Support our Nation today - please donate here

Swansea teachers to strike in row over colleague’s dismissal after ‘breaking up pupil fight’

13 Jul 2023 4 minute read
PA Wire/PA Images

Hundreds of secondary school teachers across Swansea, who are said to be angry over the sacking of one of their colleagues for breaking up a fight between two pupils, are to go on strike.

The NASUWT Teachers’ Union said its members voted overwhelmingly to take part in the industrial action on Thursday over “adverse employer practices, threats to their job security and the failure of Swansea Council to comply with existing collective agreements”.

More than half of the city’s secondary schools will close for the day due to the walkout, while a number of others will partially close.

The union said its members do not take strike action lightly, but said in the face of rising violence in schools experienced after the coronavirus pandemic, teachers should feel “supported when they intervene to keep themselves and their pupils safe”.

Swansea Council has previously said it is “extremely disappointed” in the union’s decision to ballot for a strike and said it refutes all claims of employer abuse.

The row between the union and local education officials is claimed to be over an incident involving a male teacher who pulled apart two male students who were engaged in a physical fight.


According to the union, the teacher was disciplined but then exonerated on appeal before a second appeal led him to be dismissed.

Neil Butler, NASUWT’s Wales representative, said the union “does not recognise the outcome of the second appeal”.

“Our members are very angry about this, it’s outrageous on a number of levels,” Mr Butler told the PA news agency.

“The reason this is a wider problem is that we know that violence and aggression in schools has gotten worse, so teachers needing to intervene in physical situations is getting more common.

“They are already very, very nervous to do that because lay a hand on a child and you’ve got child protection procedures. But in law, teachers do have the right to use reasonable force to protect children and stop them beating each other up.

“Ultimately, actions like this put teachers more on guard, it makes safeguarding in schools worse and leads to teachers not wanting to stay in the jobs anymore.

“This is about standing up for teachers being allowed to do their jobs properly,” he added.

NASUWT general secretary Dr Patrick Roach said: “Our members in Swansea do not take strike action lightly but today they are sending a strong message that their employer cannot bully or threaten them without any consequences.

“Swansea Council cannot ignore, side line or ride roughshod over collective agreements with the NASUWT, which are an essential element of the working conditions of teachers.

“The NASUWT will not hesitate to take further industrial action should Swansea Council fail to demonstrate they respect and will uphold agreements relating to teachers’ contracts.”

Serious breach

Helen Johns, NASUWT national executive member for Swansea, called the council’s involvement in the teacher’s dismissal “a serious breach of policy” and an “unfounded intervention in a school process”.

It is understood the dismissed teacher is expected to take his case to an employment tribunal.

The union is currently in a dispute with three other secondary schools elsewhere in Wales over issues of dealing with poor pupil behaviour.

A spokesperson for Swansea Council previously said: “This action is regrettable and will only serve to deny children of educational opportunities.

“This is based on an individual case and while this continues, for legal reasons and to protect the integrity of the processes, we cannot comment on specifics.

“We value all of our teaching staff and have built good relationships with heads and other staff over a number of years.

“We refute any allegation of employer abuse, victimisation and other claims made by the union which they will need to substantiate.

“We hope that the union will continue to talk with us so that we can work together to find a solution that avoids unnecessary disruption to our schools and the education of children in Swansea.”

A rally is to be held outside the Guildhall, one of the council’s main offices, from 4pm.

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
9 months ago

Authorities need to face up to the realities of youth misconduct in today’s society. If teachers can’t break up fights in school who on earth is on hand to do the work, or do they just stand by and let 2 or more little hooligans kill each other ? Duty of care ? It is a duty to everybody and some times there will be a conflict of interests. That is where common sense should prevail.

Mr Williams
Mr Williams
9 months ago
Reply to  hdavies15

Very well said.

Mr Williams
Mr Williams
9 months ago

Respect to the teachers of Swansea for standing up for their colleague. I have had to break up fights many times, and sometimes you have to use physical restraint. The teacher concerned did the right thing, we have a duty of care in schools to keep our pupils safe! The problem is that thuggish behaviour is being tolerated too much in society generally, and far too much sympathy is being given to incorrigible, naughty children in schools. How many times I, and many of my colleagues, have referred a naughty child to a senior member of management to be met… Read more »

Mr Williams
Mr Williams
9 months ago

‘A spokesperson for Swansea Council previously said: “This action is regrettable and will only serve to deny children of educational opportunities’.

Get a grip Swansea Council!

The children would be denied many more opportunities if they were injured and in hospital – or even worse – after being caught up in violent attacks.

Swansea Council should be ashamed of themselves for the way they have treated that teacher who put himself at risk to prevent further harm to two, possibly more, children. I hope they have the decency to apologise to him.

John Hammond
John Hammond
9 months ago

So Swansea is implicitly suggesting that the two pupils should hav ebeen left to fight on, without intervention. Madness!

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.