Support our Nation today - please donate here
Opinion

Pandemic disruption to education may explain the fall in the number of Welsh speakers at the 2021 Census

16 Dec 2022 5 minute read
Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

Rhian Hodges, Senior Lecturer in Sociology and Social Policy, Bangor University

Cynog Prys, Lecturer in Sociology and Social Policy, Bangor University

The recent 2021 census held unexpected news for Wales. It found the number of Welsh speakers in the country had decreased by 1.2% since the previous 2011 census, from 19% to 17.8%.

This represents an estimated loss of almost 24,000 Welsh speakers between 2011 (562,000) and 2021 (538,300). Despite the introduction of the Welsh government’s language strategy, the number of Welsh speakers in Wales has continued a downward trajectory begun in 2001.

One of the reasons for this decline could be found in the disruption caused to Welsh-medium education by the global COVID-19 pandemic.

Overall, the revitalisation of the Welsh language is seen by many as a story of success.

The 2011 Welsh Language (Wales) Measure gave Welsh equal legal standing with English in Wales. Welsh speakers can access their language on radioon TV and online.

Welsh was even broadcast to the world at the 2022 men’s football world cup, spoken by players at a press conference – and used by Brazilian football legend Cafu in an advert for Budweiser.

This confidence is reflected by the Welsh government’s current Welsh language strategy, introduced in 2017, which aims to have one million people speaking Welsh by 2050.

There has included growth in Welsh-medium education. This sees pupils receive the majority of their school education in Welsh, in many parts of the country. It’s particularly notable in urban locations where Welsh had declined as a community language.

So the recent decline will be troubling for those involved in promoting the Welsh language, especially as the largest decreases were found among school-age pupils. Education is a key strategic theme within the government’s language strategy – which aims to increase the number of young Welsh speakers and see them go on to use their language beyond the education system and within their daily lives.

The 2021 census showed that the largest decreases in the number of Welsh speakers were in the five- to 15-year-old age range. The number of school-age Welsh speakers decreased by 6%, from 40.3% in 2011 to 34.3% in 2021, and the number of three- to four-year-old Welsh speakers fell from 23.3% in 2011 to 18.2% in 2021.

Learning in lockdown

Before the release of the census results, the impact of the pandemic was noted as a possible concern for language acquisition and educational attainment within schools in Wales.

The annual census data collection day was March 21 2021, which followed periods of lockdown and school closures where many families were working and learning from home. School closures had a significant impact on the number of opportunities available to children and young people to learn and use the Welsh language consistently.

New Welsh speakers who had learnt the language in the educational system and did not have Welsh speakers in their households may have been particularly disadvantaged. The pandemic may have led to a loss of skills for some young Welsh speakers over a sustained period of time.

Recent research funded by the Welsh government looked into how the pandemic affected children who were not in regular contact with the Welsh language at home. The study noted that this group would require additional support to get back on track with their Welsh – but also that this is feasible if appropriate support is put in place.

The lack of exposure to the Welsh language may also have negatively affected children’s perceptions of themselves as Welsh speakers. Their linguistic confidence and fluency is likely to have been affected by a significant period of isolation away from Welsh-speaking teachers and peers.

Similarly, this could have influenced how non-Welsh-speaking parents viewed their children’s Welsh language skills. Opportunities for children to showcase these skills were limited, as school events such as sports days and school concerts were postponed indefinitely.

This may have led parents, who complete the census on behalf of their children, to under-report their children’s Welsh language ability.

Generation COVID

There is evidence that the pandemic affected the educational attainment of children and young people on a global scale.

In Wales, the pandemic also highlighted a range of social inequalities based on gender, ethnicity and social class, and has been followed by an increase in poverty. For children who do not have Welsh-speaking family members at home, these factors may have led to inequality in access to Welsh language activities.

The decrease in Welsh speakers can also be attributed to many complex factors beyond the influence of COVID-19. There are fewer people aged under 15 in Wales than there were in 2011, and fewer school-age pupils in the population could dilute the important influence of education on the Welsh language.

However, the reality remains that a generation of children have had their lives and education affected by the pandemic. Further research and a policy response are now needed to assess this impact, and to provide the necessary support for this generation of Welsh speakers in Wales.

Dr Rhian Hodges has received funding in the past from the Welsh Government, The Welsh Language Commissioner, The ESRC, and the Community Renewal Fund to to conduct social research. Dr Rhian Hodges is also one of the Directors of Menter Iaith Bangor, a community language initiative in Bangor, north Wales.

Dr Cynog Prys has received funding in the past from the Welsh Government, Welsh Language Commissioner, The ESRC, and the Community Renewal Fund to to conduct social research. Dr Cynog Prys is a Community Councillor for the ward of Y Felinheli.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

7 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ioan Talfryn
Ioan Talfryn
1 month ago

There has been a lot of discussion following the publication of the census results regarding the Welsh language and, as in this article, the greatest attention was paid to the apparent fall in the number and percentage of children between 5 and 15 who speak Welsh. The reality is that the fall didn’t happen. I’ll use figures for North East Wales to explain that but I could have chosen figures from many parts of Wales to underline this fact.  In 2011 many non-Welsh speaking parents reported that their children could speak Welsh when, in fact, they were not fluent in the language… Read more »

Rhufawn Jones
Rhufawn Jones
1 month ago
Reply to  Ioan Talfryn

Which means that things are actually far worse than they appear, as the above analysis shows that have much less than 17.9% Welsh speakers!!

Huw Prys Jones
Huw Prys Jones
1 month ago

It is certainly plausible that the disruption caused by the pandemic was a factor in the decline in the number of school age children reported as being able to speak Welsh in the Census. However, as I’ve argued in an article in the current edition of Golwg, the 2021 figures are more likely to reflect a certain degree of correction rather than any real decline in this respect. This is because the 2011 and 2001 figures for children were wildly unrealistic when subject to any scrutiny. Moreover, as Ioan Talfryn says in his comment above, the numbers of children noted… Read more »

Welbru
Welbru
1 month ago
Reply to  Huw Prys Jones

Is there a link to your Golwg article please? I can’t buy it where I live.

Huw Prys Jones
Huw Prys Jones
1 month ago
Reply to  Welbru
Karl
Karl
1 month ago

Rubbish, it’s bad wording of the English census.

Rhufawn Jones
Rhufawn Jones
1 month ago

Another reason is colonisation, which our politicians are too scared to tackle.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.