Support our Nation today - please donate here

Why voting tactically for a different party may be the best way to support your own

10 Dec 2019 5 minute read
Image by Mohamed Hassan from Pixabay.

Huw Prys Jones

Whatever their differences in aspirations, every opposition party going into Thursday’s election has one thing in common – they need a hung parliament as the outcome.

Their objectives and policies will come to nothing if the Tories win an overall majority in the early hours of Friday morning.

It is also patently obvious that a hung parliament cannot be achieved by one party alone. Labour, Plaid Cymru and the Liberal Democrats must understand that whatever their attitudes may be towards each other, they must develop a symbiotic relationship if they are to succeed.

Likewise, even their most fervent members and supporters must also realise that the way they cast their vote must depend on where they live. In some places, the best way to support one’s own party may well be to vote for another.

It is clear that a hung parliament is the only way to avoid giving a blank cheque to Boris Johnson to do as he likes. And the only hope to avoid the kind of fully-fledged Brexit that has become an article of faith for the Conservative Party.

If there are Labour members who still hope for a majority government under Jeremy Corbyn, I suggest they seriously consider a visit to planet earth. Any Labour members squandering their votes by voting for their own party in Powys, for example, are jeopardising Labour’s chances of forming a minority government by risking Tory victories.

Recent reports increasingly suggest that the same may also be true in Ynys Môn.

It is also utterly bizarre to see Labour bringing members in to campaign in Arfon when they could be trying to defend or gain seats from the Tories.

On the other hand, with no prospect whatsoever of a majority Labour government, Plaid Cymru and the Liberal Democrats must see the advantage of any Labour advance where they have no chance of winning.

Any Labour gains against the Tories in those seats will be of direct benefit to them, by increasing the chances of a hung parliament.

For that reason, it was equally bizarre to see a Plaid Cymru politician in a story on Golwg360 yesterday campaigning in the Gower constituency. This is a Labour/Tory marginal held by one of the most consistent supporters of a People’s Vote among Labour MPs.



It will be easy for Plaid members and supporters to vote tactically for the Liberal Democrats in a few seats in this election, as the party has already made the decision for them in the Unite to Remain pact.

Their task has also been made easy in the Vale of Glamorgan where they can vote to unseat Alun Cairns without a Plaid or Lib Dem candidate there.

The real challenge for Plaid (or Liberal Democrat) supporters will be in those Labour / Tory marginals where their own parties run. This is where they will have to take matters into their own hands and make a hard-headed choice.

Be it in Cardiff North, Gower, Pembrokeshire or north Wales constituencies outside Ynys Môn and Gwynedd, supporters of the Unite to Remain alliance could well be in a position to help unseat the Tories if they vote tactically for Labour in sufficient numbers.

Many will rightly question the wisdom of giving their faith in a party that has been so equivocal towards Brexit over the past couple of years. Many will also recoil at voting for a party that has given succour to many anti-Welsh sentiments over the years.

Nevertheless, in the numbers game of this election, we also need to be cynical and ruthless in our alliances if we are to have any hope against the Brexit establishment.

Such a tactical vote for Labour in those constituencies would not mean that Plaid or Lib Dem supporters are letting down their own parties in any way. On the contrary, they would be empowering their MPs with far greater influence by helping to secure a hung parliament.


At the last election in 2017, it is worth noting that the combined votes of Plaid and Labour would have been enough to unseat five Tories in Wales.

It is true that one of the five, Guto Bebb, effectively switched sides to become a committed People’s Vote supporter during the last parliament.

In terms of the other four constituencies, however, just think how much more valuable four additional opposition members would have been to Plaid MPs over the last couple of years than the votes amassed for their party in those Tory seats.

National totals of votes may well be the subject of interesting articles by political academics, but are in reality of little significance. Like it or not, under the first past the post system, it’s only the number of seats won that count and it really is a matter of winner takes it all.

Party allegiance and loyalties run deep and especially at election time. Many of us in Plaid will think of the selfless commitment of past members who worked tirelessly to build a national movement in Wales.

