Oxfam axe volunteers in bitter fallout over alleged anti-Welsh language tirade
Oxfam has axed volunteers in the bitter fallout of a two-year feud, which began with an alleged anti-Welsh tirade by a charity shop staff member.
Retired couple Susan and Paul Baker, who volunteered at the store in Hay-on-Wye, are the latest volunteers to be dismissed from their roles, according to The Times.
This is the latest episode in a saga that began in March 2019, in the Welsh border town, when Eifion Williams, 48, from Wrexham, claimed on Twitter that a member of staff told his family to leave the shop because they were conversing in the language.
He said: “a man behind the till” told his family to “get out of the shop and stop speaking that bloody foreign language”.
Oxfam responded by issuing an apology and suspending Vaughan Evans, a part-time manager at the store, and then promptly closed the shop, even changing the locks.
At the time of the incident, Rachel Cable, Head of Oxfam Cymru, said: “We are concerned by reports that a member of Oxfam’s team in the Oxfam shop in Hay-on-Wye made an unacceptable comment about the Welsh language.
“We are very sorry for any offence that this has caused. The alleged remark does not reflect Oxfam’s values and we take allegations of this nature very seriously.
“We strive to ensure that inclusivity and diversity are at the heart of our approach wherever we work in the world, including here in Wales.
“We are now looking into this matter with the utmost urgency.”
The Minister for the Welsh Language, at the time Eluned Morgan, said she was “extremely disappointed” to hear of the incident and added that “steps need to be taken to ensure this doesn’t happen again”.
Evans denied making the remarks about the Welsh language, and the incident was investigated. Though disciplinary hearing concluded that the allegations could not be substantiated, he was not reinstated to his post.
This prompted a stand-off between volunteers who wanted their manager reinstated and Oxfam bosses, who did not.
The feud reached boiling point when Danny Sriskandarajah, Oxfam’s chief executive, personally travelled to the town amid support from senior figures within the annual Hay-on-Wye book festival.
Sriskandrajah apologised for the “pain and hurt” the closure of the shop had caused and said that the suspension “should have been handled better.”
The store then prepared to reopen to the public in February 2020 under new management, but before they were allowed return to the shop, volunteers had to to take training courses, which included suggestions such as greeting customers in Welsh.
According to Juliet Lewis, 66, a volunteer for 15 years at the store, she and other volunteers had to watch a video of cartoon bears hugging to help them understand empathy.
She told The Times that she was told to change the name of her ‘oxfambookshay’ Instagram account, as well as delete posts that could be seen as “detrimental” to the charity. These included posts criticising Oxfam’s use of plastic packaging.
One also featured an illustration from a book, which was for sale in the shop, by the renowned classicist Professor Mary Beard, portraying an ancient Greek figure balancing a wine goblet on his erect penis.
Sacks of items donated by the public were thrown out, as the shop prepared to reopen. It is claimed that this went against conflict resolution agreements with volunteers, who say they’d been told they’d be consulted on the lay out and running of the shop.
They say this also went against the way volunteers were already doing things by concentrating their efforts on selling donated items and second-hand books. This did not fit with the charity’s desire to market its range of “Sourced by Oxfam” ethically produced items.
Lewis and other volunteers protested against the changes, and new rules which meant they had to to sign up to Oxfam policies, which they said they had never seen, and this led the charity to withdraw their invitations to volunteer.
Susan and Paul Baker were the latest in a line of volunteers to be dismissed, and their appeals to resolve outstanding issues were rejected by the charity.
Volunteers are also still angry about how the initial claims from 2019 around remarks about the Welsh language were handled.
Juliet Lewis added: “As far as the world is concerned, we’re all still racists and that rankles — they didn’t stand up for us, they didn’t have our backs.”
Oxfam confirmed that four volunteers were dismissed from their roles, with a spokesperson telling The Times: “We were disappointed that, despite extensive efforts by both Oxfam and the volunteers, including undertaking mediation, it has proved impossible to resolve the situation in any other way.
“The four volunteers felt that they were unable to accept the ways of working which are standard across our shop network or commit to fully uphold our values.
“The shop reopened this year following lockdown, bringing in some new volunteers to work with the remaining dedicated and committed team.
“We acted swiftly to investigate allegations that a member of staff at the Hay-on-Wye shop had made unacceptable comments. Given the serious nature of the alleged comment we believed the right thing to do was to apologise immediately to anyone who may have been offended, pending a further investigation.”
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Charity shop volunteers can sometimes be a bit intimidating
If he’d spoken to me like that I’d be doing jail time.
Anti-Welsh comments have no place anywhere.
I live there and until they changed the supercilious and unfriendly volunteer staff wouldn’t go near the place. They were particularly snooty and appeared to think they were doing customers a favour.
This story brought the Daily Fail out in a nasty anti Welsh rash. Does its usual act of supporting the underdog against the tyranny of putting up with spoken Welsh in public places.
Oxfam charity shops lost the plot years ago. I no longer visit them.
They don’t actualy like less well off people hoping for a bargain.
Just for the record, the accused man is Welsh himself, I am English and my husband is half Welsh with close Welsh speaking family. My son learned Welsh at school. None of our now ex team at the Oxfam shop are anti-Welsh or anti Welsh language – that is just such an absurd accusation. Whatever that guy thought he heard, he OVERheard anyway – as the conversation in question had not even been with him! Nobody checked or said anything to us – oh how a single tweet can get you attention!! Oxfam was scared into an apology because they… Read more »
Juliet, I’m sorry to break the news to you but he did say ‘get out of the shop and stop speaking that bloody foreign language’. These were the EXACT words he used to my family. The EXACT words.
According to the report, your claim could not be substantiated. Were you invited to give evidence to the inquiry? Your tweet gives the impression that the man ordered your family out of the shop because they were speaking Welsh. Is that what happened? Or did he have some other reason to tell your family to get out of the shop and added the bit about “bloody foreign language” as an extra insult? Or did he just randomly pick on your family, to order them out of the shop and insult their language as well?