Support our Nation today - please donate here

Tories warned not to claim Civil Service behind their Labour tax attack

05 Jun 2024 4 minute read
Prime Minister Rishi Sunak (left), host Julie Etchingham and Labour Party leader Sir Keir Starmer during the ITV General Election debate at MediaCity in Salford. Photo Jonathan Hordle/ITV/PA Wire

Rishi Sunak’s Conservatives have defended their claim that Labour would impose £2,000 in tax rises as it emerged a senior Treasury official had warned them not to say civil servants were behind their central claim.

The Prime Minister repeatedly highlighted the claim during his ITV head-to-head debate with Sir Keir Starmer, claiming “independent Treasury officials” have costed Labour’s policies “and they amount to a £2,000 tax rise for everyone”.

But the Treasury’s permanent secretary James Bowler said ministers had been told not to suggest civil servants produced the figure at the heart of the Tory attack.

The claim comes from a document produced by the Conservatives which made a series of assumptions to estimate the cost that might be attached to potential Labour policies.

It claimed that the difference between the money that Labour would raise from its policies and the amount it would spend would be a deficit of £38.5 billion over four years, amounting to around £2,094 for every working household.


Some of the estimates in the document have been carried out by civil servants at the Treasury, using assumptions provided by politically appointed special advisers.

But Mr Bowler said the headline figure used by the Tories should not be attributed to impartial civil servants.

In a letter to Labour’s shadow Treasury chief secretary Darren Jones he said the £38.5 billion total for Labour policies in the Tory document “includes costs beyond those provided by the Civil Service”.

“Costings derived from other sources or produced by other organisations should not be presented as having been produced by the Civil Service,” he said in a letter to Mr Jones on June 3.

“I have reminded ministers and advisers that this should be the case.”


Mr Jones demanded an apology from Mr Sunak.

“Civil servants confirmed they had told Tory ministers they were not allowed to say their dodgy attacks on Labour were independently done by civil servants,” he said.

“Last night Rishi Sunak did it anyway. He lied to the British people. He must apologise.”

Energy Secretary Claire Coutinho repeated the claim on Wednesday, saying it was based on “official costings from the Treasury”.

She told BBC Breakfast: “I’ve worked in the Treasury and I can tell you that these are brilliant, independent civil servants and they would not be putting anything dodgy in there.”

On Times Radio Ms Coutinho even claimed “this is something which has been signed off by the permanent secretary of the Treasury”, adding “those costings have been done by independent Treasury civil servants”.

But shadow paymaster general Jonathan Ashworth said: “I feel that Rishi Sunak was exposed as desperate last night – desperately lying about Labour’s tax plans, making accusations about Labour’s tax plans which are categorically untrue – Labour will not put up income tax, will not put up national insurance, will not put up VAT.”

He told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “Rishi Sunak was resorting to lying because he is desperate and what do desperate people do when in a corner? They lie.

“We saw it with Boris Johnson over parties in Downing Street in lockdown, and Rishi Sunak has exposed himself as no better and no different than Boris Johnson with his lies last night.”


Polls suggested neither Mr Sunak nor Sir Keir landed a knockout blow during the ITV clash on Tuesday night.

A snap poll from YouGov suggested the Prime Minister performed marginally better, with 51% making him the winner against 49% for Sir Keir among people who expressed a preference.

But a Savanta survey pointed to a more convincing victory for Sir Keir on 53%, ahead of Mr Sunak on 47%, excluding those who said they did not know.

Perhaps the most telling findings from the YouGov survey were that 62% found the ITV debate frustrating and just 17% found it a helpful exercise.

YouGov surveyed 1,657 GB adults on Tuesday, and Savanta surveyed 1,153 people who watched the debate after it concluded.

Campaigning on Wednesday will be low key as commemorations for the 80th anniversary of D-Day begin.

Both Mr Sunak and Sir Keir will attend the UK’s national commemoration event in Portsmouth alongside members of the royal family and armed forces veterans, before attention is focused across the Channel for further anniversary events in Normandy on Thursday.

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mab Meirion
Mab Meirion
10 days ago

My survey of John Crace gave it to Clark of Kent…

What an example to set your children Lying to the Nation…

Can’t think where he gets it from…(Modi Ji, Fat Shanks, Trump, Putin)…

Fi yn unig
Fi yn unig
10 days ago

The £2000 lie. An amount Sunak finds in small change down the back of his £2m sofa is the proven lie which will (politically) hang him. He has even repeated it in the face of the civil service letter which has confirmed and exposed it officially. What a weak, washed up and pathetic little man.

10 days ago
Reply to  Fi yn unig

Oddly enough I never heard Starmer call Sunak a liar or ask him to table his evidence. Now given that Starmer has already said on a number of occasions that his regime would not be seeking changes to income tax I found it a bit strange that he was so reluctant to verbally slap Sunak a bit harder. Opportunity lost.

10 days ago
Reply to  hdavies15

In Parliament it is a violation of protocol to call another MP a liar and it being the truth is no defence.

Fi yn unig
Fi yn unig
10 days ago
Reply to  hdavies15

Starmer did eventually say ‘garbage’ to the repeated £2k claim from Sunak and I was disappointed he said no more than that but today, it has become clear with the letter published by the presumed impartial civil service that Sunak lied. Starmer, all along for months now, has been quietly feeding the Tories more rope with which to hang themselves and there last night, Sunak wound yet more of it around his own neck with all his desperate shouty interruptions. Strategy working, keep going. I’ll have plenty to pick on in a Welsh context when Starmer is in. The list… Read more »

Y Cymro
Y Cymro
10 days ago

Watched the debate last night and what a shambles. Usual attack on Wales and the Welsh NHS to deflect the chaotic Conservative. running of their English NHS. To be honest it was like watching two bald men fighting over a comb. But what I found equally frustrating was the continuous interruption by Rishy Sunak and the chair’s inability to shut him up. Also, the bare faced lies told with the claim of £2000 tax rise when today after fact checking has been proven that it was untrue. Looks as if Trumpian “alternative facts” have now crossed the pond.

10 days ago

So even if it were true it would be over 4 years. Really £500 then?

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.