Support our Nation today - please donate here
Opinion

Welsh Government is hellbent on dodging scrutiny of a Wales-only Covid inquiry

04 Mar 2022 5 minutes Read
Wales’ First Minister Mark Drakeford. Picture by the Welsh Government

Tom Giffard MS, Welsh Conservative Shadow Minister for Culture, Tourism and Sport

One-in-four people who died from coronavirus in Wales were infected in hospitals.

Wales has the highest death rate of any other UK nation, while measures such as Covid passports were controversial and ineffective.

Those are just three reasons why Labour ministers in Cardiff Bay should launch a Wales specific public inquiry into their handling of the pandemic – but the list is as long as my arm.

Mistakes have been made by governments of all hues across the globe during this unprecedented crisis, but Labour here in Wales are hellbent on dodging scrutiny.

Instead of admitting mistakes were made and allowing full scrutiny to take place, Labour ministers are still too scared to hold one and are instead hiding behind a UK-wide inquiry.

Quite frankly, it is scandalous. People up and down the country who have lost loved ones and have been affected by restrictions since the pandemic began deserve answers to their burning questions.

Decisions made in Cardiff Bay – both good and bad – had a direct impact on lives in Wales and cannot be dismissed by a Labour administration that was keen to stress at every opportunity that they have done things differently.

If First Minister Mark Drakeford is so confident in the actions of his government, then why is he against having them examined in a Wales-specific inquiry?

That’s the question many people across Wales will be asking themselves. Just what has this Labour administration in Cardiff Bay got to hide?

This avoidance of scrutiny – in the face of public scandals such as delays to testing in care homes and hospital discharges into care homes – should sound alarm bells.

If the Labour Government is truly going to learn lessons should we have to face a new pandemic, it must hold a Wales-specific inquiry.

Drakeford’s nationalist friend in Scotland, Nicola Sturgeon, has commissioned an inquiry to look into her government’s actions.

Ignore what happened in Wales

However, Drakeford is still trying to escape scrutiny and instead wants to have his government’s actions confined to a single chapter in the UK-wide investigation, and due to failings in our media they will focus on the decisions made by ministers in Whitehall and ignore what happened in Wales.

But this Labour government has always been keen to dodge scrutiny from the very beginning of devolution.

In April 2020, Labour’s Jenny Rathbone asked then health minister Vaughan Gething questions about the pandemic during a virtual plenary session.

Gething, who is now in charge of our economy, replied: “What the f**k is the matter with her.”

And even on non-Covid matters, the Labour Government has been avoiding scrutiny with a string of damning reports involving the Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board.

A recent report into its vascular services found an amputee’s wife had to carry him to the toilet after being sent home without a care plan, and that follows the release of the long-suppressed Holden report which revealed a “culture of bullying” at the Hergest Unit.

The health board has been plagued with problems for years, with damning reports into the deaths of two patients published last month – highlighting further failings in mental health services in North Wales.

When questioned by the Welsh Conservatives on the vascular services report in the Senedd, the First Minister failed to clearly apologise for the major failings.

There is certainly a theme emerging with this Labour administration.

Some of the things in need of proper scrutiny are Labour’s use of the ineffective Covid passes, discharging care home residents back into their homes without a Covid test and thousands of incorrectly addressed shielding letters being sent out.

On Labour’s watch, children in Wales have lost out on the most learning and the country has seen economically cruel and clinically unnecessary restrictions in an overzealous attempt to tackle the Omicron variant.

Failure 

The failure to regularly test NHS frontline staff and allow large scale events to go ahead as initial cases rose at the start of the first wave also need to be thoroughly investigated through a Wales-specific inquiry.

Sadly, the First Minister is making a mockery of the parliament and the country he professes to love. Labour ministers should not be able to use emergency powers and the widest use of devolved powers ever and think it is okay for them not to be scrutinised and be held accountable.

Not only would a Wales-specific inquiry play a key role in examining Labour’s response to the pandemic, but it would also ensure lessons are learnt for the future.

We are not alone in our calls for a Welsh probe, with groups such as Asthma UK and the COVID-19 Bereaved Families for Justice Group also wanting to see Labour’s decisions go under the microscope.

