Support our Nation today - please donate here
Opinion

Before the general election, let’s have some political honesty about the dire state of the Welsh economy

31 Dec 2023 8 minute read
Chancellor of the Exchequer Jeremy Hunt delivering his autumn statement in the House of Commons last month. Photo UK Parliament/Jessica Taylor

Martin Shipton

How many politicians will have the honesty to tell us that we’re entering a general election year at a time when the economic prospects for Wales are, frankly, dire?

Not many, I imagine.

The Conservatives in particular like to pretend that the outlook isn’t as bad as it actually is, and hint at cuts or even abolition of “iniquities” like inheritance tax. The fact that only tiny numbers of people in Wales would benefit is a minor detail.

The important objective is to give the impression that the UK Government can afford to be generous to its citizens – or at least some of them.

This is meant to create a “feel good factor”. Some believe that Jeremy Hunt’s Budget in March, with its inevitable giveaways, will be quickly followed by the calling of an election for May. Perhaps. But I suspect that before committing himself, Rishi Sunak would want to see polling evidence that Labour’s lead was narrowing significantly. So far that hasn’t happened.

Independence

Welsh nationalists have often been accused of failing to grapple with Wales’ real challenges in the here and now by seeing independence as a panacea for all the ills we suffer as a peripheral nation in a centralised UK economy. “We wouldn’t be in such a mess if only we were independent with all the fiscal tools at our disposal,” is the get-out clause and the refrain.

But while it’s always important to take note of the world as it is, rather than how we’d like it to be, I would argue that a more pernicious political fantasy is to disregard the nation’s all too real problems and pretend that things are better than they are, with a view to gaining political advantage.

In the week before Christmas, the Welsh Government published its draft Budget for 2024-25, making it clear that its priority was to protect spending on the NHS and frontline public services. Pretty much everything else would face cuts.

We’ve heard voices raised within the arts sector and the housing sector, among others, warning of job cuts and company closures. Amgueddfa Cymru, responsible for Wales’ national museums, is talking of an existential crisis.

For everyone who wants Wales to be a prosperous nation, it’s important to understand the nature of the plight we’re in. While politicians will inevitably produce their different varieties of partisan spin, there are others who can steer us in a more considered direction.

Senior civil servants

Senior civil servants usually stay behind the scenes, while Ministers prefer to be in the limelight. The officials are happy with that, because if anything goes wrong it’s the Minister who carries the can rather than them. The convention is that technical briefings to journalists about the content of a Budget are given by officials while political on-the-record statements are made by the Minister. That, in line with common practice, is what happened when the Welsh Government’s recent draft Budget was published.

On rare occasions, however, it’s permitted to name senior officials. Accompanying the draft Budget were a number of documents including a report from the Welsh Government’s Chief Economist Jonathan Price. Mr Price does not pull his punches. His report is a sober analysis, based on statistics not rhetoric. At the start of the report it is made clear that it does not represent Welsh Government policy. In other words it is not tainted by political partiality.

These are its highlights:

* Wales is deeply embedded in the wider UK economy, and over the short-term outcomes in Wales are mainly driven by factors which are common to the UK as a whole.

* High and prolonged inflation has eroded living standards, with high energy and food prices disproportionately affecting people on low incomes and other disadvantaged groups.

* By the third quarter of 2023, UK GDP per head had barely surpassed the pre pandemic level, and household incomes remained below that level – four years of lost growth. This compounds a long period of poor performance for the UK economy, stretching back to around the time of the financial crisis [in 2008]. The available data indicates that the economy in Wales has followed essentially the same trajectory.

* Recent data shows a softening of the labour market in Wales and the UK, with an increase in inactivity due to ill health. However, in historical terms, the labour market in Wales continues to perform better than in the 1990s, prior to devolution.

* As of 2023, UK trade intensity remains 1.7% below its 2019 level, versus an average increase of 1.9% across other G7 economies, and the trend in Welsh export performance since around the time of the [Brexit] referendum has been very similar to that for the UK as a whole.

