Support our Nation today - please donate here

Braverman lifestyle choice comments ‘nonsense’ says homeless charity founder

07 Nov 2023 3 minute read
Home Secretary Suella Braverman – Image: Joe Giddens

The founder of a homeless charity has described Home Secretary Suella Braverman’s comments about rough sleepers as “nonsense” and “completely inappropriate”.

Dr Zahid Chauhan, founder of the charity Homeless Friendly, believes Ms Braverman’s remarks have exacerbated the stigma around homeless people and said her comments will demotivate people from receiving support.

It comes after the Home Secretary said rough sleeping is sometimes a “lifestyle choice”.

“It is completely inappropriate to brand that as a lifestyle choice,” Dr Chauhan said,

“These people are already suffering, they’ve already been stigmatised and coming from a national politician statements like that don’t help the cause.

“I think by saying these things, you’re just pushing people away.”

He added the comments generalised people’s personal situations and said she lacks understanding of their experience.


The GP said: “You cannot generalise things like that. You cannot brand that every person who is experiencing homelessness and sleeping in a tent is making a lifestyle choice.

“It’s actually nonsense and I think it’s ignorance, lack of understanding.”

Dr Chauhan spoke of people who have resorted to sleeping in cemeteries and claimed that current services do not provide enough support for homeless people and rough sleepers.

“I’ve seen people sleeping in graveyards with a tent because they’ve got nowhere else to go … This is the manifestation of crisis when you become a rough sleeper in a tent.

“There are loads of events take place before that and unfortunately our services are not geared up to support (homeless people). Our wider systems are not geared up to support them.”

“People talk them down, look down at them, and that doesn’t help these people it just creates more problems for them.

“My plea is if you cannot support them, don’t humiliate them.

The Labour councillor received an OBE in 2019 for his charity work, which focuses on encouraging GPs to allow rough sleepers into their clinics.

He has since urged Ms Braverman to spend time with members of Homeless Friendly to gain a better understanding of how the homeless live and learn of the struggles that homeless people face.

“I think she would benefit from our listening and our attending one of our training sessions,” Dr Chauhan said.

He said the UK Government needs to show care and compassion in order to help improve homeless services.

Dr Chauhan said: “Let’s gear up our homeless services, our housing services, benefits and social services to support these people.

“I think there’s more help and support needed but before the help and support comes, we need to understand the problem and we need to have the right caring attitude.”

One former homeless man, who spent six months sleeping rough and described his tent as a “lifeline”, challenged Ms Braverman to walk the streets with him to see the realities some people face.

Chris Royston said her comments had left him feeling “hurt”, “misunderstood” and “stigmatised”, as he accused the Government of seeking a “political score” and lacking the “want” to tackle the underlying causes of homelessness.

Prime Minister Rishi Sunak refused to criticise the Home Secretary’s claim but stopped short of repeating her comments.

Energy Secretary Claire Coutinho moved on Monday to distance herself from Ms Braverman’s comments.

The minister said she “wouldn’t necessarily use” the language the Home Secretary chose to talk about homelessness.

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
5 months ago

She needs to be attacking vulnerable people for the party (this is what they are now), the party do not censure her, this means the party supports her. The back of this it is still the Conservative Party attacking refugees but now impacting the many people they have driven to this. Contrast though with Lee Anderson who wanted people to be living in tents. The PM can end this by removing the minister from post and outright denouncing the comments (don’t forget she emailed sensitive documents on a off the books personal email account and jumped before pushed before Sunak… Read more »

Dai Ponty
Dai Ponty
5 months ago

And where does she think their are going to go just disapear the charities have no room to put them the SCUM PARTY have no soloutions to any problems

Richard 1
Richard 1
5 months ago

Braverman wants to emerge as Tory leader after the coming electoral wipe-out, so her position is meant to appeal to the party’s compassion-free right wing. After a single Parliament of Starmer mucking up she will come back with a mandate for savage repression on all fronts – not just the homeless

5 months ago
Reply to  Richard 1

Maybe there won’t even be an election, she’ll become leader, cancel the election, and use the Public Order Act on all who protest.

5 months ago

Suella Braverman is a walking advert for Welsh independence.

5 months ago

If she had one once of decency she would have resigned, she hasn’t resigned, and it comes as no surprise, because she doesn’t have an once of decency

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.