To honour these past generations, it is surely incumbent upon us to ensure that we put our votes to maximum use at this election.

What we have in the Tories is an extreme anti-European and xenophobic party led by a shameless liar who is utterly devoid of any morality or decency. The kind of contemptuous English nationalist mentality that underpins their Brexit appeal must be seen as a direct threat to our identity and values.

For the future of Wales, a key consideration when we cast our votes on Thursday has to be which candidate in our local area is best placed to beat them.

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gwylon Phillips
Gwylon Phillips
4 years ago

Pressure here in Preseli Penfro to vote Labour to oust Stephen Crabb. I will not be tempted. I will vote for Cris Tomos, the Plaid candidate and for my Country, CYMRU.

4 years ago

I share your sentiments Gwylon and I know exactly where you’re coming from. Plaid always gets my vote because when I sing the words ‘Pleidiol wyf i’m Gwlad’ – I mean it. However, for the first time in my life (and probably the last) I’m seriously considering voting Labour because in Aberconwy in 2017 the Labour candidate came very close to defeating Guto Bebb so there’s every possibility of a Labour win this time round. This really is an exceptional election and as far as Wales is concerned Corbyn is slightly the lesser of 2 evils (although I would never… Read more »

Jonathan Edwards
Jonathan Edwards
4 years ago
Reply to  O.R

Totally agree and sympathise

Jason Evans
Jason Evans
4 years ago

Well said Gwylon, totally agree with you. I’m in Preseli Pembs and Cris gets my vote. I hear a lot of people, I mean a considerable amount saying ” I would vote for Plaid but I they’re not in a position to challenge labour and the Conservative down here”. The thing is if all these people actually voted for Plaid then they could quite easily challenge both of these parties.

Jonathan Edwards
Jonathan Edwards
4 years ago

I suggest you man up, and take a grown-up decision like an adult. Noone is asking you to like or trust Labour in Preseli. But it is the least bad option for a Welsh Nationalist in highly marginal Preseli in 2019 under the broken UK system. Contrary to what lots of Pembs folk think, Brexit is bad for Preseli and Wales. And the Brexit crisis is the nearest thing to a war that you and I will see. It is very sad that Plaid has had since the 1930s to produce an independent-minded middle of the road candidate to win… Read more »

vicky moller
vicky moller
4 years ago

Also in preseli and impressed by this articles valid points
I am doing the bizarre., voting cris tomos plaid as he is the most outstanding candidate representing the long term solution of community empowerment for a green inclusive world
However I am giving people doorstep info leading them to vote labour
And my family and friends are voting labour with broken hearts
And labour are not offering anything by way of respect or reciprocity, no surprises there
Totally respect the article and all thinking this way but my very long term spectacles show a different perspective

Jonathan Edwards
Jonathan Edwards
4 years ago
Reply to  vicky moller

Why are you doing something that is admittedly “bizarre”? Wouldn’t you feel better doing something rational? All I know about Cris Tomos is that he’s introduced a fiddly recycling scheme and he seems happy to let Crabb win in Preseli. Latest poll shows Crabb 8 points up in Preseli. Plaid and LibDems predicted to get 8 points between them. So their standing lets Crabb win.??!! By the way, Plaid’s job is not, when the chips are down, to get “community empowerment for a green inclusive world”. Plaid’s job is to get Indy. When we’ve got Indy will be the time… Read more »

4 years ago

The author must be inhabiting some form of parallel, sado-masochistic universe with his dreams of a hung parliament and yet more gridlock and gamesmanship at Westminster. And wilfully blind to the reality on the ground that Labour’s red wall is crumbling on a daily basis in Labour’s traditional heartlands. Dozens of seats will fall to the Tories on Thursday, with perhaps the Brexit party helping themselves to a few seats as well. Interesting to consider that Labour’s perceived lack of patriotism and their ‘Britain’ s crap’ narrative could be one of the reasons for this. Within such a scenario, the… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.