Support our Nation today - please donate here
Opinion

Reading the runes of the King’s first Christmas broadcast

26 Dec 2022 4 minute read
King Charles III during the recording of his first Christmas broadcast. Photo Victoria Jones PA Images

Ben Wildsmith

A glance at my previous columns will reveal my feelings about royalty so don’t @ me, but Chazza’s first bash at a Christmas speech seemed well judged to me. Striking a contemplative tone, the novice monarch managed to touch on a number of issues that unify us at this time of year, and crucially, without conveniently ignoring the desperate state of the nation.

The remaining acceptable royals ‒ Camilla, William, Kate, Edward, Sophie, and Anne were shown off in a predictably Disneyfied montage of caring activities to illustrate Charles’ central theme of public service. Andrew, Harry, and Meghan have, of course, been airbrushed out of the picture Soviet-style, and it was rictus grins and empathy frowns all round for the remaining cast as they engaged with the great unwashed for the cameras.

In his first address to the nation, the day after his mother’s passing, Charles was at pains to emphasise that his days as a gobby critic of the body politic were at an end now that he had assumed the throne. In that same speech, however, he unnecessarily installed William as Prince of Wales, completely evading any political scrutiny as even Plaid Cymru felt too inhibited by the etiquette of mourning to object. Since then, he’s kept his hand in politically by using sarcasm to provide a thin cloak of deniability.  Here he is eviscerating Sir Jeffrey Donaldson of the DUP whilst casting the royal glow of approval over Sinn Fein’s Michelle O’Neill.

Complicated

And this is the thing with Charles: he’s a complicated man. Given that the DUP’s raison d’être is loyalty to the Crown, you might expect Charles to favour them over the organisation whose armed wing assassinated his uncle. Whatever is going on in that clip, it seems to come as a surprise to all involved except the lad himself.

The Christmas message had a hint of subversion, too, if you cared to look. On the surface, Charles’ message was about unity and service. These are the touchstones of the modern royal schtick and the favoured tropes for justifying their continuance in national life. So far, so Elizabethan. It didn’t take him long to put his own stamp on proceedings, however.

Having related his experience in Bethlehem to underscore his own faith, he named other religions as the equal of his own and explicitly extended his message to include those of no faith. He characterised Christmas as a celebration of light overtaking darkness which, as anybody with a Jethro Tull album knows, is a decidedly Pagan interpretation of the festival. For years, Charles has said that he intended to be a defender of the faiths and on his first yuletide outing, he seems to have come good on that ambition.

Whilst the section on service fulfilled a clunky PR role for the slimmed-down Firm, it also featured an extended tribute to public service workers. The armed forces were mentioned first, but extremely briefly and that, of itself, drew a distinction with the Duke of Edinburgh’s directorial choice to place Her Maj between tanks like a cross between Rambo and your nan.

NHS and care workers

Charles’ vision of service extended to the NHS and care workers. Interestingly, footage of ambulances was used to illustrate this and it’s difficult to believe that the palace was unaware of the contention this might provoke during the current disputes. As he paid tribute to ‘health and social care professionals, our teachers and indeed all those working in public service, whose skill and commitment are at the heart of our communities’ one could imagine the consternation in Downing Street.

Charles, it seems, is going to be a handful. As public sector disputes spread in the New Year we will doubtless see government rhetoric intensifying as the Tory administration seeks to discredit the strikers, calling into question their patriotism and wider motives. Despite polls showing 70% public support for the strikes, Keir Starmer’s opposition is committed to treading an imaginary middle line which they are convinced will win over floating voters.

So far, the only ringing endorsement of public sector workers has come from a king who seems to recognise that he is one himself. He has positioned himself as an embarrassment to the right, who profess loyalty but disagree with everything he says, and the left who agree with his positions but believe in the abolition of his role. For politicians, Charles looks set to be a right, royal pain.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

14 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
AntonJacques
AntonJacques
1 month ago

I visibly and audibly sighed when I saw the prince and princess of Wales in front of a little girl in a Welsh outfit. It was a complete unapologetic scene of these people look over the Welsh, get used to it. They’re so young.

Why wasn’t it a scene of them speaking to Wales football fans? Or being at the Eisteddfod?

Mab Meirion
Mab Meirion
1 month ago

I thought he was trying to give his new prime minister a few pointers in the humanities dept and his job description, less Kali more Shiva…

Mab Meirion
Mab Meirion
1 month ago
Reply to  Mab Meirion

This morning’s Chunkymark on utube makes a comment or two on this subject…

Riki
Riki
1 month ago

You mean the “King of Englands” Christmas message!

Jonathan Edwards
Jonathan Edwards
1 month ago

“Christmas as a celebration of light overtaking darkness” is not just pagan, it is Christian also. Yes Carlo may well turn out to be awkward in 2 ways. Not only Christian but male as well. The Monarchy functions better in its own terms when the Monarch is female: EiR, VR, EiiR, long reigns, boat not rocked. You wait, Charles III will trigger people. Lot of unaccountable soft/actual power. Wales needs to get him on side for Indy. Dominion status a no-brainer. Keep Monarchy, get 90% Indy. Miles ahead of where we are now.

Mawkernewek
1 month ago

The actual first Christmas probably didn’t happen in the middle of winter, the shepherds wouldn’t have been up in the hills then.

Y Cymro
Y Cymro
1 month ago

I’d rather poke my eyes out than listen to anything he says. This is a man who soon at great cost to the public purse will on his coronation pledge allegiance to the people he allegedly serves when he couldn’t even be loyal to his dead wife Dianna with his marriage vows or to the country he was made Prince of in 1969. He’s a untrustworthy disloyal adulterer. And to rub salt into an already open wound, he like a mafia don placed his balding England fan son William and grinning clothes horse wife Kate as Prince & Princess of… Read more »

Last edited 1 month ago by Y Cymro
Mab Meirion
Mab Meirion
1 month ago
Reply to  Y Cymro

Someone said that to me about him 25 years ago after that someone had banned him from their mid-Wales retreat…

Reginald Bowler
Reginald Bowler
1 month ago
Reply to  Y Cymro

“Dianna”

But you can’t even get her name right.

AntonJacques
AntonJacques
1 month ago

Great article

Cynan again
Cynan again
1 month ago

Never watched QE2’s speeches. Won’t be watching Chucky 3’s speeches either. Not my monarch, why should I care?

Mawkernewek
1 month ago

William was pictured repeatedly. Maybe Charles is going to get bored with kinging after a little while and abdicate?

David Harking
David Harking
1 month ago
Reply to  Mawkernewek

I reckon he has about 20 years left. Cymru probably has bigger fish to fry but for now the Monarchy fuels independence. If you believe in equality (as most people do, in Wales) then you can in no way justify half a sand grain of support for this cult of wealth, undemocratic institution to which we are all subservient.

hdavies15
hdavies15
1 month ago

People can derive any sort of comfort they like from that speech as reported above. That’s what they have always done is chuck a bit of goodwill in all directions thus reducing the all round pressure to put them out of work. He’s had over 50 years of adult life learning from the doyenne of manipulation. E2R was good at it in a somewhat different way. Only rarely did people care with sufficient intensity to denounce her and they were often turned upon by others who should have shared in the rebellious, contrary outburst. All highly manipulative abuse of emotion… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.