Support our Nation today - please donate here
Feature

Mr Gething’s resignation came about through the force of serious journalism. That’s something we in Wales should celebrate

16 Jul 2024 7 minute read
Vaughan Gething making the announcement he was quitting as Welsh First Minister after four members of his Government resigned. Photo PA Video/PA Wire

Martin Shipton

Delusional to the bitter end, Vaughan Gething – who has resigned as Wales’ First Minister – continues to protest his innocence of any wrongdoing.

He may have lost the confidence of the Senedd, of his own party and of the Welsh public, but none of that was his fault, he would have us believe.

According to him, his downfall was “politically motivated” and inspired by racism.

His diehard supporters may find it convenient to swallow his self-pitying narrative. The rest of us take a more realistic view of what he has done.

He accepted donations totalling £200,000 from a waste disposal business. What was extraordinary about this was not simply the staggering amount of money involved for an internal party election, but the fact that David Neal, the man who owns the waste company, had received two suspended prison sentences for dumping toxic sludge in the sensitive wetlands landscape known as the Gwent Levels.

Error of judgment

Despite Mr Gething’s protestations that he had “done nothing wrong”, most people took the view that he had made, at the very least, a serious error of judgment in taking the money.

Concerns intensified when it became clear that he had been lobbying Natural Resources Wales – the environmental regulator – to go easy on one of Mr Neal’s companies. It also transpired that another of his companies had received a £400,000 loan from the Development Bank of Wales, the Welsh Government-owned bank that was overseen by Mr Gething at the relevant time in his capacity as Economy Minister.

Not to mention the fact that on the very day Mr Neal’s company donated £100,000 to Mr Gething, another of his firms submitted plans to build a giant solar plant to a Welsh Government body.

Not once has Mr Gething acknowledged that there may be a perception that he was compromised by accepting Mr Neal’s money or that he had a potential conflict of interest.

Deleting messages

No one forced him to accept money from Mr Neal and nor did anyone but Mr Gething himself write during the Covid crisis to ministerial colleagues, telling them he was deleting messages because they would be disclosable under the Freedom of Information Act.

In deleting the messages he was disobeying explicit instructions from the Welsh Government to preserve as a record messages that might, indeed, need to be disclosed under FoI. Subsequently Mr Gething misled the UK Covid Inquiry by stating in sworn evidence that messages were deleted not by him, but by the Senedd’s IT department when his phone was refitted.

Since February, when it was first disclosed by NationCymru that he had accepted £200,000 from a convicted criminal, the Labour Party has dithered about what to do about Mr Gething.

He was elected leader of Welsh Labour in March and days later as First Minister. From the first day he took office he has been under scrutiny by the Welsh media. As the revelations kept coming, everything else in Welsh politics took a back seat.

The opposition parties picked up on the latest exposes, but privately many people in Welsh Labour were also concerned and increasingly disenchanted with Mr Gething as leader.

He sacked a minister, Hannah Blythyn, wrongly accusing her of being the source of the leaked messages to NationCymru. Even some of his own supporters were shocked by the disdainful way in which he treated Ms Blythyn, whose mental health was affected badly by her unjust dismissal.

‘Gimmick’

Mr Gething was defeated in a vote of confidence, but refused to resign, accusing the opposition parties of participating in a “gimmick”. Many saw this as an attack on the integrity of the Senedd and its parliamentary procedures.

Yet still the Labour Party tolerated his continuation in office. Why?

Initially there was tribal loyalty coupled with inertia, and a recognition that Mr Gething’s relatively small number of supporters in the Senedd group would kick up an almighty fuss if moves to remove him were made.

When the general election was called, there was a further motivation: nothing should be allowed to cause a distraction during the election campaign. But concerns didn’t disappear, and Mr Gething’s behaviour became an issue on the doorstep.

Opinion polls showed there was a differential in voting intention for the UK Parliament and for the Senedd, where the next election is due in May 2026. While Labour had enough of a lead in Wales to ensure that it won 27 of the 32 seats on July 4, its support in a Senedd election dropped to just four percentage points above Plaid Cymru, most of whose votes traditionally come from the Welsh-speaking west and north-west of the country.

The drop in support was attributed to the unpopularity of Mr Gething, whose approval rating slumped to lower than that of Rishi Sunak, the outgoing Prime Minister of a discredited Tory government at Westminster.

That, coupled with the fact that all three opposition parties said they would not help the Welsh Government – which lacks a majority – pass a Budget if Mr Gething remained First Minister, led to the events that forced him out. Finally spurred into action, four senior Cabinet members told him to go and when he refused to do so they resigned, forcing his hand.

It may be that Mr Gething received a call from the Prime Minister’s inner circle, advising him to go. He’s far more likely to have complied with a request from that quarter than a democratic vote of the Senedd.

Discredited

Hailed when first elected as the first Black leader of any European government, Mr Gething will leave office as a discredited figure who lost control of his own narrative, and whose ambition and arrogance greatly exceeded his talent for leadership.

In an age when fake news and conspiracy theories have increasing cachet for many, Mr Gething’s resignation came about through the force of serious journalism. That’s something we in Wales should celebrate.

However, despite announcing his intention to go, it seems he is in no hurry to do so. It appears that he and his close supporters are hoping to prolong his departure. Instead of the seamless transfer of power to Rhodri Morgan that took place in 2000, when Alun Michael, the first failed leader of post-devolution Wales was ejected from office, they want to spin it out over the summer, with Mr Gething still in place as a caretaker leader.

Huw Irranca-Davies is being touted as a potential challenger to Jeremy Miles, who would be the obvious successor. Anyone who stands against Mr Miles would be seen as the continuity Vaughan Gething candidate – hardly a good thing to be right now.

