Support our Nation today - please donate here

Afghanistan war ‘always doomed to fail’ says Welsh peace society

16 Aug 2021 3 minute read
President Joe Biden discusses the evacuation of Afghanistan. Picture by The White House, Public Domain.

The war in Afghanistan was “always doomed to fail” and the British government should take the lead in offering refugees a safe home, according to a Welsh peace society.

Cymdeithas y Cymmod backed a statement by Stop the War which said that the “disaster now unfolding in Afghanistan is the consequence of a twenty-year long failed military intervention”.

“The responsibility rests with the US, British and other NATO governments which plunged into a war that was always doomed to fail. The starting of the conflict, not the manner of the ending of it, is the problem,” they said.

Their condemnation came after the Taliban recaptured nearly all of Afghanistan in just over a week, despite the billions of dollars spent by the U.S. and NATO over almost 20 years on the Afghan military.

Afghan President Ashraf Ghani has reportedly fled the country.

“If there were still countless countrymen martyred and they would face the destruction and destruction of Kabul city, the result would have been a big human disaster in this six million city,” he said in a Facebook post yesterday.

“The Taliban have made it to remove me, they are here to attack all Kabul and the people of Kabul. In order to avoid the bleeding flood, I thought it was best to get out,” President Ghani said in a Facebook post on August 15.”

According to witnesses, at least five people were killed in Kabul airport last night – either by gunshots or a stampede – as hundreds of people tried to leave the capital.


Cymdeithas y Cymod is part of the international IFOR (International Fellowship of Reconciliation) peace movement which has branches across the globe.

They argued that the military occupation of Afghanistan could not lead to stable governance and would be rejected as a foreign imposition by many Afghans.

The society added that “democracy and human rights can rarely be imposed externally and must be the product of the efforts of the peoples themselves if it is to prove durable”.

“Cymdeithas y Cymod supports the Coalition’s demand that the British government should take a lead in offering a refugee programme and reparations to rebuild Afghanistan,” they said.

“Such an act would go a great deal further in advancing the rights of the Afghan people, women in particular, than continued military or economic intervention in the fate of Afghanistan.

“We urge politicians of all parties to learn the lessons of the failed wars of intervention and turn to international cooperation as the means of resolving disputes.”



Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
j humphrys
j humphrys
2 years ago

Best left to Afghans, and surrounding countries.

arthur owen
2 years ago

Cymdeithas y Cymod could acknowledge that there was another invasion in 1979 but,of course,that was not by ‘western imperialists’.All these incursions into Afghanistan have failed,and the Afghan people seem to be worse off after each one.

Mab Meirion
Mab Meirion
2 years ago

So now we know Joe Biden…worse than Saigon, in the dead of night…what did you learn from Iraq ? Just one more American President…

Shan Morgain
2 years ago

There was once a fairly stable Socialist government in Afghanistan backed by Russia (c. 1990). The USA opposed that and to remove it the USA supported insurgent groups (mujahadeen) with money, arms and military advice. One sect of these, the Taliban, became the most successful. The USA got what it wanted, the destruction of the socialist government. It then made the Taliban the bogey to justify further military action and interference.

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.