Britain must ‘move away’ from defence reliance on America, MPs and peers warn
Britain must “move away” from its reliance on the United States for defence and security, MPs and peers have warned amid continued transatlantic tensions.
In a report published on Friday, Parliament’s Joint Committee on the National Security Strategy (JCNSS) said the UK should continue to collaborate with the US “where practical”.
But it warned the Government should prepare for a “worst-case scenario” in which Europe could no longer rely on US support in a crisis.
Instead, the JCNSS said the UK should plan to transition to a more European-led Nato and “move away from a bilateral relationship with the United States that is so dependent on the latter”.
Britain currently relies on US support in several key national security areas, including maintenance of its Trident nuclear missiles, intelligence sharing and major projects such as the F35 fighter jet and Aukus submarine deal with Australia.
But the JCNSS said recent comments by US president Donald Trump had shown “demonstrable areas of tension” in UK-US relations that could “compromise the reliability of these dependencies”.
As well as his wider criticism of the Nato alliance and threats to annex Greenland earlier in the year, Mr Trump has repeatedly criticised the deal to transfer sovereignty of the Chagos Islands to Mauritius and been willing to use tariffs against traditional allies.
JCNSS chairman and Labour MP Matt Western said: “The unpredictability of the US relationship is a growing concern.
“The UK’s deep dependence on the US for security guarantees has a long history, and the partnership will outlast prime ministers and presidents alike.
“But the UK needs a clear plan to move away from some areas of strategic reliance to ensure the UK can pursue its national interest.”
As well as creating a more European-focused Nato, the committee recommended the Government pursue stronger relations with “middle powers” such as Australia, India and Canada.
‘Middle powers’
The recommendation follows a speech by Canadian prime minister Mark Carney at Davos in January, in which he called for “middle powers” to work together in the face of “an era of great power rivalry”.
Naomi Smith, chief executive of campaign group Best for Britain, said the JCNSS was “completely right”.
She said: “With a tyrant on Europe’s doorstep, we must urgently move away from a dangerous overreliance on US defence infrastructure and stand shoulder to shoulder with our closest allies and friends.”
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Trump is a danger to the world.
When Denmark sent troops to Greenland, they went armed to the teeth and prepared to fight a US invasion. Even had blood supplies and plans to blow up runways. This is how low Farage’s best friend in the US has taken a once great nation.
Of course we need better alliances, a EU army starting to look like a good move now. And drop any dependence on US kit, that includes Trident. Build our own, like France.
It’s really important that countries. Including NATO members, adequately arm themselves because Trump could turn on anyone at any time. For a man who dodged conscription himself he does not think twice sending other people’s sons and daughters to fight his private wars.
America cannot be trusted as an ally of any kind. I think now would be a good time to remove their forces from our bases.
Trump would turn on the UK in the blink of an eye.
Whilst I do not support the idea of a fully federal Europe, I do believe that as a continent we need to be far more capable of asserting our own influence globally and taking responsibility for our own security. We also should not dismiss the possibility, however unlikely it may seem today, that geopolitical alignments could shift in ways that undermine Europe’s long‑held assumptions about American partnership. Not long ago, it would have seemed unthinkable that a US president could publicly criticise its traditional allies, and appear more aligned with a Russian dictator. Imagine having to stand up to a… Read more »