Support our Nation today - please donate here
Opinion

We need to unchain the dragon

15 Nov 2024 6 minute read
Picture by the National Assembly (CC BY 2.0)

Farrell Perks

I have long held radical political beliefs, advocating fiercely for an independent Wales—a sovereign nation free from the tyranny of monarchy and capitalism. Yet, I wasn’t always the staunch defender of Welsh identity that I am today.

This transformation didn’t stem from a change in ideology, but from a deeper understanding of the political and cultural history of these storied lands. In many ways, I am what some might call a ‘convert.’

Born in the West Midlands, I was uprooted to Wales on a parent’s whim at a young age. Although I proudly consider myself Welsh, captivated by the beauty of its landscapes and the richness of its culture, there are still those who question my Welshness. A conflict I once struggled intensely with, though I pay it little mind these days.

It is against this backdrop that I became radicalized by the treatment of Wales, not just in the distant past but in the present day, as it remains shackled to England like a colony. Our economy is treated as a resource to be exploited, our people neglected, our culture systematically erased.

No voice

It was Michael Sheen who first opened my eyes to the harsh reality of the hand dealt to the Welsh people. As a fledgling independent journalist, I was already aware that something was deeply wrong. The apathy that clung to our communities, not just towards politics but towards Wales itself, was suffocating.

Then, I stumbled upon a speech Michael Sheen gave in support of Welsh independence. His words were like a lightning bolt, illuminating the injustices I had only vaguely sensed.

“The towns and villages that grew up around the coalfields and ironworks are being beaten down and forgotten, seemingly even by the political party born out of its struggles,” he said. “As the dazzling promises of ‘Britishness’ grow more hollow with each passing Welsh budget day, we are left with the realization that the world reshaped itself, and we were, after all, left behind.”

That speech changed me. I resolved to take a more active role in reclaiming Welsh culture and society, a culture I had only recently begun to embrace fully. It became clear, as I looked deeper, that the levers of power across the UK are rigged against us. The Crown Estate profits from our lands, Westminster siphons off our resources to fund “England & Wales” projects that do nothing for us.

We are constantly told we’re too small, too poor, too weak to seek our independence. This narrative has been drilled into us so thoroughly that, as Sheen puts it, “When we wake up to the dangerous position we’re in, we open our mouths to warn each other, only to find we have no voice—because we never got to build one.”

Yet there is, as Sheen says, a dragon on our flag for a reason. Dragons soar on the magic and mystery of the past, terrify with their fiery wrath, and symbolize a spirit that exists in our hearts. But in the realm of Welsh democracy, the dragon rarely roars. We have a fierce national spirit when it comes to sport, but when it comes to our political future, apathy reigns.

Failures of the Established Left

Whilst we struggle on the ground, trying to scrape by on what little we have left, our jobs gone, our industries gutted, our communities disconnected by a crumbling infrastructure, what do the ‘established’ left offer us in return? Empty platitudes and a half-hearted promise to kick us a little less hard while we’re down.

Every time we manage to free ourselves from the chains of those intent on taking everything from us, whatever banner they happen to be wearing this time, our chosen saviours fall flat. They settle only for a desperate attempt to undo the damage done by those before them, never daring to dream bigger or push further. Click, click, click goes the ratchet, grinding us ever further to the right as we watch helplessly, caught in the gears of a system designed to crush us.

And why, you may ask, is the left so allergic to real progress? Greed and complacency. Labour has sat at the top of the Welsh government for decades, pocketing salaries ranging from £60,000 to £150,000 a year, plus expenses, while presiding over the hollowing out of our nation. They tell us, time and time again, that “things are hard economically,” and so more services must be cut, more communities abandoned.

They offer us nothing but the cold comfort of managing decline, the cynical lie that this is the best we can hope for.

Make no mistake, there are those within left-wing parties in Wales who genuinely wish to change the system, but until the parties they call home begin to reflect their ideals, they are, quite simply, pissing into the wind. The spectre of political apathy looms large, and all the parties seem content to shrug it off, muttering that nothing can be done, as voter turnout shrinks, as fascists thrive, as our democracy slips further from our grasp.

The Slow Death of Democracy

This brings me to the concept of the “ratchet effect” in politics. It’s a simple yet devastating phenomenon: it is far easier for political parties to shift right than to shift left. The rhetoric and policies of the right are often easier to implement, cheaper for the wealthy, and simpler to sell to a fearful populace.

Each populist policy passed by the right drags the entire political spectrum further right, forcing the left to fight battles on terrain that favours their opponents.

