This pandemic is the moment tech giants have been dreaming of – even I’m shoveling my data online
Mike Parker
Like most middle-aged people, I’m finding the technological demands of this pandemic to be quite a challenge. I’d happily settled into my online rut, principally a filthy Twitter habit, and then suddenly I’m having to master horizons I’d never even contemplated.
As a belligerent Facebook refusenik, there was no going there, but in order to talk to my family and my neighbours I’ve had to cave in and download WhatsApp. Its opening page proudly reminds me every time that it is ‘from Facebook’, so really, all those years of picturing myself as the Lone Ranger have come to a big fat zero; Zuckerberg and his little hippety-hoppety minion Clegg are now in full possession of my soul. My only compensation is that they’re going to be sorely underwhelmed by what they find there.
At the beginning of the crisis, WhatsApp groups sprung up like digital Dad’s Army brigades, and each with its own distinct personality. We live between two different villages. The WhatsApp group for one, the more agricultural community, is brisk, practical and firmly to the point. The other, for a post-industrial village brought back from the brink by incomer romantics, is sweet, chatty and heavy on the emojis. Its greatest explosion of life so far has been when everyone clubbed together to order a mammoth delivery of organic cheese.
The WhatsApp group for the wider area took itself very seriously indeed. Our small town of two and a half thousand people was divided into colour-coded zones, like post-1945 Berlin, each with a delineated chain of command and accountability. Requests were fired out, orders barked and questions posed as to whether anyone had heard reports from the outlying villages, as if they lay not across a few sweet green fields, but the far side of a smouldering, post-apocalyptic no-man’s-land.
Zoom
In fairness, marshalling such a large number needed some sharp organisation, and the town group has been brilliant at co-ordinating information leaflets, shopping and support rotas and even the production of PPE for local healthcare workers. There is though the undeniable sensation that its modus operandi comes from blokes who’ve lost large chunks of their life playing World of Warcraft.
It’s a feeling only confirmed in another unwelcome digital intrusion, the Zoom meetings. Oh god, the Zoom meetings. Off he goes again, holding forth into his laptop like it’s the conch of power in Lord of the Flies. How on earth do you keep concentration? Where do you look? It’s bristling with spyware of course, and keeps tabs on who’s paying attention, so you really have to try to maintain some sort of focus. I end up zoning out on the ornaments and pictures in the background, and if that fails, hitting cancel and sending a message that sorry, the internet has crashed again. That this is entirely plausible may be the only upside to crap rural Welsh broadband.
Actually though, sometimes I feel that our eternally terrible broadband may well be our saving grace. This is the time that the tech giants have been dreaming of. Recalcitrant rural grumps like me are swept aside in a headlong rush to greater surveillance – all for our own good, of course. And it’s almost impossible to resist. That age-old drivel – “those with nothing to fear have nothing to hide” – comes newly kitted out in camo fatigues and medals bought on Ebay, clapping loudly on the doorstep for NHS heroes, but still voting for the people that sent them to the frontline unequipped and alone.
Over the last month, almost all of us have shoveled yet more of our data into the arms of the state and the tech multinationals. Be reassured though, by English Health Secretary Matt Hancock, who told us yesterday that “all data will be handled according to the highest ethical and security standards…and we won’t hold it any longer than is needed.”
And for those of us who aren’t so good at reading the small print, and who tick the I Agree box with indecent, guilty haste, he’s even prepared to write it on the side of a bus.
Read more in Mike Parker’s series for Nation.Cymru below:
Part 1: We’ve been told before that things will never be the same again – can we mean it this time?
Part 2: Last weekend’s pandemic-panic awayday was inevitable – but so was the visceral response
Part 3: Will we use this crisis to rediscover the value of community – or for more suspicion and othering?
Part 4: The BBC needs to start listening to doctors – not government spin
Part 5: In a pandemic, fake news can become a lightning conductor for our fears and frustrations
Part 6: Could the pandemic bring us all back together while keeping us apart?
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
“Zuckerberg and his little hippety-hoppety minion Clegg…” is a quite jaded comment.
Surely you would want a devoted Liberal (whose core beliefs promote liberty and anti-surveillance) working a top position at Facebook?
Hear hear
not the one who once sold his soul to David Cameron?
The top dollars he receives seems to keep him from speaking out on any Liberal causes. Have you heard him speaking up in favour of Edward Snowden for example?
Someone, who started university 2012 or later, on his salary would pay back less in student loan repayments than someone who gets a regular middle class job, thanks to interest.
I would indeed want that, but the coalition years led me to the view that Mr Clegg’s convictions have a certain bendable quality. He can certainly talk the talk and he may well believe what he says, intellectually. But in the real world – unlike his courageous if flawed predecessor Charles Kennedy – his instinct is to follow the master. If it was thus with Cameron, why would it be other with Zuckerberg??
Clegg’s convictions ? That’s an oxymoron unless he got nicked by the Old Bill for something not known to me. He has a record of being utterly pliable, blows whichever way the wind of power ( and money) goes. Was it Marx ( Graucho not Karl) who said something like … “those are my principles, if you don’t like them I got plenty more..”. Clegg to a T.
I don’t think that that there’s much sold difference between us, despite the ostensible superficialities.
There are ways of staying in the loop of social media and avoiding surveillance capitalism, but of course, being less commercial the applications are less well known and less well used. A replacement for Facebook is Diaspora, but it is virtually unknown, and ‘everyone’ is on Facebook. Sadly people seem to be willing to leave their virtual doors unlocked whilst at the same time becoming more and more paranoid about their physical security, ironically turning more and more to surveillance capitalism to ensure their security using Alexa and Ring! And given the widespread knowledge that Zoom is fundamentally insecure, why… Read more »
That is very helpful information. Never heard of Diaspora or Signal before but I’ll have a look.
“I’m from the government and we’re here to help you”, “it’s only temporary and you’ve nothing to worry about anyway as long as you aren’t doing anything wrong.”
Famous phrases from the past.
Diolch, Padi.
Diolch am yr info, diddorol