Support our Nation today - please donate here

Praise for basic income pilot for care leavers

25 Oct 2023 3 minute read
Care leavers on the basic income pilot.

Minister for Social Justice and Chief Whip Jane Hutt has praised the progress and uptake of the basic income pilot scheme after meeting care leavers taking part in the programme.

The Basic Income for Care Leavers in Wales pilot provided care leavers turning 18 between 01 July 2022 and 30 June 2023 with the opportunity to receive £1,600 (before tax) per month for a period of two years.

During the 12-month enrolment period, which ended on 30 June this year, 635 young people leaving care in Wales joined the pilot.

The provisional uptake rate of 97% is higher than that of other opt-in basic income schemes worldwide.

The scheme has been heavily criticised by the Welsh Conservatives for allowing unaccompanied asylum seeking children to be eligible for the payments.

A Welsh Government source said the number of young asylum seekers leaving care every year is “a very small proportion of those taking part in the pilot”.

An evaluation of the programme  will now get underway to consider how the pilot has been implemented and what the effects and cost of it have been.

Following analysis of these aspects, there are plans for a series of thematic reports to be published over the course of the four-year research programme.

It is expected to be several years before the evaluation will be completed.

This is due to the fact the research plan will track the impact of the pilot on their lives now, as well as the next few years as they continue into adulthood.


Minister for Social Justice and Chief Whip Jane Hutt, who attended a basic income pilot scheme event at the Future Inn in Cardiff on Wednesday (October 25), along with the First Minister and Deputy Minister for Social Services, said the early feedback from speaking to those taking part in the pilot scheme was positive, but it would take years for the impact and outcomes on the cohort to be fully assessed.

“We have heard fantastic feedback so far from those enrolled and are delighted with the record-breaking uptake, but we are still at the early stages of the pilot scheme and it will take years for the true impact on their lives to be assessed,” she said.

“It has been a pleasure to meet many people who have benefitted from the Basic Income for care leavers in Wales pilot scheme today and hear from them the differences the payments are making to their lives now and their future plans.

“We are now focusing our efforts on supporting young people with their transition off the pilot and learning about the affect it has had on their lives.”

Deputy Minister for Social Services Julie Morgan, speaking at the event taking place during Care Leavers Week, said: “The Welsh Government is committed to supporting care leavers as they make the difficult transition into adulthood.

“We understand it will take time to see the impact the pilot scheme will have had on those on it, but we are optimistic we will see the positive differences it has made to their lives and the opportunities it has presented to them that they would otherwise not have been able to enjoy.”

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Padi Phillips
Padi Phillips
7 months ago

It’s great that these young people are benefitting from this trial, but as a UBI pilot it will be of extremely limited value as it will only yield data about a very narrow group of people.

Any real trial of a UBI programme would need to have a far wider variety of participants in order to yield findings more representative of the population as a whole.

Tory criticisms about the inclusion of unaccompanied asylum seeking children is just the usual xenophobic claptrap we’ve come to expect, so can be safely ignored.

Dr John Ball
Dr John Ball
7 months ago

I’m all for helping young people, especially those in, or leaving care. I’m also very much in favour of a Universal Basic Income, but any experiment that addresses its use must be constructed carefully and its effects analysed even more carefully. Every UBI experiment everywhere in the world ( and there have been many) has been based on a ransom sample of beneficiaries drawn from across the population. young, old, working, unemployed et al to glean a picture of the effect the payment had on the recipients life. Sadly, this scheme is more an experiment dreamed up by academic sociologists… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.