Awkward Senedd exchange raises questions over Reform’s preparedness
Emily Price
Doubts have been raised about Reform’s readiness to operate as an effective opposition in the Senedd after one of its MSs appeared confused about how to ask a question during Plenary proceedings.
Casnewydd Islwyn MS Art Wright was described as “totally embarrassing” by political sources following questions to the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Minister for Social Justice and Equality on Wednesday (10 June).
Mr Wright was the second MS to be called by the Llywydd during the session to put a question to Sioned Williams.
Members can ask one pre-tabled question and once the Minister replies, the Member automatically gets one follow-up – or “supplementary” – question related to the topic, which does not need to be submitted in advance.
Reading his pre-tabled question from a piece of paper, Mr Wright asked: “What are the government’s plans to implement single sex spaces in Wales in accordance of the law?”
Ms Williams said the Welsh Government is taking forward implementation of the law in Wales “in a way that is clear, consistent and workable”, while ensuring that all people are treated with “dignity and respect”.
However, when Mr Wright should have stood to deliver his supplementarity question, he instead read out a short sentence from a piece of paper before quickly sitting down.
He said: “I have tabled the question today out of provenance from a direct ask from concerned citizens and many women’s advocacy groups across Wales who are tired of waiting for the protections our laws set out.”
As Senedd TV cameras showed Members exchanging bewildered looks, the Deputy First Minister replied: “I didn’t hear a question there, so I’ll leave it there.”
A political source told Nation.Cymru: “Reform said they’d hold the new Welsh Government to account, but they can’t even read out a prepared question from the sheet in front of them.
“Good governance in Wales relies on good scrutiny from opposition parties, but Reform are either incapable or uninterested in providing it.”
We asked Mr Wright whether he was aware that he was expected to ask a follow-up question and, if he had intended to ask a supplementary, what that question would have been.
The Reform MS did not respond.
It comes after shadow cabinet minister Jason O Connell was accused last week of offering little more than “soundbites” after his Senedd debut saw him reading from a long script which included slogans and catch phrases used by Reform during the Senedd election campaign.
It is unusual to have a Senedd that is around 70 per cent new Members, all of which are currently undertaking an ongoing programme of training on how to participate in debates and other parliamentary procedures.
Reform’s election hopefuls also underwent media and candidate training conducted by TV presenter Jeremy Kyle which included mock interviews.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Hopefully they will ask someone other kermit the frog, the cookie monster and big bird to provide them with the appropriate training and etiquette for public office.
Media training with Kyle?
HA!
The evidence to date not only shows that nearly all Reform MSs are totally politically inexperienced at Senedd level, but that they are of pretty low calibre as well. It looks as if we can expect largely shambolic opposition from Reform for the duration of this Senedd session.
IAI (inexperienced and inebriate) is the new DEI
Good to see the anti-elite party er…. punching down again….
Someone couldn’t even put together grammatical sentences for him to read out – “in accordance of the law”, “out of provenance from a direct ask”. Hope they don’t ask the same person to write someone a speech. Though on the other hand, I suppose it might be revealing in its way.
Hysbys y dengys dyn o ba radd y byddo’i wreiddyn.
Just imagine for one terrifying moment that Reform had won a majority in the Senedd.
Nigel would have his work cut out running Wales from Clacton or from wherever he’s currently in hiding.
I don’t like ’em, and don’t want ’em in the Senedd and I certainly don’t feel sorry for them, however, this is a democracy and they are here representing a very sizable proportion of those who voted in Cymru. Give them enough rope and they’ll shoot themselves in the foot! But this kind of reporting smacks of political elitism and snobbery, and feeds the very reason people have voted for them in the first place………… They are new and inexperienced, and frankly not much worse than some of then Assembly Members we had in the first few elections, so be… Read more »
They’re much, much worse than what we’ve had in the past.
People voted for them for one or two reasons, or both, they fell for the farage lies, because they don’t like people a different colour.
Looks like a perfect time for the electorate to start submitting written complaints.
To be fair, I think most of planet earth knew they’d be a joke.
Hey, ‘gender criticals’ – these are your guys! Reform, Putin, Trump, Orban, a great bunch.
Views and affiliations are fair game but not inexperience.
They’ve talked the talk so we should expect some level of competence at the very least. Having finally found a platform which comes with responsibilities, we’re going to find out just how competent, or rather how incompetent Reform is going to be. Reference Kent County Council and others where Reform are in charge.
Why is Reform leader in Wales, Dan Thomas, investing in a property portfolio (including at least one property in England) rather than investing in R&D and job creation here in CYMRU?
It’s certainly an error on Art’s part and I’m sure not one to be repeated however is it really worth a story in Nation Cymru?
Art’s mistake is far from “totally embarrassing” as considered by your political source. Perhaps that’s why they didn’t want to be named.
His performance is indicative of the contempt he and the other Reform MSs have for our democracy. He’s stealing a living and we can see it in plain sight. The sooner ‘Art’ and the rest of his Racist chums depart the Senedd the better.