The anger among Mr Gething’s supporters in the Labour Senedd group – and apparently they were in fury mode during the meeting that followed his resignation announcement – is not reflected amongst the wider party membership or even MPs.

Many who voted for Mr Gething are shocked and appalled at how the situation has played out.


Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

20 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
westisbest
westisbest
4 months ago

Diolch Nation Cymru. Actual journalism for Wales

Padi Phillips
Padi Phillips
4 months ago
Reply to  westisbest

Nation Cymru should demonstrate how vital an independent media is in order that our democracy remains not only held to account, but actually viable. Clearly we need more, and I think the Senedd should at the very least give some consideration to the grant funding of independent journalism so that our democracy remains both robust and strengthened.Much could be learnt from the system in place in Norway. We also need to the return of investigative journalism on both BBC and ITV. It’s great having Y Byd ar Bedwar on S4C, but what of BBC Cymru and ITV Wales? As it… Read more »

Fi yn unig
Fi yn unig
4 months ago
Reply to  westisbest

Any of Martin Shiptons’ fabulous and forensic articles on this debacle would work but I would have loved for THIS one to have been read out in full immediately after Gethings’ pitiful, denial filled resignation speech. Maybe that would focus the minds of those who disgrace themselves, their party and Y Senedd by supporting him. The one thing I expect of Starmer is to implement zero tolerance of such behaviour. He failed his first test here.

Che Guevara's Fist
Che Guevara's Fist
4 months ago

I have to admit it, I am seriously impressed with the level of journalism from NationCymru. When you’re used to the propaganda and just downright awful crap that routinely comes our way from English occupation “media”, our very own homegrown talent is certainly an amazing change from all that.

Gething can’t and won’t accept being held to account and would rather flex his narcissism in pretending to act the victim. Good riddance to him and his corruption. This is how you deal with that corruption: bringing it into the light. This is what real journalists do.

Di iawn!

Liz Justice
Liz Justice
4 months ago

Celebrate excellent journalism because it is rare. Well done guys

Garry Jones
Garry Jones
4 months ago

Serious journalism indeed, from Martin Shipton, Ben Wildsmith, and Emily Price these past weeks. Forensic, persistent, and a credit to Nation.Cymru. 
If VG had shown contrition before today, perhaps even a qualified mea culpa, then given time there may have been a way back for him to a place in government. This seems unlikely now. VG’s pride seems to have secured his fall. 

Mawddwy
Mawddwy
4 months ago

Fantastic stuff as always M.S.

The despicable race card act needs to be called out repeatedly.

If it’s been difficult for his family then it’s been absolutely unbearable for the rest of us and handily catastrophic for Welsh Llafur.

Up the Republic.

Last edited 4 months ago by Mawddwy
Ann
Ann
4 months ago

Wasn’t there also an issue during the Labour leadership election regarding the fact that one union (was it Unite) only sent Gething’s information to their members who had a vote because of the political levy?

Crystal
Crystal
4 months ago

nice

Daf
Daf
4 months ago

Fair play Nation Cymru. If Gething’s supporters can’t see what the rest of us can, then support for Welsh Labour will drop even further. I wonder about Gething’s advisors as well. His whole campaign and brief leadership has felt mismanaged and very out of touch with public opinion. Not to even acknowledge the poor optics of a donation from a convicted environmental criminal shows very poor judgement. Gething has to take responsibility of course – but Welsh Labour need to have the guts to root out the advisors and staff who’ve done such a bad job too.

Marc Evans
Marc Evans
4 months ago

Diolch i Martin Shipton, (possibly Wales’ last professional investigative journalist? I hope not) Today saw the sad but inevitable outcome of a sad and bad set of circumstances, with the Welsh government, the Labour party (not just in Wales) and above all, Mr. Gethin culpable of a casual regard for the principles of public life, service and integrity. You have diligently uncovered the truth which none of the above particularly wanted disclosed. Without your work we’d still be in the dark. I noted some of Gething’s Senedd colleagues urging us to accept his resignation as an end to the story,… Read more »

John Davies
John Davies
4 months ago

Of course the accusations against Gething were “politically motivated” Everything in politics is. There is nothing wrong with this. For a politician to somehow pose as being outside of or above politics is bizarre. It is also very unattractive, a claim to somehow not only stand above politics but to stand above ordinary people as a sort of hopefully benevolent lord. Politics is the process whereby we try to keep the rascals honest, so congratulations to Nation Cymru for its journalism. Bizarre too is Gething’s contention that he had done nothing wrong. Sweetheart deals with deeply venal private individuals and… Read more »

Linda Jones
Linda Jones
4 months ago

Excellent journalism from Martin Shipton and Nation Cymru, may it continue. Without it we may never have known about the corruption at the heart of government in the Senedd. Labour in the Senedd seem to believe that anything goes as long as no one finds out. Morally bankrupt in my opinion, a party in power in Wales stuffed full of incompetents, totally devoid of any vision or ideas for our future. Hopefully they are on their way out.
Keep up the great work Nation Cymru

includemeout
includemeout
4 months ago

I almost feel sorry for him (note, I said “almost”). All those hard years climbing the greasy pole. I’m sure he saw himself, once his time as FM was over, becoming a sort of Welsh Mary Robinson, getting all the big international jobs that were due to a “trailblazer”. There’ll be none of that now. He’ll just have to join all the other failed leaders on the lecture circuit, and who’s going to pay to hear him explain how he only lied and cheated within the rules?

J Jones
J Jones
4 months ago

Just like to also add my appreciation to Nation.Cymru for the reasons described here. In time it should help drive away the unwanted characters polluting politics and maybe even attract the quality people that is sadly lacking.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.