News

Tory MP for Dudley suggests access to Welsh beaches is a ‘basic right’

22 Jul 2021 2 minutes Read
Marco Longhi MP. UK Parliament (CC 3.0)

A Tory MP has suggested that access to Welsh beaches is a basic right for his constituents.

Marco Longhi, who represents Dudley North, in the West Midlands, complained to the House of Commons that the nearest beach is in Wales and that access is “almost mission impossible”.

He made the comments in a debate titled Connectivity and Infrastructure within Wales and Cross-border. The UK Government is conducting a review into the matter.

In response to a question from Longhi, the Secretary of State for Wales Simon Hart said improving “cross-border holidaying” between Wales the and west midlands is “exactly what the review is about”.

He added that this is in part because it brings “gratification to the residents of Dudley”.

‘Forefathers’ 

Marco Longhi said: “My Italian forefathers always understood the importance of sunshine, sandy beaches and full-bodied, gorgeous ice cream, but for those who live in Dudley, the nearest beach is in Wales, and access is almost mission impossible.

“What can my right hon. Friend do to improve the wellbeing of my constituents by improving access to these basic rights?”

Simon Hart replied: “Sadly, we cannot move Dudley, but what we can do is progress the Union connectivity review and strengthen the links.

“I know my hon. Friend’s part of the world very well. Of course, the cross-border holidaying and other activity between the west midlands and Wales is well known, and we want to improve it.

“That is exactly what the review is about, because we know that brings not only gratification to the residents of Dudley, but economic prosperity to both areas.”

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
28 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Roderich Heier
Roderich Heier
2 months ago

What a lot of specious nonsense!! Since when has going to the beach been a ‘human right’? By the same logic the citizens of Switzerland or Bavaria or Austria have a human right to untramelled access to the beaches of northern Italy or Slovenia. This M.P. for Dudley really must recognise that Cymru/Wales is not England/Lloegr.

William Glyn THOMAS
William Glyn THOMAS
2 months ago

If the inhabitants of Dudley respect the rules in Wales then I am certain that they will be welcomed.

tired of this
tired of this
2 months ago

Entitled garbage. Apart from anything else there’s lots of beaches along the English side of the Severn Estuary, and that area is actually faster and easier for the citizens of Dudley to get to via motorway. Or is it the nice ‘unspoiled’ ones in ‘the countryside’ they want?

SundanceKid
SundanceKid
2 months ago
Reply to  tired of this

They want to prove a point. “We WANT access to Wales and we WANT it NOW without any hinderances”.

Mab Meirion
Mab Meirion
2 months ago

The Hawker Hart spent most of its life dropping bombs on the natives…this one is after the DFM!

I wonder what the balance of opinion will be in the Barmouth pubs tonight(not a lot we’re busy)…after all it was the home of the Wolverhampton Ski Club once…he is a proper trouble maker that SSW…

CJPh
CJPh
2 months ago

Let’s not forget the basic, God-given human right of access to “full-bodied, gorgeous ice cream”. Speech and association? Those are privileges doled out by the Grand High Scoopholder. With extra sprinkles is you’re lucky.

SundanceKid
SundanceKid
2 months ago
Reply to  CJPh

Omg that line about ice-cream sounded like a parody.

MattJ
MattJ
2 months ago

He’s not so good at geography is he. There are beaches just as close to Dudley that are in England as there are in Wales. Just another colonialist thinking Wales is his to do with as he pleases.

SundanceKid
SundanceKid
2 months ago
Reply to  MattJ

His problem is that Wales is still imposing restrictions on access, not that he cannot access any beach.

Quornby
Quornby
2 months ago

One of the idiots Mark wants us to love.

Wrexhamian
Wrexhamian
2 months ago

Only someone with a wholly unionist perspective (Longhi) could make this demand without realising the offence it may cause, and only someone with the same unionst perspective (Viceroy Hart) could answer in support of that demand. To make such a statement during a pandemic, implying a need to override Welsh Government regulations, is also irresponsible. It’s “mission impossible” for a very good reason.

It’s also an unnecessary statement, as Welsh regulations may be easing up on 7th August, which leads to the suspicion that it was said as another public exercise in belittling devolution.

Gareth
Gareth
2 months ago

It shows the attitude of England that they consider that we in Wales must do as we are told. We can have our own rules and laws as long as England can totaly ignore them. We are still a colony after all

Stephen Owen
Stephen Owen
2 months ago
Reply to  Gareth

Their first and last colony.