The left’s fear of radical change, their reluctance to challenge the status quo, has positioned them as little more than caretakers of a broken system. They are content to tinker at the edges, to play the role of moderates, to be the managers of a declining nation. But we need more than managers. We need revolutionaries.

We are shackled to the bloated corpse of an empire that continues to drain us dry. But we do have levers—if only we had the courage to pull them. We can invest in our future, in the people of Wales, in our industries, in our communities.

It won’t be easy, it won’t be cheap, but it’s necessary. Because the alternative is more of the same: a slow death by a thousand cuts, a gradual slide into irrelevance.

We are not too small. We are not too poor. We are not voiceless. It’s time we realize that the dragon on our flag is more than just a symbol—it’s a call to action. Let it roar. Let it burn away the apathy, the complacency, the chains that bind us. Wales deserves better, and it’s time we demand it.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
23 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Elizabeth Jeffreys
Elizabeth Jeffreys
1 day ago

Thank you this is an excellent article, one I totally support. I am convinced that Wales could have a successful future as an independent nation. A visit to Slovenia population 2.12 million with a GDP of 68.2 billion USD where I witnessed the quality of life they now enjoy gave me the confidence to believe this was realistic and feasible for Wales. Our population 3.1 million and GDP 85.4 billion British Pounds. We need Michael Sheen to lead the campaign to make this a serious proposition

Clive Thomas
Clive Thomas
1 day ago

This has to the best written call to action I have read in a long while. It captures the managed decline that is Labour’s only remaining option. Their complacency is self-serving and time limited. Wake up Wales for God’s sake!

Robin Huw Crompton
Robin Huw Crompton
1 day ago

I could not agree more with your analysis. Well done!

Frank
Frank
1 day ago

Very well said. Stand as a politician in Cymru and I’ll vote for you. Writing about the plight of Cymru is a good thing but you need to get into the Senedd. We need people like you.

S Duggan
S Duggan
1 day ago

The article is dead right – now is the time for belief in ourselves. It’s time the Dragon was unshackled and allowed to roar! Yes, a charismatic leader could lead the charge but we also need many charismatic individuals. Within Plaid there is the seeds to this revival, many believe, now is the time they got braver.

Richard Jenkins
Richard Jenkins
1 day ago

Diolch! So well expressed! This is what our nation needs! More of how we can & less of why we can’t!
We are big enough, clever enough, rich enough.

J Jones
J Jones
1 day ago

As mentioned previously by many, Ireland is showing the way forward, though it’s taken a century for them to convince their own young people to remain in their own country and prosper.

The capital required to run a country does however require the level of capitalist economy that they and all prospering countries have. Showing contempt for any capitalism will just make the electorate think of a horse and cart economy and North Korea.

A fully independent country should mean everything to us, but extreme socialism will stop it happening, so we have a choice to make.

Neil Anderson
Neil Anderson
1 day ago
Reply to  J Jones

The only future worth having is going to be more equitable (read ‘socialist’), more peaceful (read ‘socialist’) and more free (read ‘socialist’).

J Jones, only small-scale capitalism (read ‘enterprise’) could possibly contribute to this. Most enterprise won’t be about money anyway, but about culture and ecological restoration.

Capitalism – in its latest neo-liberal form – has failed to do anything much except accelerate trickle-up to The One Percents – the TOPs. They – and their trumpets in the media – are very, very fond of capitalism though… Quite a brake on progress really.

J Jones
J Jones
1 day ago
Reply to  Neil Anderson

Unfortunately, regardless of whatever spin they put on it, socialism to many simply means work avoidance. The idle rich in England prevented our independence and the idle poor now in Cymru will also prevent our independence.

What annoys me most is that many of the latter have actually come from England in search of a lazy lifestyle, forcing many talented ambitious Cymru out of our country.

Neil Anderson
Neil Anderson
4 minutes ago
Reply to  J Jones

That’s a very facile description of socialism, J Jones. Did Aneurin Bevan inspire ‘work avoidance’ among generations of NHS staff? Try A&E any night and check for yourself…

But I find it difficult to identify the people of Cymru, always pro-socialist, and the other peoples who have chosen to live here, in any of your slapdash criticisms.

Must try harder!

