Split from Westminster party would be ‘advantageous’ for Welsh Tories says academic
A Swansea University academic has said that a split from the Westminster party would be “advantageous” to the Welsh Conservatives.
The Telegraph newspaper revealed on Saturday that the Tories in Wales were seriously considering detaching themselves in order to be able to move “into a more Welsh-focused direction”.
Andrew Tettenborn, a professor of law, wrote in the Spectator that such a move would allow them to copy the success of the Scottish Conservatives under Ruth Davidson and attract small-c conservative voters from the other parties.
He said that there was no reason why separate Conservative parties should be at odds with their Unionist beliefs, as there was already a precedent in Northern Ireland of unionist parties that were independent of those in Britain.
“In both Scotland and Wales, it’s worth recalling that dislike of dictation from London is not limited to progressives and swivel-eyed nationalists,” he wrote.
“The Scottish Conservatives got their very creditable result in the General Election of 2017 in large degree because their then leader, Ruth Davidson, was noticeably Scottish-centred in her approach to politics: she was clearly not beholden to the views of MPs in London, and was known to be her own woman on matters like immigration and Brexit.
“There is no reason to think right-leaning Welsh voters are any different, and that they would not prefer a party which, while broadly staying in line with CCHQ in London, was prepared if necessary to take a different view on specific areas of policy.”
He pointed to industrial policy, education and transport as issues where the general political mood in Wales was at odds with England.
“It would also give the Welsh Tories a useful bonus, in the form of a stick with which to beat Welsh Labour, which remains nothing more than a branch of the national party and subject to its dictation,” he said.
“It might even attract a few votes from conservative nationalists who would otherwise have supported Plaid, but are put off by its tiresome left-wing image.”
Andrew Tetternborn’s comments in the Spectator come after some in the Welsh Conservative party said that “clear blue water” was needed between the Tories in Wales and England.
The aim was the “creation of a number of policies in the pipeline that will appeal more uniquely to the Welsh electorate, whilst maintaining a strong Unionist position,” they told the Telegraph.
“There will be clear blue water between both sides,” the source said, in a reference to Rhodri Morgan’s ‘clear red water’ speech – co-written by current First Minister Mark Drakeford, which declared Welsh Labour’s semi-detached status from the UK party.
“We will rebrand the Welsh Conservatives and run different policies to the ones Westminster produces,” the Conservative source continued.
“Welsh Conservatives want Welsh-focused answers to Welsh issues that arise in the devolved competencies.
“The mood is very much of abandonment by Boris. Senedd members were not even invited to Number 10 after the election.”
Not all Welsh Conservatives were said to be on board, however, with the Senedd Member for Brecon and Radnorshire, James Evans, among those who opposed the plan.
The Welsh Conservatives made a starting bid for a semi-detached status to the UK party before this year’s conference, saying that Wales should get its share of money from HS2 to invest in Wales’ rail infrastructure.
The UK Government has classed HS2 as an ‘England and Wales’ project meaning that Wales will not benefit in the same way as Scotland and Northern Ireland from additional rail funding as a result of the project.
Speaking at the start of the Welsh Conservative conference, however, Andrew RT Davies said that additional funding should now come to Wales.
“We’re making the case that Wales should receive its fair share of HS2 spending,” he said in his speech.
Andrew RT Davies however declined to comment to the Telegraph on whether they would seek a split from the UK party.
“We’re proud to work with our colleagues in Westminster in delivering solutions to the cost of living crisis and assisting Ukraine,” he said.
“Over the coming years, we will continue to make the case for a Welsh Conservative government with conservative values that reflect the values of the people of Wales and create a strong Wales in a strong UK.”
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Let’s have a split from England with a physical boundary with passport control between the two countries. Welsh services and jobs for Wales. English services and jobs for England.
Possibly the worst suggestion possible.
I’m all for independence but there is no need to shut ourselves off from England with a passport control and causing people to lose jobs. Many countriy in the world have free movement across borders for both tourism and work
They have some sort of border controls across state lines in the United States. It doesn’t seem to pose a problem there. We may have to institute a border if we ever enter the single market in any event.
These Tories just have absolutely dim clem whatsoever do they. Nor any self awareness I’d hazard a guess. And after more than a century and a half of being rejected by the Welsh electorate in any sort of democratic vote to Westminster or the Senedd, the best they can come up with is a stunt and a slogan borrowed from Welsh Labour. I’ve never seen anything so pathetic. And as for the silly pejoratives they like to fling around! Infantile.
‘…swivel eyed nationalists’ ….’Welsh Labour …a branch of the national party’ – is this supposed to be journalism?
His comments immediately lost credibilty with that remark. I’m surprised an academic would resort to such purile name calling.
well I am particularly offended, I am apparently both swivel eyed and Welsh Labour.
no need to worry though the comments were made by a Tory and people in Wales rarely listen to their brand of Fascism anyway.#IndyWales
I beg to differ. Wales separating itself from Little Britain & Unionist Tory rule would be more advantageous.
The Professor makes some good points, and clearly our nation should possess a self-standing Conservative Party, free from any external teat. When people talk about developing “a more Welsh-focussed direction”, the obvious question is why aren’t people in Wales ‘Welsh-focussed’ in the first place? Priorities and loyalties? Welsh (and Scottish) Conservatives display real existential difficulties on these issues. They are limp and agnostic on the notion of identity. It is a great pity about the lazy “swivel-eyed” and “tiresome” cliches, but it has to be said that he writes perfectly for his Spectator audience – a collection of myopic, London-centric,… Read more »
You are either for or against independence. The “Welsh” tories can’t bring their voters with them on this issue so they are by definition just a branch office of lickspittal London yes men. Labour will have to make the same choice soon enough…. they can be a truly Welsh (ie autonomous) party or go the same way as “Scottish” Labour….. Into the history books.
This would seem impossible for the Tory’s in Cymru to do. Could, or would they go on tv here, and call out Johnson for blatant lies being told daily, call him out over school meals, cronyism, ignoring MI5 warnings on placing Russians in the Lords, law breaking etc. Then could they call for more devolution of power, because that is what we have voted for in past elections. All of this would need to be done, to prove to people here they are different and worthy of a vote, Could they, I think not.
They would just be yet another Tory faction. I lost count years ago
Yes of course it would be better for THEM. They just want some distance from the electoral fallout of the Failed Johnson Junta. But unless they start putting Wales before their nasty failed free market dogma and learn some compassion for those of us without land, money or hope, it won’t make one iota of difference.
“He said that there was no reason why separate Conservative parties should be at odds with their Unionist beliefs,”
Look at how the UK Conservatives are treating Northern Ireland now, how they’ve been treating Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales for decades; how can anyone suggest it’s a unionist party?
Silly season early call. The germ in it, though, is that Cymru does need a conservative party with our traditional values. If I was in Welsh Labour, I would be terrified of such a party, one like the Plaid Cymru founders established, as the time for such a party has now arrived. Gwlad have the brains, but the name is a problem. Change your optics.
Let’s face it, it’s never going to happen is it.
Contrary to what this article says, Labour in Wales have started the same process.
But as long as Labour and Tory HQ see the Welsh branches as a route to No. 10, they will never let either of them go.