly appease the far-right wing of the Conservative party. ERG and to gain favour with the public after Covid controversies with the likelihood tougher restrictions will come into affect in England in January 2022. It money over morality. Also, Boris Johnson assumes because the Omicron variant is less likely to kill although more infectious, and seeing millions are triple vaccinated in England, will not be a problem. But he forgets, other variants are still out there, you can catch & carry Covid even though triple vaccinated, and… Read more »

Last edited 7 months ago by Y Cymro
Brian Coman
Brian Coman
7 months ago

Drakeford apparently is a Unionist and a Corbynist who detest Plaid, calling their policies’ Voodoo’ like.. Plaid finds Labour anti-Welsh. They have joined parties on certain issues. All Plaid have is a couple of more questions at debates with no ministerial positions. It is now illegal to take part in charity swims , park runs and could be fined for going to work . Measures are brought forward and leaked overnight. People in Cardiff for example will be able to see the fireworks in Weston Super Mare on NYE, while they stay in a very sad city after Xmas ,and… Read more »

Charles Coombes
Charles Coombes
7 months ago

Being out of step is a good thing.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.