* Although inflation has fallen sharply, the OBR [Office for #Budget Responsibility] expects inflation to remain high for longer than previously expected. The OBR also expects growth to remain sluggish and for unemployment to rise, albeit relatively modestly.

* Low growth, high inflation and tax increases in combination reduce living standards. Real household disposable income per person is forecast to be 3.5% lower in 2024-25 than their pre-pandemic level. This represents the largest reduction in real living standards since ONS [Office for National Statistics] records began in the 1950s.

The OBR forecasts for the UK are broadly applicable to Wales. As the latest data suggests income fell slightly less in Wales in the years following the pandemic’s initial impact (probably reflecting government support measures), incomes in Wales may recover pre-pandemic levels one year earlier than in the UK, in 2025-26. This would nevertheless represent an unprecedented seven lost years of income growth.

* A key long run challenge remains relatively weak productivity, the main long run driver of sustainable increases in pay, prosperity, and the tax base.

* Challenges also remain in the labour market: employment opportunities are restricted for many disadvantaged groups, particularly the disabled, those with long term health conditions, and people with low skill levels.

* Employment creation has been unevenly distributed across Wales. The rapid growth of remote working presents both a new challenge and an opportunity. – the Welsh population has been growing more slowly than in all English regions.

* With the number of deaths exceeding the number of births over recent years, due principally to a low fertility rate, in-migration has prevented overall population decline. – Population change varies across Wales, with a number of local authority areas experiencing a decline in population over recent years.

* The OBR has noted that the UK’s fiscal position has improved since the previous forecast in March 2023. However, this improvement has been mainly driven by higher-than-expected inflation boosting tax revenues. These additional tax revenues have been used by the UK Government to fund tax cuts. No additional funding has been provided to take account of the impact of higher inflation on the cost of the provision of public services. Over the longer term, the value of the new tax reductions is almost equal to the additional unfunded pressure on public services from inflation.

* Beyond the current spending review period, day to day spending is projected to increase only very modestly in real terms and capital spending is fixed in cash terms. This represents a continued severe squeeze on public spending, with a large real-terms reduction in public investment.

* The OBR has also judged that the UK fiscal position is unsustainable over the longer term. This principally reflects the effects of an aging population, compounded by the impact of higher interest rates on the cost of government debt. The OBR also notes additional pressures arising from increasing global security threats and the costs to the public sector of both the transition to net zero and adaptation to a changing climate.

* Further pressures and risks are associated with poor health, inactivity, and the loss of fuel duty revenues without replacement as the UK transitions to net zero.

* Wales is facing similar demographic pressures to England over the coming years. Whether resources are available to meet those pressures in Wales will depend to a large extent on whether the UK Government funds them appropriately in England. The devolved taxes are expected to continue making a positive contribution to Welsh Government finances.

* The large gap between total public sector revenue and expenditure for Wales represents a major transfer to Welsh people through the UK fiscal system. This transfer is the main reason for the gap between measures of household income and GDP in Wales and means that potential UK Government policy choices represent a key risk to Welsh living standards.

Quantitative easing

All the indications are that if, as expected, Labour wins power at the general election, it will maintain the Tory government’s neo-liberal economic approach.

With the current Shadow Chancellor Rachel Reeves running the economy, there are unlikely to be any radical innovations like using quantitative easing to stimulate growth.

Printing money to mitigate the damage to the economy caused by Covid-19 was, it seems, acceptable. But using such a policy choice to relieve poverty and promote prosperity in the post-pandemic period is seen as unacceptable. So much the worse for us.

Meanwhile, in a few months time we can look forward to a charade of an election campaign in which fixing the economy is reduced to unconvincing soundbites and Daily Mail culture wars focussing on migrants in small boats take centre stage.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
9 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
adrian savill
adrian savill
1 month ago

Top class analysis

David Zenati-Parsons
David Zenati-Parsons
1 month ago

Interesting, the policy choices of future UK governments could increase even further the abject poverty some of our citizens already experience. Something for us all to ponder.

