Support our Nation today - please donate here

Accepting hospital patients into care homes ‘has led to doubling of Covid-19 deaths’

28 Apr 2020 5 minute read
Picture by Matthias Zomer

A social care leader says news that care home deaths from Covid-19 have doubled is “utterly shocking but not surprising” because the virus has been imported into them by patients discharged from hospital.

Mario Kreft MBE, the chair of Care Forum Wales, said the newly-published figures from the Office of Nationals Statistics (ONS) were an indictment of the failure to lock down earlier and harder.

Accepting hospital patients into care homes had, he said, played a major role in enabling the spread of the infection at such an alarming rate.

The report from the ONS showed that in the week ending April 17, there were 119 deaths from Covid-19 in care homes in Wales, compared with 56 deaths the previous week.

According to Mr Kreft, the lag in publishing the statistics meant the situation now was likely to be much worse with an even greater number of Covid deaths in care home.

Mr Kreft said: “The fact that the number of care home deaths from covid has more than doubled within a seven day period is utterly shocking but sadly not surprising.

“The true situation will be even worse than these new figures suggest because of the time lag in publishing them.

“We can also see a clear increase in care home deaths during the last few weeks – not all of which mention Covid on death cert but likely there are more that are hidden.

“We have seen an increase in the number of care home deaths where Covid is not mentioned on the death certificate up from 95 in the week ending on March 13 to 183 in the week ending April 17.”



Care Forum Wales has for weeks calling for the publication of the numbers to ensure transparency and also to identify the true scale of the crisis so it can be tackled more effectively.

The organisation, which represents more than 450 social care providers in Wales, has also warned that half the 650 adult care homes in Wales face the threat of closure unless urgent action is taken and more financial support is provided.

“The information from the Office of Nationals Statistics has unfortunately confirmed what we have been warning about since February,” Mario Kreft said.

“The inadequacy in the policy to tackle the coronavirus crisis and the failure to lock down earlier and harder are now taking their tragic toll.

“Anecdotally, the message from our members is that admissions from hospitals have been a major factor in spreading the virus like wildfire in care homes, as opposed to community transmission.

“While those patients were not displaying symptoms when they were discharged from hospital, they later developed symptoms and infected other residents.

“There is now a very heavy toll on the residents and it’s clear from those care homes who have taken in hospital patients that there has been a very high risk of importing the infection into the care home and this has had tragic consequences.

“We understand from our members that they were assured these patients were Covid-free and they were accepted on that basis but in many cases that turned out not to be the case.

“Every death from coronavirus is one too many and a tragedy for the family and friends of those who have passed away, as well having an incredible emotional cost on the staff who dedicate their lives to caring for their residents.”

‘Not viable’

Mario Kreft added that there would be severe, existential consequences for the care sector if they continue without adequate support from the government..

“The care home sector cannot function with high occupancy of 90 per cent or more and was in a fragile state even before this all began because of the way care homes are funded by local authorities and health boards,” he said.

“If occupancy falls below 85 per cent it means the care home is not viable and we are seeing cases where occupancy is down to around 45 per cent or in one case down to 20 per cent.

“Occupancy in homes that have not accepted hospital patients is also falling because of the natural way of things because these homes have very frail people.

“We are very concerned about this and we have said that we would not accept a policy that would lead to mass care home deaths and residents being treated as collateral damage.

“It’s vitally important we do everything in our power to shield social care and save lives.

“We welcome the testing of everyone coming out of hospital and it really does need to be ramped up because if care homes don’t function, the NHS won’t function so we have to keep care homes running.

“Care Forum Wales has been calling for a proper regime of testing since February and improvements in the supply of PPE.

“We know people have been working very hard but there have been many promises on testing that have not come to pass but there is still a long way to go before we have the system of testing that we need, both to track staff so they can return to the front line and importantly to keep our residents safe.

“PPE is being consumed in huge quantities every day so we are going to have to ensure the supply chain is very strong in the months and maybe years ahead.

“The whole sector is under threat and without proper financial support we could see the closure of half our care homes within a year or less.

“Without a masterplan, without surety it’s conceivable there will be significant losses at the very time the NHS needs the care sector most.”

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Plain citizen
Plain citizen
4 years ago

Care homes are mainly privately owned institutions managed to generate a profit. Care forum Wales is their lobbying group. They want more taxpayers money. Obviously the virus is increasing the mortality rate of frail old people especially with pre existing conditions. Matio Kreft is effectively saying that homes are going to take a hit to their profits for something that the taxpayer who pays the bills can do nothing about. Obviously he wants more money for not looking after people who have died. If homes have to run at a loss for a year until we get back to normal… Read more »

Helen Lewis
Helen Lewis
4 years ago
Reply to  Plain citizen

I suspect you have little idea of what you are talking about. There is little profit in the sector overall. A substantial proportion of the bills are paid privately rather than by the taxpayer. If homes have to run at a loss they are likely to close.

Kerry Davies
Kerry Davies
4 years ago
Reply to  Helen Lewis

“Every employer shall ensure that suitable personal protective equipment is provided to his employees who may be exposed to a risk to their health or safety while at work.”
He and his wife made over £20M gross last year. They are reckoned to be worth £28M cash and if you think taxpayers should fund his legal duty towards his staff I must disagree. I had to buy my own and provide it when I hired casuals, why shouldn’t he?

David Roberts
David Roberts
4 years ago
Reply to  Helen Lewis

He’s talking out of his arse. I suspect he was a Herd Immunity supporter to start with!

4 years ago

Its been done before !

max wallis
max wallis
4 years ago

Care-home evidence that their residents sent back from hospital is a significant cause (he suggests the biggest source) of importing Covid into care-homes is surely important. The hospital may well claim from their test that a returnee was virus-free . Yet tests are inaccurate – if say 10% of virus-free results are wrong, it’s pretty disastrous fro the recipient care-home. The WHO recommends two tests at least 24 hours apart – why don’t we follow that in Wales? Moreover, there’s a gestation period between catching virus and showing a negative test, which gives time to pick up the virus but… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.