Lack of education on Welsh history has failed us all
Niklas George
Given that I run a Welsh history website; write/edit a monthly Welsh history magazine and operate a popular Welsh history social media with a combined following of over 60,000 people, you might be forgiven for thinking that I have a long-time, deep-seeded affection for the subject.
On the contrary, I had always found it boring. Criminally, I found it boring all the way until the age of 29, when I was talked into launching the Welsh Histories Facebook page by my wife who, at that time, had never even been to Wales (and had only just learned of its existence through me).
I research all manner of Welsh historical topics to keep our community engaged and this process has taught me just how fascinating the subject is – a hidden gem lying beneath the even larger, more polished and renowned diamond that is British history.
What I have learned over the past 14 months is that it is not the subject of Welsh history that is boring but, sadly, the way many of us were taught it – which means not taught it at all.
I attended secondary school at the now defunct Blessed Edward Jones Catholic High School in Rhyl between 2005 and 2010. Rhyl is not exactly known for being a beacon of Welshness in an otherwise proudly Welsh county and is often wrongfully claimed to be an extension of the Wirral.
Denbighshire, however, is, home to many Cymraeg speakers and boasts a colourful Welsh history, having mostly been a part of the Kingdom of Gwynedd during the height of the Welsh kingdoms.
Nevertheless, during my schooling experience, I learned nothing about this history. In fact, the only bit of Welsh history that I remember learning during my five years at high school (and I did take the subject at GCSE level) was the Romans conquering our Brythonic ancestors; the so-called Welsh Tudor family annexing us and the working-class descendants of the conquered Welsh people being sent to die in World War 1 and World 2. Hardly a patriotic Welsh history, if you ask me.
I learned nothing of Welsh heroes, such as Llywelyn Fawr in the north and Rhys ap Gruffydd in the south. Only recently, while looking for things to write about for Welsh Histories, did I discover the tragic warrior princess, martyr of Welshness that is Gwenllian. Betsi Cadwaladr. I thought that was the combination of two Welsh words used for the local health board – not an actual, brilliant and historic Welshwoman who deserves to be talked about at the same level of her rival, Florence Nightingale.
Yes, we learned about Buddug (Boudica for some) during primary school, but she is often claimed by East Anglia – so we can’t even properly claim her as Welsh, despite her spoken language almost certainly having been Brythonic as opposed to Saxon, Norman or English.
We held prayers for Aberfan but learned nothing of the causes of the horrific tragedy – we didn’t learn anything at all about Welsh mining history.
Instead of realising that Welsh history was so absent from my Welsh schooling experience, I just accepted it was too boring for school. I carried this thought into my A-Levels where, once more, I learned nothing about Welsh history.
For a period of ten years, I knew more about Frederick the Great, Peter the Great and Catherine the Great than I did about Llywelyn the Great. Yes, I was proud of being Welsh during this period – this patriotism is never lacking in Wales – but I was very ignorant of our history to the point where I just accepted there was nothing worthy of being called history outside of a few sporting triumphs.
Following my A Levels, I went to university in Liverpool – after having rejected Bangor, something I regret as I am certain I would have gotten a Welsh history experience here – and chose to specialise in French history. I wrote my dissertation about Napoleon’s Continental System (1806-1814).
Forgive me for saying, but that time could have been better, and more purposefully given how well-covered Napoleon is, spent writing about the subject of Owain Glyndŵr’s Pennal Letter (still in a French museum to this day), sent by the famed Welsh rebel to the King of France during the height of the Glyndŵr Uprising on 31 March 1406.
If I had learned any of this Welsh history during my school experience, I would have almost certainly chosen to study it further as a history enthusiast.
It is not just me – I receive comments, messages and emails daily from people who claim they were shortchanged in the history classroom. While the mandatory inclusion of Welsh history now exists on the Curriculum for Wales since 2022, a great disservice has been done to the people of Wales.
