Support our Nation today - please donate here
Opinion

How do we tackle the incidence of childhood obesity in Wales?

11 Nov 2024 5 minute read
Rocio Cifuentes, the Children’s Commissioner for Wales

Rocio Cifuentes, Children’s Commissioner for Wales

Around a quarter of children aged 4 or 5 in Wales are measured as being overweight or obese. These figures should concern us, but they should also not be seen in isolation from their context.

The reasons include the impact of living in poverty; the sedentary behaviours that reflect the impact of technological advances on modern life; the influence and lifestyle of friends and family; and the promotion and consumption of unhealthy foods to children and young people.

But in discussions of obesity and weight, there is a danger in placing too much emphasis on individuals’ own actions and choices. Particularly when it comes to children, the challenges and choices are not with each individual, but are restricted by the society around them.

Childhood obesity in Wales

The deprivation gap in the latest figures is stark, with children living in the ‘most deprived fifth’ postcode areas statistically significantly more likely to be overweight or obese compared to the least deprived. These statistics paint a highly concerning picture of inequality, but weight measurements of children, do not, by themselves, tell us much in terms of how to tackle childhood obesity.

I believe the following are some areas that must be tackled to reduce these figures. Childhood obesity is an indicator of wider health determinants, including deprivation, and measures need to tackle these holistically. This includes considering the crucial role of food and nutrition, and physical activity in determining weight and wellbeing.

Healthy food environments – school meals

One vital part of combatting poor nutrition in children is to improve the quality of the food children eat at school. Public Health Wales has recently published a report on the potential of school food to improve children’s health, which found that the diets of many children and young people in Wales fall short of national dietary recommendations.

They also said that opportunities to improve population health through school food are not being maximised.

This echoes the findings of my own survey on school food, where children talked about small portions and some not always being able to have fruit or vegetables every time they want them.

Welsh Government has committed to reviewing the current regulations for schools on school meals and young people should be actively involved in this process. It’s vital that school meals support our national effort for healthy development in children particularly now that we have universal free school meals for primary school children

Making food environments healthier

I am also highly concerned about the promotion of unhealthy food and drinks to children, including energy drinks.

In September, I asked children and young people what they thought of the proposals from Welsh Government to restrict the promotion of unhealthy foods. Around 60% of children and young people felt that where sugary, salty or fatty food is displayed always or sometimes makes a difference to whether they buy it or not.

Many children and young people mentioned placement by the tills or at the front of shops, and that unhealthy foods ‘caught their eye’.

Neary three-quarters said that deals like buy one get on free made them want to buy unhealthy foods. They mentioned feeling like they had missed out on free food if they didn’t buy them, or being influenced by pictures of the food.

Promotion of unhealthy foods clearly does make a big difference, and young people’s views need to be considered as these proposals are taken forward.

Physical activity

I also wonder whether, perhaps due to the fact that it is easier to collate data on weight, we over-emphasise weight and neglect the fundamental role of activity and exercise in child health.

The most recent Active Healthy Kids Wales report card (2021) paints a concerning picture of poor overall physical activity, with a score in relation to sedentary behaviour ranking Wales as joint lowest (with just three other countries) of the 57 countries that participate.

In 2022, Sport Wales undertook survey of over 116,000 from 1,000 schools. The survey found that there had been a 9% point decrease in children taking part in regular organised sport outside of the curriculum since 2018; an 8% point increase in those reporting no regular participation in sport outside of the curriculum.

It is clear that we must do more to support children to avoid sedentary behaviour and to encourage involvement in physical activity, alongside promoting a healthy diet. Last year, my office called for Welsh Government to ensure the roll out of the Daily Active Programme to schools in Wales. I have also called for local authorities to apply children’s rights impact assessments to their decision-making processes, so that facilities where children can take part in physical activity can be protected.

A focus on the wider determinants of obesity

While a focus on improving the outcomes of children and young people when it comes to their health is extremely important, I urge Welsh Government and others to ensure they emphasise the importance of those wider societal determinants, above any arguments around personal responsibilities, and ensure that children’s health is conceptualized in its broadest sense, to include nutrition and physical activity.

We need to support children and families to make healthy choices and give them the right opportunities to do so.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David
David
2 days ago

Do all primary/secondary schools have or access to playing fields and swimming pools?

Shan Morgain
Shan Morgain
2 days ago

Tax.We need heavy tax on sugared food, drinks, high salt, processed. The timid sugared drinks project has shown t works. NHS overload is a factor. Manufacturers have said they need regulation/ tax from Government level so one of them following the good pathway doesn’t cause market disadvantage compared to others. Sadly this Starmer-Reeves government is robably unlikely to act so we’ll get leaflets tellng individuals what to do. Way back in the 90s I remember a supermarket chain (Asda?) experimented with gradually reducing the salt in their own-brand products over two years. They had no reduction in sales and the… Read more »

Alun
Alun
2 days ago

Kids don’t need access to tablets or laptops at young ages, let them run and explore. The tablet seems to be for the parent’s convenience.

Mark
Mark
1 day ago

Remarkable that the word ‘parent’ doesn’t appear in the article at all. Don’t parents have any responsibility to control what their children eat and how active they are? The only item mentioned in the article that is not in parents’ direct control is school meals. But, as the Jamie Oliver experiment showed a few years ago, because parents have brought up a generation of children on a diet of junk, if you put a proper meal in front of them at school they won’t eat it. All that happened was less children had school meals and more brought in a… Read more »

Walter Hunt
Walter Hunt
1 day ago

It is good to see the 4th Children’s Commissioner for Wales championing this challenging issue. People’s relationship with food is complicated and changing advice of what constitutes healthy eating leaves many people confused. There are many contradictions. Depravation and obesity are linked, but in the same demographic there are children going to school or bed hungry and their families relying on food banks. Education is important and PHW surveys report wide public support for schools taking a lead. The farm to fork food chain touches on so many issues beyond nutrition and wellbeing: global inequalities, food security and sustainability (Jane… Read more »

Jonathan Edwards
Jonathan Edwards
4 hours ago

If there are obese children then, yes, it could be that they are “restricted by the society around them”. Women largely control the way in which children are brought up. When infants of course, but women also rock the cradle and the effects are long-lasting. And very bad. Women are condemned to make a bad job of it because of the way in which feminists have contorted reality and dominated their sisters. The results are awful for children confined to attic rooms and a screen with the father excluded, for women themselve and for all of us. I’m not saying… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.