Support our Nation today - please donate here

Only a fifth of children answering survey are full after school dinner

25 Apr 2024 4 minute read
Students eating at school. Picture by Ben Birchall / PA Wire.

Only 19% of children taking part in a survey about school dinners said they are full after their meal, and almost half (44%) said they can’t have more food (seconds) if they ask for it.

The Children’s Commissioner for Wales, Rocio Cifuentes, who conducted the survey with schools across Wales, called the findings ‘an important snapshot of children’s views on a vital aspect of their lives’. She called on the Welsh Government to listen to children as they review current school dinner guidelines.

On nutrition, almost a quarter (24%) of children said they can’t always have vegetables if they want them, and 22% said they can’t always have fruit if they want it.


490 children and young people aged between 7 and 18 answered the survey individually. A further 1250 children took part in groups, with teachers and youth workers submitting a summary of their views. These submissions supported the views shared by children directly.

When asked for their ideas on making school dinners better, by far the most common answer amongst children related to wanting more food.

Commenting on the findings, the Children’s Commissioner said: ‘We know that so many children rely on this meal as their most important source of energy and nutrition because working families are struggling to put food on the table at home.

“I’ve heard concerns anecdotally about portion sizes being too small for lots of children, and these survey results confirm those concerns.

“In the current societal context, it feels more important than ever that the main meal children are having in school gives them the energy and the nutrients they need to grow, to play, and to learn.”


The Children’s Commissioner continued: ‘The Welsh Government have said that they’re reviewing the guidance and regulations behind school meals. This snapshot of children’s views gives a very strong indication to them that the guidance needs to change.

“It should be a priority for the Welsh Government to take this forward and to make sure they keep listening to children and young people’s views as part of their work. I’ve also shared children’s views with councils so they can reflect on these strong messages.’ 

‘The universal free school meals policy is fantastic, but it has to meet children’s needs in order to fulfil its full potential. 

“The Government recognise that for many,  this may be their only hot or substantial meal of the day, so we have to get this right and make sure that this significant investment by the Government is having the most positive effect possible on children’s lives.

“For us to do that, we have to listen to what children across Wales have told us. This isn’t just about right to good food, but to healthy development, access to education, and mitigating the impacts of child poverty too.’

Quotes from children

“It doesn’t full you up. It’s dry and they don’t give seconds.” – 11-year-old 

“Ni’n gael yr un peth a’r babanod” / “We have the same thing as the little ones.” – 10-year-old 

“We get the same amount of food as year 1 and it doesnt fill us up i always feel hungry after eating.”- 11-year-old 

Quotes from teachers

The group felt that there wasn’t enough choice of school dinners and that portion sizes were small. They were often left hungry.”

“Hoffwn i weld plant Blwyddyn 6 yn cael prydiau sy’n fwy o faint gan ei bod nhw’n cael yr un maint a phlant Derbyn a Blwyddyn1. Mae nifer o blant dal yn llwglyd ar ôl cinio.” / “I’d like to see Year 6 children having bigger portions because they have the same portion as children in Reception and Year 1. Lots of children are still hungry after dinner.”

“Prin dim llysiau bellach. Fel arfer, yr unig lysieuyn yw sweetcorn am nad oes angen coginio hwnnw.” / “There are almost no vegetables any more. Normally, the only vegetable is sweetcorn because it doesn’t need to be cooked.”

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Linda Jones
Linda Jones
1 month ago

Yes the meals are pretty paltry and often without much nutritional value.

1 month ago

That’s commonly because they’ve been fed refined carbohydrate in the form of bread or a sugary drink which raises the blood sugar which then suppresses the satiety hormone leptin. Raised blood sugar also promotes the realease of the hunger hormone ghrelin.

1 month ago

Meat and 2 or 3 fresh veg. None of the crap they might get at home. Destroy the myth of cheaper convenience foods.

Simone Davies
Simone Davies
29 days ago
Reply to  hdavies15

If an 11 year old asks for more food they should have it. If it’s not junk food it’s ok. It must be awful to be hungry in school.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.