News

Welsh Labour’s radical rhetoric ‘not always matched in reality’, says academic

21 Sep 2021 3 minutes Read
First Minister Mark Drakeford AM.
First Minister Mark Drakeford. Mark Hawkins / Alamy Stock Photo

Welsh Labour’s radical rhetoric “has not always been matched in reality”, according to an academic.

Nye Davies, a lecturer in politics at Cardiff University, argued when “a party with a radical history becomes the party of the establishment”, it can lose its radicalism.

In an article for IPPR Progressive Review, he said Welsh Labour politicians often reference the party’s “past traditions and progressive politics”.

This includes hailing the NHS as an “institution forged in Wales representing Welsh principles of community and collectivism.”

He pointed to Welsh Labour politicians regularly invoking the NHS’s founder Aneurin Bevan, “one of Wales and Labour’s most revered figures”.

This he said positions Welsh Labour as a progressive party and “this rhetoric also serves to project it as the party of Wales.”

In his article Nye Davies wrote: “Caveats are needed, however, when we consider that the rhetoric has not always been matched in reality.

“The Welsh government has not always followed its radical and progressive intentions, demonstrated by its policy of providing subsidies to large multinational companies such as Aston Martin (introduced by Drakeford in a ‘for your eyes only’ 007 parody), which later announced significant job losses.

“In fact, Drakeford’s predecessor, Carwyn Jones, invoked the spirit of Labour founder Keir Hardie in 2015 to argue that Welsh Labour needed to be ‘pro-business’, a questionable appeal to a radical socialist politician.

“This gap is further evidenced by lived experiences of Wales’s economy. A report by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation found that, pre-pandemic, ‘almost a quarter of people in Wales were in poverty (700,000) living precarious and insecure lives’, including three in 10 children.

‘Hampered’ 

He added: “It must be acknowledged, however, that the Welsh government’s attempts to follow a progressive agenda have been hampered by Wales’s devolution settlement.

“This has led to a story of Welsh devolution that, in policy terms, has been ‘pretty unimpressive’.

“Even still, these figures do not reflect the aims of a government with progressive intentions.

“These examples are emblematic of the dangers of presentism, an approach to the past that involves the picking and choosing of history in order to serve the present.

“When a party with a radical history becomes the party of the establishment, this history can become so generalised that it loses its radicalism.

“While references to the past are useful, reigniting the struggles of old rings hollow when ambitious action to meet present struggles is lacking.”

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
GW Atkinson
GW Atkinson
1 month ago

All these walls in the way of them getting their policies through the terrible devolution settlement their English party overlords gave them and they are still too cowardly and weak to push for independence.

arthur owen
1 month ago

There is no doubt that the Labour party in Wales started off as a radical sometime revolutionary party,the question is when and why did they cease to be such a party?I suggest it started during the First World War and was intensifed during the second when the party had to deal with the responsibilities (and the perks) of office.One can have their opinion of this but I suggest it is inevitable.

GW Atkinson
GW Atkinson
1 month ago
Reply to  arthur owen

They introduced the NHS straight after WW2, that’s pretty radical, especially with all the toffs, tories and English press totally against it.

Grayham Jones
1 month ago

The Labour Party in have got to stop being little Englanders and and be proud to be fighting for a new wales 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿 A Free Wales 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿 start thinking about your children and grandchildren future in wales 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

Mawkernewek
1 month ago

Isn’t this equivalent to ‘”The Pope is Catholic”, says academic’? Surely academic research is aimed at telling us what we don’t know yet?

Crwtyn Cemais
Crwtyn Cemais
1 month ago

O ble daeth yn wreiddiol y math o ddatganoli sy’ gyda ni ? O’r Blaid Lafur Brydeinig, o San Steffan. Mae angen i’r Blaid Lafur yng Nghymru ymladd yn fwy y tu fewn i’r Blaid Lafur Brydeinig tros Gymru – Er lles ein glwad ni, mae wir angen i’r Blaid Lafur yng Nghymru ddod o hyd i’w hasgwrn cefn hi! ~ Where did the original devolution settlement that we have come from? From The British Labour Party, from Westminster. The Labour Party in Wales needs to fight harder within the British Party for the interests of Wales. For the sake… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.