Ann Swindale
Ann Swindale
2 months ago

I would suggest to the Rt Hon Gentlemen that they stopp worrying about their constituents “God given right” to a jolly to the beach with ice cream thrown in until all of the said constituents have enough money to feed their families without resort to a Food Bank; have safe, secure housing without worries about flammable cladding or whether they can pay the rent; clothe themselves without being forced to use charity shops etc. I think I know my Bible pretty well and it doesn’t mention trips to the seaside or ice cream!

Mark
Mark
2 months ago

Oh whats’s that smell? just another pile of inglish tory BS

Chris
Chris
2 months ago

Cymru has a basic right to kick out anyone who refuses to follow the rules of our nation.
If visitors come and comply with these, the Coreso I Gymru. Otherwise, clear off.
The recent poster that has Tories choking on their Caviar says it best
This is Wales
We are not England
We have our own laws

hdavies15
hdavies15
2 months ago

Simple really Mr Dudley Longhi. As a card carrying Tory you are probably aware of the rules and how rules need to be observed. Now these rules happen to have been written by another government that errs on the side of caution. So if you wish to be flippant with other people’s health do so on your side of the Dyke where you seem to be quite adept at making a mess of things anyway. Your declared disrespect for other people marks as the sort of person not welcome here. Stay away.

Steve Duggan
Steve Duggan
2 months ago

What a cheek to complain about the infrastructure in Wales when its primarily his party’s neglect that’s the reason for it ! As for ‘a basic right’ – when were our ‘basic rights’ observed when our resources were plundered, language and culture targeted and freedom taken away whether we liked it or not ?! We now live in a country with a stronger voice – if, for example, we say we do not want you infecting our beaches, that is ‘our right’ !

Last edited 2 months ago by Steve Duggan
Mandi A
Mandi A
2 months ago
Reply to  Steve Duggan

Like the ‘basic right’ to buy up houses in rural Wales to rent them back to their English neighbours, entitlement or what. We can refuse to sell a property if the vendor is not going to live in it, although of course, we have bucketloads of evidence that they just lie. Or when houses are built with s.106 grants then sold on or used for holiday lets. We need a mobile Planning Inspectorate with teeth to monitor these movements and declarations of intent. Appreciate this comment has gone a long way from icecream but it’s symptomatic.

Andrew Penny
Andrew Penny
2 months ago

Just a reminder to this MP that it is my basic human right not to be infected by anyone travelling from Dudley to a Welsh beach…..

Dyfi Dreamer
Dyfi Dreamer
2 months ago

More grist to the mill for the desperate-to-be-offended little xenophobes on this website.

Wrexhamian
Wrexhamian
2 months ago
Reply to  Dyfi Dreamer

You have made the common mistake among BritNats of confusing anti-colonialism with xenophobia.

Anthony
Anthony
2 months ago

It is Dudley boy, for the Welsh. 👍

Huw Davies
Huw Davies
2 months ago

According to ‘Google’, Dudley is 114 miles from WestonSuperMare and 107 miles from Borth (which is due west of Dudley). WSM takes 2hr 7min to reach, straight down the M5, while Borth takes 2hr 44min via theM54/ A458/A457.
I can’t see Marco Longhi’s logic here. A basic human right to spend over an extra half hour in the car with the kids moaning ‘are we there yet’ every 5 minutes?

Surely he can’t be another English Tory trying to make some anti devolution political point?

Anthony
Anthony
2 months ago

This is basically a challenge to Welsh autonomy, this pandemic has allowed Wales to fully express its devolved powers in a way that is normalising Wales ability to act independently, Dudley, Rod and all those vile creatures that lurk in the corners of their lairs absolutely hate this, they hate the Welsh and certainly would not like to see them flourish….. Why? Because I think they’re actually scared we’d do really well on our own, in fact people in England would see Wales as a model for change.

Alan Reilly
Alan Reilly
2 months ago

Is it also a human right NOT to go to Dudley lol?

hdavies15
hdavies15
2 months ago
Reply to  Alan Reilly

It is a human right to leave Dudley especially when there is an absolute pr*ck as incumbent M.P

Alan Reilly
Alan Reilly
2 months ago
Reply to  hdavies15

Is there anything to miss if you do leave lol? Birmingham wouldn’t be high on my list of centres of culture anyway.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.