Support our Nation today - please donate here

Shadow Minister calls for research on children’s appetite for ‘alternative protein’ to be halted

01 Jun 2022 3 minute read
The protein can be used as a substitute for mince in popular dishes

Shadow Education Minister Laura Anne Jones MS has written to Jeremy Miles objecting to plans for schoolchildren in Wales to take part in research to gauge their appetite for “alternative protein”.

The research is being conducted by Cardiff University and the University of the West of England and will see children aged 5-11 being given a product called VeXo, said to look like “conventional” mince, which is a combination of insect and plant-based protein.

In her letter Ms Jones called for the education minister to step in “to ensure our children are protected, parents are well-informed and that there is a choice to take part, and not mandatory enforcement”.


Ms Jones MS, the Sennedd Member for South Wales East said: “It is absolutely ludicrous that young children are being used as guinea pigs to test the absurd desires of scientists who prefer bugs to beef.

“The Labour Government need to answer questions about how this was allowed to happen, did they sanction this, have parents been made aware, can children say no in favour of proper food, and why the sustainable nature of Welsh farming is being undermined like this.

“We know the challenges of climate change and proposals to diversify diets, but that does not mean a handful of zealots can impose their way of life on an uninterested populace, especially children, without proper and genuine consent.

“I look forward to the Minister’s reply where he will hopefully put an end to this nonsense.”


VEXo has been developed by husband and wife team chef Andy Holcroft and entomologist Dr Sarah Beynon.

It can be used in a similar way to minced meat, whilst reducing saturated fat by over 80%.

Nearly one-third of 2-15 year olds are overweight or obese, with obesity costing the NHS in Wales around £73 million.

Bug Farm Foods, which developed VeXo was funded by the Welsh Government and Innovate UK under the Small Business Research Initiative (SBRI) project to find a way to harness the nutrients contained in insects and deliver them in a form that is acceptable to our western palettes.

The company, which has a Research and Development facility in St Davids, first launched VeXo in Wales in September 2019.

The edible insect industry has grown at a fast rate across Europe and North America over the past few years, fueled by an expanding human population demanding new, more sustainable sources of protein.

Dr Sarah Benyon said: “Insects are exceptionally nutrient-dense and environmentally sustainable to produce.

“Many insects contain weight-for-weight a similar amount of protein to beef and they can contain all nine essential amino acids. Insects can be farmed in high-welfare farms while requiring very little feed, water and space and emitting hardly any greenhouse gases.”

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
2 years ago

Alternatives to conventional protein yes certainly. Insects? Yuck!
I’m 5 years vegetarian so already eat alternative protein sources (plus eggs and milk). But even if I were still eating meat I wouldn’t want insect meat! I know the arguments for it, but just like I’ve never eaten a prawn, I’d not willingly eat an insect although I must have accidentally aspirated some over the years

2 years ago

This company (and product) sounds good to me. Trialling it on children in schools? Not exactly confidence building regarding our elected officials. Some of the educational reforms (broadly speaking, much needed) are equally ideologically driven and lacking in any care for children. On the consumer market, this sounds like a good alternative for those who do not want to consume meat. Critical theory is a perfectly fine subject to electively persue in uni. Foisting this on children is harmful.

2 years ago

Why aren’t they serving this up in the Senedd canteen?
There’s more obesity there than any school.

2 years ago

So, the New World Order begins in Wokey Wales, with crickets, grasshoppers, silkworm and mealworms mashed together to make “Vexo”! No wonder Welsh Gov. didn’t answer calls to aid our farmers in producing food for the coming emergency, they already had other things in mind. And they begin with our kids!

Peter Cuthbert
Peter Cuthbert
2 years ago
Reply to  I.Humphrys

The article says ‘Plans’ so the product is not as yet being offered to kids. Over 80% less saturated fat sounds good to me. Given what I know about University research ethics Committees I would have thought a great deal of discussion about the research will go on before it takes place. Notice that it is a Tory MS who is complaining and trying to push the ‘Anti-Woke’ agenda. Will the product damage Welsh farming? Probably not, but given the low extent to which the UK grows its own food, perhaps our farmers should consider whether to produce more veg… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.