Support our Nation today - please donate here

Revolutionary shake-up of Welsh local government could change the way you vote

19 Jul 2017 4 minute read
Picture by Llinos Dafydd


Lowering the voting age to 16, allowing prisoners to vote and a Scottish-style voting system are just some of the radical proposals the government is consulting on.

Sam Coates looks at the raft of changes to how voting in elections to Wales’ councils could work.


Voting reform

Following years of debate, Local Government Minister Mark Drakeford is proposing a shakeup of the voting system for Welsh councils that could have significant implications for the which political parties dominate local government.

Drakeford is proposing allowing councils to adopt the Single Transferable Vote, the voting system currently used in Scottish council elections as well as the Northern Ireland Assembly.

However, two-thirds of councillors on an authority must back a change, making the prospect of any Councils embracing the system appear remote following the elections of May this year.

Labour councils are expected to resist the change whilst rural authorities with a different party make-up are likely to be cautious of creating geographically larger wards that are the consequence of the proportional voting system.

The change in Scotland was part of a deal with the Liberal Democrats to keep Labour in power in Holyrood a decade ago and ended an era of Labour dominance of councils.

With sole Liberal Democrat AM Kirsty Williams serving in the Cabinet, the change could be viewed as an attempt to shore up the Education Secretary’s support for the government.

The Welsh Assembly was recently given the powers to decide its own electoral arrangements and greater powers over local government.

Extending the vote

The consultation also proposes a radical extension of the franchise, including being the first country in the UK to allow all residents to vote regardless of nationality.

16 and 17-year-olds are set to be given the vote for council elections and the minister is also ‘testing public opinion’ on attitudes to giving votes to prisoners.

The European Court of Human Rights has challenged the current blanket ban on prisoner voting, but this was yesterday rejected by Conservative Leader Andrew RT Davies.

Making voting easier

Underneath the headlines the consultation also proposes a raft of small measures to make voting easier that could transform the experience of electing councillors.

Voting in mobile locations such as supermarkets, voting over several days, electronic voting and relaxing alleged barriers to voter registration appear on the shopping list.

Individual voter registration was brought in by the Westminster coalition government and has been accused of suppressing registration of groups of people considered less likely to vote Conservative.

Drakeford’s proposals include using sharing data across public services to enable automatic registration of voters.

Party politics

Proposals likely to kick off arguments between political parties include banning sitting Assembly Members from standing as councillors and forcing candidates to disclose party membership.

In the early days of the Assembly, sitting councillors becoming AMs wasn’t uncommon, however now Plaid Cymru AM Neil McEvoy is the only politician balancing both jobs, and was recently re-elected to Cardiff Council, attracting criticism from Welsh Labour.

Forcing disclosure of party affiliation will be seen as an attempt to flush out councillors who routinely stand for election as Independents across rural areas of the country.

Powys and Pembrokeshire, in particular, have strong traditions of Independent councillors, but some commentators have long suspected many are party members believing they would struggle to win election as candidates for their party.

How many of the reforms will survive?

As the minister who brought in presumed consent for organ donation when Health Minister, it’s no surprise that Drakeford has broken rank with parts of his party and proposed such a thorough challenge to the status quo in local government.

The ambition of the proposals when contrasted with predecessor Leighton Andrews is clear.

The consultation is open to public responses until 10 October and the government plans to implement its decisions next year.

Wales’ political parties are expected to engage heavily, with some of the more radical proposals such as changes to the voting system likely to be opposed by parts of the Labour party.

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Capitalist and Welshnash
Capitalist and Welshnash
6 years ago

Voting is the greatest responsibility any citizen will have, and should not be considered something given away so cheaply. That is why I think the voting age should be increased to 21, if not older, and require citizens to take a short, free of charge class on how democracy works. It is mass democracy which has lead us to the mess of Brexit, and such direct democracy must be avoided as much as possible. We have elected representatives so that democracy is not direct and subject to the whims of a populist mob. Lower the voting age will counteract this.… Read more »

6 years ago

So an 18 year old can join the armed forces & die for his country but he is too young to vote?

Mister Pow
Mister Pow
6 years ago

The Cabinet Secretary’s comment that as 16 year olds can serve in the forces, pay taxes and get married, they ought to be permitted to vote appears unanswerable in terms of logic and fairness. No taxation without representation… I’ve heard that somewhere before.

Lyn Thomas
6 years ago

The major flaw is the permissive nature of the change in voting system, turkeys voting for christmas comes to mind. Far better to agree on STV and introduce real democracy to councils.

Max Wallis
6 years ago

Drakeford’s forcing joint working on groupings of Councils is acceptable only if there’s democratic accountability. The joint waste-grouping and joint transport groups have proved dreadful, both strongly steered by WG civil servants instead of transparently complying with legislation and engaging in meaningful consultation. Constituting the group’s boards from Leaders and chief officers is a recipe for remoteness and unaccountability.. No, no, no! What alternative ? multi-party reps from each LA on the joint-Boards and open accessible working including specialist/interest-group nominees?

Lyn Thomas
6 years ago

Id rather go for directly elected regional councils, elected by STV. And retaining the existing units as district councils.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.