Opinion

Why the revival of Welsh became a model for minority languages across the globe

26 Nov 2021 5 minutes Read
Speak Not: Empire, identity and the politics of language by James Griffiths / Hawl i Fyw Adra signs Llŷn Peninsula

James Griffiths

On a day this September, I drove from Ynys Môn down the Llŷn Peninsula, to a hill overlooking Pwllheli, in search of the site of one of the most important events in the revival of the Welsh language.

It was here, 85 years earlier, that three men set fire to a half-built bombing school, intended for use by the Royal Air Force as Europe barrelled once again towards war.

The burning of the bombing school and the trial that followed galvanised both the Welsh nationalist movement and the movement in defence of the Welsh language. In particular it raised the profile of one of the arsonists, Saunders Lewis, a professor at Swansea University and founder of Plaid Cymru.

While they objected to the bombing school on pacifist and environmental grounds, Lewis and his two fellow arsonists — D. J. Williams and Lewis Valentine — were mainly concerned that an RAF base would bring English workers and soldiers into one of the most Welsh parts of Wales, at a time when Cymraeg was headed towards terminal decline. The bombing school represented, in the words of one critic, a threat to “one of the few remaining homes of Welsh national culture.”

Llŷn today would appear to validate those fears. The former site of the bombing school is now a caravan park catering to English tourists, and tensions over English-owned holiday properties on the peninsula are reaching heights not seen since a wave of arson attacks in the 1980s and ‘90s. As I drove out of Llŷn, I passed two giant red signs reading, in Welsh and English, “No more second homes” and “The right to live locally.”

Tynged Yr Iaith

And yet, the Welsh revival movement that was driven in large part by the burning of the bombing school — and boosted significantly by a speech Lewis gave in 1962, “Tynged Yr Iaith,” in which he called for direct action to demand legal protection for and recognition of the Welsh language — has been successful beyond its instigators’ wildest dreams.

When Lewis gave his 1962 speech, he warned that “Welsh will end as a living language, should the present trend continue, about the beginning of the twenty-first century.” By the time he died in 1985, at the grand age of ninety two, there was a secretary of state for Wales, Plaid had sent nine members of parliament to Westminster, the Welsh language was properly recognised in court, and there was a flowering of activism and cultural activity across the country, supported in part by new publicly funded television and radio channels in Welsh.

According to official statistics, today some 880,000 people speak Welsh in Wales, and the country is well on track to hitting the target of a million speakers by 2030. Younger generations have never known a Wales without Welsh at the forefront, and have a confidence and pride in the language not seen for over a century. The revival of Welsh has not only benefited speakers of that language: it is used as a model and inspiration by communities around the world as they seek to protect and revive their own minority tongues.

These efforts can fuel wider movements towards decolonisation and autonomy for minoritised communities. In Hawai’i, the (partially Welsh-inspired) language revival has helped shape a cohort of Hawaiian speakers who are leading the fight to protect native lands and rights. Nor is it a coincidence that the generations who grew up speaking Welsh in schools are among the greatest supporters of Wales’ independence from the United Kingdom.

Languages survive or perish based on politics

Languages survive or perish based on politics. The Blue Books, a series of reports commissioned by Westminster which led to the suppression of Welsh in the 19th century, were produced in response to growing worker unrest in Wales. Hawaiian was suppressed following the islands’ illegal annexation by the United States. In Hong Kong, where I live, the fate of Cantonese is teetering in the balance, as efforts to preserve it in the face of encroachment by Putonghua (Mandarin) risk being seen as Beijing as secessionist, sparking a backlash that could speed up Cantonese’s decline.

Growing up, while I learned about the suppression of the Welsh language, this was never connected with other communities’ similar experiences, nor was there any mention with how the revival of Welsh inspired and was inspired by efforts to protect other minority languages. For a long time, one of the strongest criticisms of the Welsh language movement, and the nationalist movement more generally, was its insularity, an instinct to look backwards and bemoan a lost past. Even as other minority language communities looked to Wales for inspiration, Welsh speakers could be ignorant of those they should have been building solidarity with.

Ellis Vaughan, a student at the University of Bangor, told me that when he was growing up, “it was so often emphasised that we had something unique and different” in the Welsh language. While this was intended as a way of celebrating the ancient tongue, it cut young people off from a pro-indigenous rights and minority language movement that spanned not only Europe, but the entire globe.

“When I started studying other Celtic languages, I almost got annoyed, “ Vaughan said. “You don’t have to go far to find a whole slough of minority languages who have typically suffered very similarly in the past and have a similar fight ahead of them.”

“I remember wishing that we would have been taught that we’re not the only ones doing this. That we’re not alone in this fight.”

This is an edited excerpt from Speak Not: Empire, identity and the politics of language by James Griffiths (Zed/Bloomsbury 2021).

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
7 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dafaydd Paidaphoenicont
Dafaydd Paidaphoenicont
1 day ago

Beth am gynnau tan fel y tan yn Llŷn? beth am gynnau tan fel y tan yn Llŷn? tan yn ein calon, a than yn ein gwaith, tan yn ein crefydd, a than dros ein hiaith.

Last edited 1 day ago by Dafaydd Paidaphoenicont
Y Cymro
Y Cymro
22 hours ago

Revival is a little misleading. It gives the impression that it was dead before given life once more. Cymraeg has never gone anywhere., it’s alive & kicking , even though it has been attacked continually over the past 2000 yrs.

But I’m so proud that custodians of Cymraeg maintain our language and culture, and how its survival against all the odds had inspired other speakers of minority language to keep their mother tongue alive.

Yma o hyd! #CariadCymraeg ❤️🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

Malcolm rj
Malcolm rj
20 hours ago

After the introduction of the Welsh not in schools by the English government to try to kill of the Welsh language and culture it’s a miracle that the Welsh language has survived against all odds

Paul Reynolds
18 hours ago
Reply to  Malcolm rj

It wasn’t introduced by the English government.

Individual Welsh teachers chose to use it.

Last edited 18 hours ago by Paul Reynolds
Malcolm rj
Malcolm rj
6 hours ago
Reply to  Paul Reynolds

The Welsh NOT may not have been the law from the English government but they didn’t stop the school’s from doing it to the Welsh children and why were the school’s in Wales only allowed to teach in English and also you had to talk English in all public buildings they were doing everything possible to kill off the language and our culture

Wrexhamian
Wrexhamian
4 hours ago
Reply to  Paul Reynolds

Yes, some Welsh teachers used the Welsh Not, as part of their mandate to make English the language of education in Wales in accordance with the specific instructions in the 1870 Education Act. France did something similar regarding schools in Britttany. Unlike the French, we have moved on from those dark times, thanks in large measure to groups of brave and committed young people who put their careers and personal freedom on the line in the 1960s and 70s. Wales owes them a huge debt of gratitude.

Erisian
Erisian
6 hours ago

Despite being an avowed aethiest I think we should acknowledge the enormous debt we owe our the Welsh churches, Welsh speaking musicians and Sain for showing anyone with the sense to listen what an incredible language Welsh is.
As Dylan Thomas said
‘Praise the Lord! We are a Musical Nation’

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.