Y Cymro
Y Cymro
1 month ago

Wales, Welsh society and economy mirrors UK Labour & Conservative misrule and inaction. They are the ones who have shaped our country over the decades. Unionism has failed our country not Welsh nationalism. Blame where blame’s due. There are many mechanisms available to the English Conservative government at their disposal to aid Wales such as devolving the Crown Estate , devolving full control over over our water resource and giving us HS2 consequential denied so we could ourselves reinvest money back into rebuilding our crumbling road & rail infrastructure, faltering health system and services. If they won’t we should. Both… Read more »

Steve Duggan
Steve Duggan
1 month ago

If/when Labour gets in next year nothing will change, the party is too scared, too timid. To get the UK out of this mess it needs investment that’s how FDR did it in the 1930s US or China has dragged itself out of poverty over the past 40 years. Yes, it will lead to more national debt in the short term but what other choice is there? Investing money makes money and in theory the country will be better of in the longer term. At the moment we are just bumping along at the bottom. Though independence is rather looked… Read more »

Neil Anderson
Neil Anderson
1 month ago
Reply to  Steve Duggan

Steve, after independence, Cymru will have a national debt of zero (with one minor caveat). There will be every opportunity to invest our funds (using QE and otherwise) to focus on the needs of the people, not the wants of the few – the latter the Westminster priority. Over time, we can reduce our dependence on the economy of rUK. The continuation of the failed neo-liberal economy will never deliver for Cymru (and for most in the rUK), and no change is foreseeable until major climatic breakdown forces it. But it will take more courage than we currently appear to… Read more »

Richard H
Richard H
1 month ago

Worth recalling that one of the leading proponents of Devolution, Prof Kevin Morgan, subsequently called post Welsh 1999 economic policy and its performance, “Devolutions dirty little secret” The virtually complete failure of every economic initiative, from Object One onwards, to every “launch today, bury tomorrow”, bolted together program. Techniums anyone? No-one held to account, just “lessons learnt” shuffling platitudes, and on to the next failure. “Fail harder!” Much is linked to the CORE structural economic relationship, “Wales/England/UK/Beyond” listed above, but Wales has also buried its own future by its own hands and by its own self serving evasions. Where is… Read more »

Annibendod
Annibendod
1 month ago
Reply to  Richard H

I personally would not conflate devolution & independence. I appreciate the point you make. I am of the opinion that devolution has thus far failed to deliver what I’d most hoped for – a turnaround in Wales’ economic fortunes. Part of that is the constitutional limitations of the Senedd and Welsh Government. The rest is a product of the lack of vision those governments have had thus far. I agree, an honest appraisal would be valuable. Drakeford, Jones, Morgan & Michael’s governments have frankly been dire. However, what is valuable is that gradually, the experience and infrastructure of governance is… Read more »

Last edited 1 month ago by Annibendod
Dr John Ball
Dr John Ball
1 month ago

As Martin points out, the way democracy works is that officials advise ministers and stay essentially invisible. Since Jonathan Price has made a point of putting his name to the report, a response directly to him is appropriate. His report is full of woe, the UK gets a good number of mentions and by implication the Tory government – a non-political report? Since its establishment in 1999, the one clear duty of the Senedd, together with substantial powers, was economic development. These powers have never been fully used, a series of inept ministers have failed to present a workable development… Read more »

Annibendod
Annibendod
1 month ago

Lots of excellent points raised but perspective needed. Our number one priority has to be the Earth itself. This is what sustains us. All our political, economic and so on activities must be judged in the light of their impact on the Earth. Secondly, the point about Wales being economically (and obviously politically) embedded into the UK is wholly the cause of our emasculation as a people and our inability to materially influence the economic, social and cultural outcomes that matter to us. I’ve long argued that the prevailing centralising, agglomerative London-centric outlook of successive UK governments is at the… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.