Support our Nation today - please donate here

Welsh farmer condemns Cardiff inaction on sheep ‘slaughter’ after quadrupling of dog attacks

01 Mar 2024 2 minute read
Photo Dafydd Hughes

Figures published this week by NFU Mutual on the cost of attacks on livestock across the UK show that the situation in Wales has gone from bad to worse.

Gareth Wyn Jones – described by the BBC as “the nation’s favourite farmer” – is condemning Cardiff’s inaction over what he says is “the slaughter of defenceless animals on the hills of Wales.”

A year ago the media was reporting that there were four times more attacks than in comparable parts of the UK.

Rise in attacks

Now new figures for Wales show that, just in the last year, there has been a further doubling of attacks.  The increase for the rest of the UK was only 11%.

This means that over the last three years, while attacks on livestock in the rest of the UK were up a third, in Wales there was a staggering four-fold increase in dog attacks.

In his assessment of the figures, Gareth Wyn Jones who farms in Conwy said, “The slaughter of defenceless animals on the hills of Wales has got even worse, yet down in Cardiff the Welsh Government is pretending there is no crisis.

Gareth Wyn Jones

“We must do everything we can to save the dog’s life and the sheep’s life. Allowing e-collars to be used by properly trained people could help reduce the number of attacks.”


Former police dog trainer and founder of the Association of Responsible Dog Owners, Jamie Penrith, says better training of dogs is needed and that the Welsh ban on safe aids such as e-collars needs an urgent rethink.

Mr Penrith from Cornwall said, “E-collar training creates a long-term aversion which stops the dog from ever wanting to approach sheep – even if they have escaped from their homes or owners.

“The Welsh Government’s response of just encouraging owners to use leads is great for training humans, but completely fails to train the dogs. And it is the dogs which have the teeth which are causing so much suffering to Welsh sheep.”

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Barry Pandy
Barry Pandy
1 month ago

Farmers: the biggest bunch of whingers and whiners going. Everything is the fault of the Welsh government according to farmers rather than the fault of individual dog owners. There is something called individual responsibility i.e. dog owners being held responsible for the actions of their dogs, not everything can be blamed on the Welsh government. But then again it is an election year so the tory farmers have got to do everything they can to blame the (not-tory) Welsh government. Brexit should have taught the farmers a valuable lesson: be careful what you wish for. If they think for one… Read more »

1 month ago

“Nations favorite farmer”? OK, he supports the use of e collars, that is electric shock collars, Welsh Gov stops cruel practices and this is wanted back in use? I know people with dogs that would never use these and can control their dogs just fine, that include recall. They also would never let them off the lead near livestock and very aware on what is around when walking dogs. Things appear to be worse after lockdowns. I see more people out and about with dogs out of control and nothing about an electric shock collar would have any effect with… Read more »

Barry Pandy
Barry Pandy
1 month ago
Reply to  Jeff

I wonder how many of the offenders are English tourists out for a jolly in our national parks?

Meri Jós o'r Bala
Meri Jós o'r Bala
1 month ago

Complaint made to the clearly Tory biased BBC asking them to qualify their “the nation’s favourite farmer”statement. I invite others to do the same.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.