Support our Nation today - please donate here

‘Gaping black hole’ in wind farm proposal says Welsh rural campaign group

28 Oct 2022 3 minute read
Image by Steve from Pixabay.

A rural campaign group is calling on developers to provide details on how it plans to connect a 36-turbine wind farm proposal in mid Wales to the National Grid.

Developer Bute Energy is proposing to construct a wind farm of 36 wind turbines, each 220m high, at the ‘Nant Mithil Energy Park’ which stretches across Radnor Forest, but The Campaign for the Protection of Rural Wales (CPRW) says it gives little detail of how it plans to connect the proposal to the National Grid. 

CPRW claims it would require a huge new infrastructure development of electricity pylons and cables that would stretch across the border and into England. 

Following two public meetings and one online webinar from Bute Energy, CPRW has said it and many members of the public have been left with more questions than answers.

“Several questions put to Bute Energy by CPRW and members of the public at their consultation meetings simply could not be answered.

“Huge questions about how Bute were planning on ever connecting this proposed development to the national grid simply were not answered.” 

CPRW added: “With the closest viable connection point to the National Grid being across the border in England, the transmission cables and pylons needed would stretch across the landscape.

“How can people give their honest opinion on this development when they have only been shown a small element in isolation? There is a gaping black hole in this proposal which needs to be filled.

“CPRW is calling for Bute Energy to disclose to the public the full scale of this development, including the massive project to connect it to the National Grid.”

‘Crossing needed’

At the public meeting the developers also confirmed that a new crossing across the River Wye would be required to transport the huge turbine blades to the site but could not say how big, what materials or whether this bridge would be permanent or temporary, CPRW has said.

“There are much more questions than answers over the Nant Mithil proposal and I urge the public to let their thoughts know about this before it goes any further,” added the CPRW Spokesperson.

Bute Energy have said that the consultation on Nant Mithil closes for public feedback on 31 October.


Responding, Bute Energy said: “Bute Energy is acting now to deliver clean green energy for Wales, and empower our communities through investment, jobs and skills.  We recently presented our early stage proposals for the Nant Mithil Energy Park, which is the start of a year-long period of consultation and refinement of the project, and we’re grateful for the constructive responses and feedback from the local community.

“As we said in our consultation, the proposed grid connection is currently being developed and will be its own separate Development of National Significance (DNS) planning application.  A preferred route option will be brought forward for public and stakeholder consultation in early 2023.

“At the recent consultation we presented an overview of the project and our outline plans – including the transportation of equipment and materials to site.

“We are currently assessing the feedback we have received from the public and are waiting for responses from statutory stakeholders, such as Powys County Council, to our request for an Environmental Impact Assessment Scoping Direction and pre-application advice.

“We will be presenting a detailed plan as part of a further public consultation next year before we make a full draft of our detailed planning application available for inspection and comment prior to submission later next year.”


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kerry Davies
Kerry Davies
1 year ago

Where on earth are these blades coming from if they need a new crossing of the Wye which lies miles to the west?
Since Wales has no need of this power and it is purely for the benefit of England could they not shift these nearer to the need and put them on Mortimer Forest?

Last edited 1 year ago by Kerry Davies
Peter Cuthbert
Peter Cuthbert
1 year ago
Reply to  Kerry Davies

A quick Google suggests that Inverness and the Isle of Wight are locations that make turbine blades. However, if all this power is for England why don’t they up sticks and build it there. The Worcestrhire Beacon and North Hill (just west of Malvern) look to be ideal windy locations and not currently developed. It is only 5 miles NW to the National Grid, or 7 miles due west or 9 miles due east according to the OS map

George Herraghty
George Herraghty
1 year ago

Since when did the industrial scale slaughter of Birds and Bats, by the million, become ‘Clean Green’ energy? Every year in Spain alone — according to research by the conservation group SEO/Birdlife — between 6 and 18 million, yes million, birds and bats are killed by wind farms. They kill roughly twice as many bats as birds. The Tasmanian Wedge-tailed Eagle is at the point of extinction due to wind farms. Recent research from around the world indicates horrific bird mortality rates:- Spain      – 330 Birds per turbine per year Germany – 309 Birds per turbine per year Sweden –  895 Birds… Read more »

1 year ago

The environmental harm caused by this so called green solution is alarming of itself, and that’s before we factor in the muck generated in the manufacture of the towers, hubs/mechanisms and blades. Then you get the wholesale ripping up of landscapes to create access routes, bases and other infrastructure. And the consumption of oils and other materials to keep these turbines working. Not an equation that makes much sense unless blinded by the light.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.