There are tens of thousands of people in Wales who were as I was and most of them will never go through the fortunate awakening that I have. For that, I say shame on those who robbed us of our history for so long and may this mistake never be repeated.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Why is British history SORRY ENGLISH HISTORY rammed down our throats in our schools we have our own history of which goes back around a thousand years before the arrival of the barbaric savages the tribes that where to form England
Labour have ruled us for 25 years, run our education system from Cardiff, they set the curriculum.
Yes i know Labour has been in power in Wales for last 25 years and did nothing before that Wales was run from Westminster some time by Labour mostly by Tory and Liberals it goes way back to the late 1880,s so you are just a Tory or a Reform supporter with your head up your backside and yes labour are partly to blame
It was policy not to teach Welsh history from the Welsh perspective. A great little book is, The Fight for Welsh Freedom by Gwynfor Evans. It’s an easy read.
Sadly the people of Cymru know almost nothing about our history. Who decided to wipe us off the map? Guess who!! When I attended Ysgol Gymraeg Dewi Sant in Llanelli in the 1950s we did learn a little about our history but then on entering the Llanelli Boys’ Grammar Technical School it was all about the glorious triumphs of English kings and queens.
In response to your question ‘Who decided to wipe us of the map?’ my answer would be the Labour party and their ill-founded belief of keeping power at all costs. We all know that if more people knew Welsh history there’d be an increased likelihood that people would vote for Plaid Cymru.
My daughter enjoyed history at school and studied Welsh History at Cardiff University in 1990. At the end of her first term, she came home and exclaimed furiously that she had never been taught any Welsh History and its fundamental role in the history of the UK at either O or A levels. She was extremely indignant, it was a big wake up call for her.
I & many others of my age group will recognise the account you have portrayed in your article Niklas along with a previous article by Stephen Price in NC. My education was through the Monmouthshire Board of education in the 60s/70s. As far as our history lessons went it concentrated on England’s narrative in the main with detours into European history that even then, always seemed to accentuate the relationships & disputes between the ruling dynasties or royal families through the ages. When I left school I could recite the birth date, accessions & deaths of all the kings &… Read more »
Remarkably similar to what I experienced in Scotland.
Monmouthshire has never had a board of education that I know of. In the 1960/70s when I was in school in Monmouthshire there was an education committee which was pretty effective to the extent of offering a school leaving certificate to 15 year olds who did not stay for the CSE exams. There was at that time a national and local debate as to whether the county was in England or Wales and there was considerable animosity towards Wales in East Mon.
Many thanks for the correction EAB, the use of “commitee” was in my mind at the time of writing but for some reason I plumped for “board” instead. I do though remember the talk at the time as to whether Monmouthshire was a part of Cymru or England. If memory serves me correctly this time (fingers crossed) the issue was settled with the boundary reorganisation of 1974 with the implementation of the county of Gwent.
Elin Jones’s book History Grounded brilliantly shows how 5,000 years of Welsh history is all around us and where to look for it – it’s packed full of interesting stuff and is an easy read. Recommended
(And it’s aimed at schools…)
Libraries, Ladybird Books, even comics and Tell Me Why / Look and Learn for those of a 1960s disposition – and curiosity – why always wait to be told an official partial version of history? We should be taught to take responsibility for our own learning from an early age.
