News

Campaigners call for remote voting at Senedd amid concerns over collapse in scrutiny

24 Mar 2020 3 minutes Read
Empty: The Siambr at the Senedd building. Picture by the National Assembly.

The Electoral Reform Society in Wales have called for the Senedd to trial remote voting and video-links for Assembly Members, after it was announced that just 12 AMs would be scrutinising the Coronavirus Bill today.

These 12 Members will also be the only ones voting on whether to give the UK Government legislative consent for the Bill.

“Today the Senedd must debate and scrutinise the 300+ page Covid-19 emergency powers bill and ultimately decide whether to give consent to the Bill,” Electoral Reform Society Cymru Director, Jess Blair, said.

“This comes at a critical time for the nation and it is only right that Parliaments across the UK are able to discuss these vital issues.

“The last two weeks have demonstrated that the current pandemic has the possibility of impacting on parliamentary scrutiny. Quite rightly, in accordance with social distancing and social isolation restrictions, numbers in the Senedd today are being limited.

“The common-sense solution is that AMs who are locked out should be able to contribute to the debate and vote remotely. Otherwise, voters across Wales will go unrepresented on this crucial legislation.”

 

‘Life-changing’

As it stands, just 12 members will be able to be present to debate the legislation – six members from Welsh Government and six members of the opposition (three from the Conservatives, twp from Plaid Cymru and one from the Brexit Party).

The weekly opportunity to ask questions of the First Minister has also been suspended.

“The Senedd must find a way to adapt to working in this crisis in a more modern and dynamic way, ensuring that an already small parliament isn’t limited in it’s ability to represent the people of Wales, and scrutinise developments as they emerge over this period,” Jess Blair said.

“At times like this, the need for accountability increases, not decreases, as life-changing decisions are made for all of Wales.

“With Welsh MPs now limited in their ability to travel to London and take part in Westminster Parliamentary sessions, proper representation in the Senedd is now even more important.

“We urge the Senedd Commission to implement virtual plenary meetings and remote voting as a matter of urgency, as well as fully rolling out the use of digital Committee sessions and evidence gathering.
“The Senedd should look to the EU Parliament’s recent rollout of remote voting to see how this could be done in practice.

“Organisations across Wales and the UK are having to adapt to working in this unique environment. The Senedd can lead by example on this, and demonstrate that it is an agile and modern Parliament.”

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Hywel Moseley
Hywel Moseley
1 year ago

Time for the UK/English parliament to do likewise. I cannot think of a better way of spreading the virus that taking a vote by crowding into a lobbyhundreds at a time. It will of course affect more Tories than anyone else! But maybe Boris does not care.

Kerry Davies
Kerry Davies
1 year ago

So what happens if Wales or Scotland fail to pass the requisite Legislative Consent Motions? The Bill is an unopposed all-party bill so the concept of “remote” scrutiny is probably best served on another item of legislation. Great idea, wrong bill.

Michael McGrane
Michael McGrane
1 year ago

I thought all AM’s had computers, they could be used for remote meetings. What about councils? The same could apply after all this is over. The time spent and travelling expenses claimed could be spent on essential services.

Dr John Ball
Dr John Ball
1 year ago

i love the typo that accidentally and accurately describes Plaid Cymru – twp

Simon Gruffydd
Simon Gruffydd
1 year ago
Reply to  Dr John Ball

typo or Freudian slip? Perhaps a coded message?

Simon Gruffydd
Simon Gruffydd
1 year ago

Why doesn’t someone just tell them that covid-19 has now been taken off the dangerous viral infection list, https://www.gov.uk/guidance/high-consequence-infectious-diseases-hcid#status-of-covid-19 , so they can all get back to work and stop playing this charade.

Our Supporters