Support our Nation today - please donate here

‘Carbon colonialism’: Concern Welsh Government tree planting project could displace Ugandan farmers

23 Sep 2021 3 minute read
Ugandan farmer. Picture by CIAT (CC BY-NC-SA 2.0).

The Conservatives have expressed concern that a Welsh Government tree planting project could displace Ugandan farmers, accusing them of possible “carbon colonialism”.

They said that some subsistence farmers were being forcibly removed from their land in Uganda to provide space for tree planting, that in turn can be used for the selling of carbon credits and offsetting carbon emissions of other countries.

The Welsh Government has spent millions of pounds planting trees in the Mt Elgon region of Mbale through its Size of Wales project, currently chaired by former First Minister Carwyn Jones.

But speaking in the Senedd, Welsh Conservative Shadow Minister for Social Partnership, Joel James MS, asked the Welsh Government to confirm that they were not using the forest planted in Uganda to also offset Welsh carbon emissions.

Responding to the question, the Minister for Social Justice Jane Hutt said that the project was a pioneering initiative in terms of the Wales and Africa programme and spent £450,000 a year from Wales in Africa.

She said that “what we do in terms of supporting this initiative is to provide funding and expertise to local and indigenous communities in tropical regions, and it’s helping to support them to secure and sustain their precious forests, grow more trees and establish sustainable livelihoods”.

“And that’s about education, community engagement and advocacy, and Size of Wales does raise that awareness in Wales of the importance of tropical forests and trees in tackling climate change with local people and with local governments.”


A spokesperson from Size of Wales responded to say that they rejected the Conservatives’ claims.

“The Mbale Trees Programme works extremely closely with the local community and farmers and runs a large network of community tree nurseries across the Mount Elgon region,” they said.

“These nurseries grow and distribute seedlings for free to local farmers and schools who voluntarily grow trees on their land.”

“Farmers have benefited greatly from tree planting which has improved soil quality and crop yields and led to more sustainable livelihoods. The trees also help protect local communities from the impacts of climate change, such as soil erosion and deadly landslides. The programme is delivered by local organisations with our support and is focussed on improving local livelihoods, as well as the environment. “

“The Mbale Trees Programme is not part of a carbon offsetting scheme, and no carbon credits are generated by the planting of trees.”

But the Welsh Conservatives claimed that the Welsh Labour Government’s policy of reforesting the entire Mt Elgon region with fruit, shade and fuel trees could call for the removal of local farmers who operate on deforested land.

Joel James MS said: “Yesterday’s response – or lack of response is highly worrying. This should have been very easy for the Minister to rule out if it was not going to use the Mt Elgon forest in Uganda to offset Welsh carbon emissions and the Welsh Labour Government weren’t going to be displacing Ugandan farmers in the process.

“Jane Hutt’s lack response in the chamber just encapsulates the Welsh Governments approach to policy, they say one thing and do another or in this case, they ignore questioning all together.

“Carbon colonialism is a major concern and has a drastic effect on local farmers in Uganda. It’s high time the Welsh Labour Government stopped dodging questions and started providing some concrete answers.”

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
2 years ago

May be well meaning but smacks of the virtue signalling so common now in politics. If tree planting is so important why have 100s of thousands of trees been torn down in Wales to enable windfarm developments. Peat bogs ruined, other natural water retention and drainage eco systems kyboshed to make room for concrete foundations and access road ways. Disgraceful absence of joined up thinking.

Sean Thompson
Sean Thompson
2 years ago
Reply to  hdavies15

Firstly, it’s simply untrue that ‘hundreds of thousands of trees have been torn down’ in order to build wind turbines. Second, the Welsh government has announced a big increase in its tree planting programme (which it hasn’t been too successful with up till now) and is proposing to drive the restoration of peat bogs in upland areas, most of which, of course have been damaged by current unsustainable commercial agricultural practices. It is these same ‘agribusiness’ practices which have led to the removal of hedges and woodlands and the pollution of waterways all over the country, such as the killing… Read more »

2 years ago
Reply to  Sean Thompson

I suggest you revisit places like Pen y Cymoedd and other large scale “investments”. A big contributor to the accelerated flow of rain waters off the hilltops into the Rhondda Valleys.

j humphrys
j humphrys
2 years ago
Reply to  Sean Thompson

Restoration of peat bogs means tearing down the metal monsters and digging up the concrete bases…………this will not happen until we get our independence.

2 years ago

A Tory worried about farmers in Uganda. They didnt worry about feeding children in England when Marcus Rashford had to sort it. Hypocrisy

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.