This would be a good idea. However, in my experience in Scotland’s neglect of my country’s history to her own people, I had very little knowledge other than Robert the Bruce, winning independence for Scotland in 1314. EVERYTHING else I know I had to meticulously research myself. I was an avid reader – and still am – and there was NO history at all taught that explained Scotland’s role in UK history. So, this is not just a Welsh thing. The blame lies squarely at the colonists door. There should be pressure exerted on government to demand tuition of Celtic… Read more »
Would be nice to live in Wales/Cymru where the vast majority of Welsh children and adults know more about e.g. Owain Glyndwr and Hywel Dda than Henry VIII and his wives…
Being born into a military family I went to lots of different schools in lots of places. My history lessons were all from an English/British perspective (especially history post 1706 ) As I’ve got Older I’ve realised how important a subject like history is. How can we really avoid making the same mistakes if we don’t learn from our past. When you look at the History of the ‘unification’ of Britain it’s not that different from the ‘unification’ of Europe. If we’d been taught true British history would we be more understanding as a nation? After all is seeking Independence… Read more »
This argument often comes up, is Welsh independence really any different to Brexit? Well, simply put, yes it is, and there are reasons aplenty. For one, the EU has never imposed laws upon us (all EU laws were accepted and approved by Westminster), can we say that for Cymru? Then there’s the real reason behind Brexit, bigger profits for big business, via (believed) less regulation, is that the reasoning behind the seeking of Welsh independence? Whereas Brexit is a nationalistic cause, Welsh independence is a patriotic cause. No one living in Cymru is excluded from the vision. Unlike Brexit, Welsh… Read more »
There is much written about how awful the Welsh Not was, and its impact on the Welsh language – justly so. What isn’t written about is the Labour party in Cymru via its education policies/political interference in the school curriculum denying our children being taught Welsh history. The Labour party over the last 100 years are the true villains in this story, they will go down in history as promoting Britishness at the expense of our own history being taught in Welsh schools. It is time we called them out for what they’ve done to our country!
The first labour majority government wasn’t until 1945, so to claim it is responsible over the last 100 years is incorrect. The blame for most of that time rests with the tories!
Like many here I was taught nothing about Welsh history in school. It was not until I went back to college at the age of fifty that I started to delve into the subject. We had to write an essay about our favourite Welsh person. Whereas, many wrote about Tom Jones or Gareth Bale, I chose to write about Owain Glyndwr and it opened my eyes. Not just to the lack of Welsh history being taught in schools but how our neighbour has really treated us for centuries. As a nation we should make Welsh history a priority in our… Read more »
Please can we stop referring to Owain Glyndwr as a Welsh rebel – this is merely perpetuating the English subjugation of Cymru. It is my understanding that Owain Glyndwr was Prince of Wales or a King – please correct me if I’m wrong.
Can you stop using AI ‘art’?
I thought the current thinking is we all have to be ashamed of our history and therefore must “decolonise” everything and re-imagine that all historical figures must be portrayed by any ethnicity other than the original.
Welsh history comes nowhere near the category that you have mentioned
I’m in my early/mid twenties and very much remember being taught welsh history in llanidloes, lots of our time was dedicated to llwellyn ap gruffydd & owain glyndwr. Although I have a feeling that was largely due to how passionately welsh our history teacher was!?
I see they did not teach you to use capital letters where necessary in Llanidloes though.
Fully agree. The new Welsh national curriculum is supposed to address this, but I’m not convinced it will. I hope so, but I think we need to be vigilant
I have a blog where I share the true Welsh history and debunk stupid myths like glyndwr killed as many Welshmen and Welshmen fought for English against llywelyn , IV also proved the “Welsh fought eachother more than anyone else” to be wrong but I keep getting dismissed as a nationalist . Why is promoting Welsh history nationalism?
as a welsh born person, i was born in 1950. i was taught english history in school. but i the good fortune to be able to read about our welsh history at home. my grandfather had purchased history books so was able to learn all i wanted..
There is a misapprehension about Florence Nightingale, Betsi Cadwaladr and Mary Seacole. There is a Blue Peter John Nettleton idea that all three are equivalent heroic nurses. In fact they are all interesting women but for different reasons. Florence Nightingale was an upper class English woman with a university level education who did study nursing under Lutherans in Germany in order to establish quality nurse training in the UK. In effect she was really a hospital educator and administrator using science to validate her work. Mary Seacole was actually a traditionally trained physician and nearer to a doctor than a… Read more »
A bit like BCUHB seems to enjoy being a Health Board but doesn’t really do the job
I would describe the english-centric “british” history as a polished turd not a diamond!