Support our Nation today - please donate here

Outgoing police and crime commissioner calls for devolution of policing and justice to Wales

07 May 2024 2 minute read
Jane Mudd and Jeff Cuthbert Credit LDRS

Nicholas Thomas, local democracy reporter

As Wales marks 25 years of devolution this week, the man stepping down as a police and crime commissioner has renewed calls for Westminster to hand over responsibilities for policing and justice.

Jeff Cuthbert, who spent 13 years as a then-Assembly Member before taking up the Gwent PCC role, said the devolution of the justice system is “the right way to go”.

Scotland and Northern Ireland already have powers to control policing and justice, but in Wales these responsibilities have not been devolved and remain in Westminster’s hands.


Mr Cuthbert said that devolving justice would help policing decision-makers “engage more directly with our partners” in other areas of government.

He said this is something “we do quite well now” but “can be far better-coordinated with health, with local government, and other major players if we’re all under the one roof”.

Mr Cuthbert added: “Policing is devolved to Scotland and Northern Ireland, to London, and places like Manchester – so why not to the functioning Welsh Government as well?

“It seems to make sense to me.”

Silk Commission

The UK Government set up the Silk Commission in 2011 to review devolution in Wales, and despite the commission’s recommendations to devolve policing and youth justice by 2017 – and reviewing the wider justice system by 2025 – no new legislation has come forward.

Jane Mudd last week won the election to succeed Mr Cuthbert, who is retiring, as Gwent’s PCC – whose job it is to hold the local police force to account.

She suggested the devolution of justice is something which could happen if there is a change of government in Westminster.

“We know that if we have a new Labour government, they’ve been very keen to explore that and explore particularly the devolution of youth justice and probation,” said Cllr Mudd, who currently leads Newport City Council.

“So we’ll see how that goes, and I’m sure we will have that Labour government,” she added.

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
15 days ago

Just sounds like the Liberals who come out with great ideas once they’ve left the office they held for years 🥲..,,

Mr Williams
Mr Williams
15 days ago

I hope he manages to persuade the UK Labour Party, including some Welsh Labour MPs, who for some strange reason are of the mindset that our nation is not capable / worthy of running our own justice system.

Gwyn Hopkins
Gwyn Hopkins
15 days ago

The governments of Scotland, Northern Ireland, London and Manchester control their own police force but not Wales. Moreover, unlike Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland also control their own justice system. These are just two of the many examples of blatant discriminations against Wales perpetrated by successive UK governments. It is glaringly obvious that the only equitable and reasonable solution is to standardize devolution across Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales to that enjoyed by Scotland (at least). How about Welsh Labour pressurizing the next Labour government to do just that?   

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.