Len Lambert died separated from his wife of 60 years. Sharon Jones died after catching Covid in hospital. Phil Smith died alone, separated from his family. Their loved ones have questions and need answers. That’s why they and others formed the bereaved families group, are now asking for a Wales inquiry.

Grieving families deserve answers, and that can only be delivered by full and independent scrutiny of the decisions taken by the Labour government in Cardiff Bay through a Welsh coronavirus inquiry.

Nothing else will suffice, and it’s high time the Labour administration commissions one.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
18 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Calum
Calum
2 months ago

Surprise, surprise, a Tory making things up to put Wales down instead of looking at the actual facts and calling his own masters in Westminster out on their disasterous handling of this pandemic.

3rd line in, he states that “Wales has the highest death rate of any UK nation”. It took me literally 2 minutes to find the actual death rate per 100,000:

  • England – 249.2 deaths per 100,000
  • Wales – 221.3 deaths per 100,000

That’s from https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/deaths

No such thing as an honest Tory

Paul
Paul
2 months ago
Reply to  Calum

A political party should not be allowed to push such a blatant lie. The Tories have been doing so on their official page for over a year.

Mark
Mark
2 months ago
Reply to  Paul

I think you’ll find the tories have been lying since their inception.

Erisian
Erisian
2 months ago
Reply to  Mark

Nah, that was the Whigs

Erisian
Erisian
2 months ago
Reply to  Paul

It’s Boris apeing Trump apeing Putin, and then just a case of flunky see, flunky do

Kerry Davies
Kerry Davies
2 months ago
Reply to  Calum

Totally shameless, this guy will go far in the Tory party.

hdavies15
hdavies15
2 months ago
Reply to  Kerry Davies

I think Suzy D had a brat called Calum. Suzy was/is on the decent end of the Tory spectrum, that’s why she was displaced on regional list. The brat is an entirely different species of scum.

Erisian
Erisian
2 months ago
Reply to  Calum

Certainly when looking for any stick to beat Welsh Labour they would not let a fact get in the way, why a lie supports their bias.

Ieuan Evans
Ieuan Evans
2 months ago

Whoever this person is I would suggest that he engaged his brain before making such outrageous comments.

hdavies15
hdavies15
2 months ago
Reply to  Ieuan Evans

I tagged my reply to you onto Kerry above. Sorry.

Gareth
Gareth
2 months ago

With the Tory’s in Cymru supporting Englands actions during the pandemic, and urging Mark Drakeford to copy and follow what they were doing, why then isn’t the English lead inquiry sufficient.I would support his call if they were to come across as being sincere, but with their record, I just dont trust the motives behind this call. Putting Cymru or it’s people first, is not in the Tory make up.

Mark
Mark
2 months ago

When are the tories going to release the Russia report or the report looking into the dodgy deals they’ve done with the Saudis or the really upto date report on how most of them including the head t*t himself broke the social gathering law over covid lockdowns, really think all tories should wind their stupid necks in.

Erisian
Erisian
2 months ago
Reply to  Mark

All good points but the “yeah, but, what about…” defense is seriously naff.
We went our own way, and we should have our own enquiry.
I thouroughly support Mark Drakeford on almost everything except his belief that the Union can be redeemed and is worth saving, but we can all learn from any mistakes made in Wales if we are brave and honest enough to examine them.

NOT Grayham Jones
NOT Grayham Jones
2 months ago

What is Drakeford so scared of, this is nothing to do with party politics its about accountability which he obviously is frightend of.

Gaynor
Gaynor
2 months ago

Agree, there shld be a Wales only inquiry, Welsh Lab want the praise but not the responsibility

Richard
Richard
2 months ago

For once you have a valid point NGJ 🥲

Quornby
Quornby
2 months ago

Johnson started the only Covid scandle with his “herd immunity” nonsence. Everyone knows that.

Alan
Alan
2 months ago

I agree that Cymru should hold it’s own enquiry regarding the pandemic if only to highlight why we diverged (correctly) from the disastrous policies being put forward by an inept & mendacious Tory party at Westminster at that time. Of more concern now though, is the repeated lie being trotted out by Tories both in Cymru & over the border stating ” Wales has the highest pandemic death rate of the home nations”. This was said again on Friday after Mark Drakefords presentation by none other than yes, you’ve guessed it, our very own R.T.Davies when asked for his view… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.