John Ellis
John Ellis
1 day ago

‘We are constantly told we’re too small, too poor, too weak to seek our independence.’ The same warning was delivered to newly independent Ireland a century ago, but it seems that most Irish citizens were too angry and/or resentful about their centuries-long domination by their larger neighbour across the Irish Sea to be greatly deterred by it. And they did have to endure half a century of practical austerity before, by the end of the 1970s, a larger proportion of Irish folk began to experience greater personal prosperity. Anger and resentment can certainly be encountered in contemporary Wales, where rather… Read more »

Neil Anderson
Neil Anderson
5 hours ago
Reply to  John Ellis

If we maintained the UK neo-liberal model, John Ellis, austerity would be inevitable post-independence, and probably as badly-managed, with maximum interference from London. But there are other models – we could, for example, rebuild the economy around peoples’ needs (which I favour), we could enhance wages, benefits and pensions. We could focus on self-sufficiency, especially for food to the extent that is possible. We could employ large numbers of people in upgrading housing, especially insulation, and build many more. We could improve intra-city and regional transportation with light (sic) Light Rail and cycleways. We could upgrade the education system to… Read more »

John Ellis
John Ellis
3 hours ago
Reply to  Neil Anderson

You present an attractive and appealing vision, but inevitably it would be one that established interests and their media allies would seek to immediately and comprehensively rubbish. And their ability to convince enough folk to back manifest lies and nonsense was made all too clear eight years ago. On the one hand it’s now possible, in our nearest and pretty conventional market town, to gather twenty to thirty people to demonstrate in support of Yes Cymru and for an active local branch of that organization to flourish. I can’t imagine that being the case fifty years ago. On the other… Read more »

Last edited 3 hours ago by John Ellis
Linda Jones
Linda Jones
1 day ago

I completely agree with this article. I would only add that democracy requires a free press and we do not have one thus making it problematic for the left to get the message out to the people. To build a movement. We are constantly fed the right wing neo liberal agenda of today’s politics. Nation Cymru is an exception to that rule.

Jack
Jack
1 day ago

Let’s stick to the real world. Wales will not become an independent nation as there is no interest in the idea at Wetsminster and it holds all the cards, In fact there is a positive disincentive at Westminster – give Wales independence then that means Scotland would also be independent. The reverse also applies. And the UK would be no more. NO major party at Westminster can countenance that idea – such a party would be detroyed at elections. So the world of real politics says there is not a snowball’s chance in hell that Wales will ever be independent… Read more »

John Ellis
John Ellis
1 day ago
Reply to  Jack

‘And the UK would be no more. NO major party at Westminster can countenance that idea – such a party would be destroyed at elections.’ Five years ago I’d have agreed with you there. But within the last couple of years a serious polling company published research gleaned from surveying political opinions of a representative sample of English Conservative voters and had found that a majority of them favoured an independent England shorn of the ‘Celtic fringe’, which they appeared to view as a never-ending drain on the generous English taxpayer. I was amazed. Indeed, I still am, but it’s… Read more »

J Jones
J Jones
9 hours ago
Reply to  Jack

Jack, you got caught on here trying to deny that Charlie was pocketing money from our land, so I’ll add this to ‘what you want to believe’ rather than what may become reality.

Anything is possible in the future of this rapidly changing world. Many said Ireland would never be independent of England and how many would have predicted their economy now outperforming what is left of the UK.

WilliamsG
WilliamsG
1 day ago

Well written and moving article.

Shan Morgain
Shan Morgain
23 hours ago

Diolch for power paean. I like the roaring of the Ddraig. But as you say it’s time – so let’s see complaining dumped and instead have some writing about the nuts and bolts. We know the economics work.So what are the practical steps to get from here to THERE?

Stephen Morris
Stephen Morris
22 hours ago

I was interested in the quotation “it is far easier for political parties to shift right than to shift left” because I think that’s actually the opposite of what happens in practice. Robert Conquest’s famous Second Law of Politics states “Any organization not explicitly and constitutionally right-wing will sooner or later become left-wing” and I think that’s really the case: Plaid and the Conservatives have both drifted far over to the left over the last ~30 years or so, which is why neither of them have any answers to how to rebuild prosperity and fairness in our generation. Elsewhere on… Read more »

Gwyn Hopkins
Gwyn Hopkins
22 hours ago

Jack says “there is not a snowball’s chance in hell that Wales will ever be independent”. This is, indeed, an amazingly reckless prediction for “ever” means an infinitely long period of time! This was the sort of comment made by the London media in relation to each of 100 or so English colonies before independence. About 15 remain with Scotland and Wales being by far the largest. Why is it that Northern Ireland is legally permitted (by the Good Friday Agreement 1998) to hold an independence referendum if there is sufficient demand for it whereas Wales and Scotland are not? 

David RJ Lloyd
David RJ Lloyd
20 hours ago

i think at these times this is a wonderful discription of what we have missed & what we must do for our welsh futures survival. a joy to read

westisbest
westisbest
2 hours ago

The best article I have read here! You have captured what a lot of us feel. Wow!

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.