Support our Nation today - please donate here

UK Government refuses to say which conditions no longer qualify for benefits under reforms

29 Apr 2024 5 minute read
Work and Pensions Secretary Mel Stride . Photo Yui Mok/PA Wire

The UK Government’s Work and Pensions Secretary has refused to set out which health conditions will no longer result in access to sickness benefits, as part of the Government’s major welfare reforms.

In a statement to the Commons, Mel Stride set out plans to overhaul the way disability benefits work, with proposals aimed at providing a “fair and compassionate” system with “bespoke” support.

In a Green Paper published alongside Mr Stride’s statement, ministers proposed to reform personal independence payments (Pip), the main disability benefit, through changes to eligibility criteria and assessments.

The plans, which will be consulted on over the coming months, also include proposals to “move away from a fixed cash benefit system”, meaning people with some conditions will no longer receive regular payments but rather improved access to treatment if their condition does not involve extra costs.

Mr Stride told the Commons on Monday: “This Government’s priority is to make sure that our welfare system is fair and compassionate. Fair on the taxpayer, by ensuring that people of working age who can work, do work, and fair on those who are in most need of the state’s help.”


He added that the consultation will be “exploring whether people with specific health conditions and disabilities can be taken out of Pip assessments all together”.

Mr Stride continued: “We are also consulting on whether we should make fundamental changes to the way we provide support to disabled people and people with a health condition.

“We know that any additional cost arising form a disability or health condition, which Pip is intended to help with can vary significantly and is unique to the individual circumstances.”

He argued that changes to the current “one-size fits all” system will offer “bespoke support tailored to individual needs”.

Acting shadow work and pensions secretary Alison McGovern accused Mr Stride of talking out of both sides of his mouth.

She said: “In recent weeks, the Secretary of State has decided to speak out of both sides of his mouth. On the one hand he says ‘I am grateful for today’s more open approach to mental health’, and with the same breath he tells us ‘there is danger that this has gone too far’.

“He wants it both ways, he thinks that openness about mental health is good but then says the very thing that brings back the stigma.

“Every time (Mr Stride) speaks, he makes it less likely that people will be open about their mental health.”

Ms Govern added: “He says some health conditions can be taken out of Pip assessments, which conditions are we talking about?”

Mr Stride replied that questions raised by Ms McGovern will be included in the consultation.


Conservative MP Ruth Edwards (Rushcliffe) fought back tears as she recalled how she was diagnosed with an anxiety disorder in spring 2019.

She said: “I was extremely ill with it and I couldn’t work for several months so I know first-hand how debilitating it can be. But I also know that with treatment and support you can lead a fulfilling career and a normal life and it’s extremely rewarding.”

Ms Edwards said she would have been “devastated” to be out of the workforce long-term, as she sought assurances about how the proposed reforms will help anxiety sufferers get the treatment and support they need to “take back their lives”.

In an interview with ITV News, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak said that “what we shouldn’t be doing is medicalising the everyday challenges and anxieties of life”.

He added: “Just because someone is grappling with some of these things, if they are less severe, they should be expected to engage in the world of work. A) because that’s fair. But also, as I said, ’cause I do believe that is fundamentally good for them as well.”

Mr Stride suggested to the Times that people with “milder mental health conditions” would no longer receive financial support. But added that talking therapies, social care packages and respite care, could be used as alternatives.

Conservative MP Nigel Mills, a member of the Work and Pensions Select Committee, questioned if Mel Stride was suggesting people would have to submit “invoices to prove the amount of support they need” or if he was looking at more tiers of award.

Mr Stride replied: “I think we should explore whether that approach we have at the moment is the best one in terms of outcomes.

“We have much to learn from the experiences of other countries around the world who have a similar benefit but go about the organisation and application of that benefit in a different way.

“New Zealand, for example, does indeed make payments based on invoices submitted for equipment by those who are receiving the benefit; Norway, for example doesn’t have assessments in the way that we do, they rely more on medical evidence provided by medical practitioners.”

Pip awards

The number of monthly Pip awards for mental health disorders has doubled since 2019, from 2,200 to 5,300, in line with an increase in overall Pip awards which have also doubled to 33,000 a month.

James Taylor, the executive director of strategy at disability equity charity Scope, called for an end to the “reckless assault” on disabled people and to fix the “real underlying issues”.

“It’s hard to have any faith that this consultation is about anything other than cutting the benefits bill, no matter the impact,” Mr Taylor said.

The Disability Benefits Consortium branded the consultation “cynical and cruel”.

Speaking on behalf of DBC, Ceri Smith head of policy at the MS Society, said: “If the Government truly wants a ‘stronger, healthier and fairer society’, they should start by addressing NHS waiting lists and fixing social care. Instead, this approach will punish disabled people and push even more into poverty.”

The consultation will run for 12 weeks, closing on July 23.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
26 days ago

A nasty party, with nasty policies trying to appeal to their dwindling core vote of nasty people.

26 days ago

Not a lot of groups left to attack and demonise now. They need targets, they need the press that support them to get the hate headlines out, Mail, Telegraph etc.

i wondered who would be next after the last attack, now who will be attacked after this.

now imagine where they will go if the win the GE. All bets are off for generations of decency.

Richard Davies
Richard Davies
25 days ago

Personal Independence Payment(s) (PIPs) is less than 14 years old. It was brought in to replace Disability Living Allowance (DLA). DLA was quite a generous non-means tested payment which was paid irrespective of employment status. [Mr david cameron—the then tory prime minister—claimed it for his disabled son, despite being incredibly wealthy. Sadly his sôn passed away, then its reform came] PIP isn’t as generous as DLA, PIP doesn’t cover as many medical conditions as DLA, it was not introduced for the benefit of the recipients, it was to reduce the support to those eligible to enable the tories to reduce… Read more »

25 days ago

So low down and dirty. They don’t have a limit to their…… words don’t even come close to describing how they operate. The best descriptions have been uttered throughout their premiership to the point where it’s just standard verbiage. ‘Disgusting, disgraceful, shameful, lying, greedy, sadistic, sociopathic, out of touch, corrupt, crooked, contemptuous, hateful’. It’s all of the above and more. I don’t understand them and I think that’s probably a good thing because if I did that would indicate there was something very wrong with me. I’m sad for humanity. I don’t know how we can break the habit of… Read more »

Cymro Penperllenni
Cymro Penperllenni
25 days ago

Fair and compassionate. Two words that are never associated with the Tory Party.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.