Support our Nation today - please donate here

Scottish Government independence spending being probed, email shows after denial

07 Jul 2023 2 minute read
Scottish flag. Photo by M W from Pixabay

The Advocate General for Scotland is “examining” Scottish Government spending on an independence minister, according to an email sent to a Labour peer.

A UK Government source had denied there was any investigation after the issue was raised by Lord Foulkes in the House of Lords on Thursday, when he asked Treasury minister Baroness Penn if she would co-operate with the probe.

However, an email exchange between the peer and Lord Stewart, the UK Government adviser on Scots Law, suggests an inquiry has been ordered.

In the email sent on Thursday, Advocate General Lord Stewart said: “Thanks for your question at the Constitution Committee.

“After the committee rose, I discussed the matter with officials from my department and tasked them with examining the matter of expenditure on this post (of independence minister) by SG, and the allocation of civil service time and personnel.

“I shall revert to you in early course once they have reported.”


Commenting on the confusion, Lord Foulkes told the PA news agency: “I am concerned that there is an attempt under way to reverse the assurances given to me by the Advocate General and Baroness Penn.

“You will see from the attached email that I received a clear assurance that the UK officials were tasked with looking into ultra vires expenditure by the Scottish Government on an ‘independence minister’ and supporting civil servants.

“I have had overwhelming support for this and look forward to a positive response from Lord Stewart on stopping this illegal spending by the Scottish Government.”

Jamie Hepburn was appointed independence minister by First Minister Humza Yousaf earlier this year, angering the UK Government and causing Scottish Secretary Alister Jack to write to the UK’s top civil servant to complain about the use of resources.

In a Holyrood committee earlier this year, the head of the civil service in Scotland, John Paul Marks, defended the appointment, saying the service “serves the Scottish Government and their priorities”.

On Thursday, a UK Government spokesperson said: “It is up to the Scottish Government how it spends its record block grant in devolved areas.

“We have been consistently clear that we think that the priority for people in Scotland is halving inflation, tackling the NHS waiting times, ensuring energy security, and growing our economy across the whole of UK.”

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
1 Comment
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Fi yn unig
Fi yn unig
1 year ago

The Scottish National Party have been repeatedly voted in on the grounds they will pursue independence for their country therefore, how can it be that appointing an independence minister in line with the wishes of the voters be deemed to result in ‘illegal spending’? This UK governments’ bulldozing of Scottish democracy is as big a disgrace as the appointment of a minister for Brexit opportunities where none were, or were ever, going to be found. Total misappropriation of tax payers’ money and only legal because THEY say so.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.