Welsh Conservatives call for review of minimum alcohol pricing
The Welsh Conservatives have called for a review of Wales’ minimum unit price (MUP) alcohol law.
Citing a recent report from Public Health Scotland, which linked the MUP there to an increase in deaths from cheap street drugs, Welsh Tories say the law is having “a whole host of unintended consequence”.
The report also found minimum pricing in Scotland had led problem drinkers to sacrifice heating and eating to pay for alcohol.
Shadow Health Minister Russell George MS also accused Labour MSs who also stood as Cooperative Party candidates at last year’s Senedd election of “hypocrisy” for supporting the law while the Co-op retailer promotes cheap alcohol in online offers.
More than half of Labour MSs are Cooperative Party representatives, and seven are members of Mark Drakeford’s cabinet, including Economy Minister Vaughan Gething, Education Minister Jeremy Miles, and Deputy Minister for Mental Health Lynne Neagle.
Negative results
“It has become increasingly clear that Labour’s minimum alcohol price is having a whole host of unintended consequences from pushing people to take drugs and sacrifice heating and eating, all the while failing to fulfil its very purpose to drive down heavy drinking, Mr George said.
“We warned the Labour Government at the time that pushing this law through without an expiry date or safeguards could trigger a whole host of negative results, but we were ignored.
“We do not see enough post-legislative scrutiny in the Senedd, and I believe, given the evidence we are seeing from Scotland, that we revisit the law in Wales to test whether it is fit for purpose with a review of the MUP.”
The Scottish report, published in July, revealed 1,330 people died from overdoses in Scotland in 2021, with almost 70% of those linked with benzodiazepines or “benzos”, which sell for as little as 20p a pill.
Benzos, sometimes known as street Valium, were linked to 191 deaths in 2015 but were a factor in 918 fatalities last year, an increase of over £380%
Public Health Scotland said as a result of the increased price, people were sacrificing health and eating to pay for alcohol.
Research published in the British Medical Journal in July also revealed that consumption among the 5% of the heaviest drinkers in Scotland had increased after the price control was introduced.
The minimum unit price (MUP) alcohol law was introduced in 2018 in Scotland, two years before it became law in Wales.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
“We don’t see enough post legislative scrutiny”, says Russell George, the Tory Health spokesman. So he is saying we need more Senedd members to hold the government to account.
Common sense solution: Legalise class B drugs in Cymru and use the tax gained to pay for services to treat people dependent on substances. Use the new laws to enable R&D of new pharmaceuticals, health treatments and materials out of things like hemp/ganja and mushrooms in Cymru, thus raising investment in the country and providing jobs and, yes, more tax for Cymru….ooh wait we can’t do that can we? Because we are chained to an archaic country that is in pawn to US Multinationals and BAE Systems, silly me,.. No Common Sense Allowed in the UK. Get back to arguing… Read more »
Cheap Gin…worked once, it could work again…A picture of Rees-Mogg on every bottle…
If people are choosing drink over paying their bills it’s likely that they have enough of a problem to apply for health benefit like PIP.
Increasing payments of health benefits would offer support for their bills without indirectly increasing numbers of problem drinkers or advertising harmful illegal drugs instead.
Playing the game of which drugs are good or bad isn’t a great idea. It’s too difficult to wind down freedoms on alcohol but realistically it’s all bad and much worse the more you take/the more regularly you take.
Conservatives encourage street drinking, Big Pharma benzo makers furious.
Quick Artie! Here comes another bandwagon. Try and get your timing right this time eh? Remember last time you jumped too soon and the horses walked over your face. Here it comes. Remember jump on three. One … Two … Three … I said three! THREE! Oh Jesus Christ! Finch Saunders, go pick him out of the road and clean that horse poo off his face will you?