Columnist advises Welsh to ‘head for high ground’ after Minister’s pledge to build hydroelectric dams
A newspaper columnist has advised the people of Wales to “head for high ground” after a UK Government Secretary of State suggested that he was looking into the possibility of building more hydroelectric dams.
Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, Kwasi Kwarteng, said that he was determined to increase the amount of hydroelectric power in Britain.
“I am fully conscious of the outstanding contribution of hydroelectric power. In fact, I was just speaking to the Norwegian Minister, and that country has 96% of its electricity derived from hydropower,” he said.
He said that he had “asked officials to look into it” to see what opportunities for hydroelectric dams existed in the UK.
Reporting on the comments in the Times, columnist Quentin Letts said: “Residents of the Welsh valleys may want to head for high ground.”
His comment was a reference to the numerous valleys in Wales that have been drowned by the UK Government to produce water and energy, including Llyn Celyn, Llyn Clywedog and Llyn Fyrnwy.
The drowning of Llyn Celyn in the 1960s was politically controversial and led to the slogan ‘Cofiwch Dryweryn’.
Wales is already home to one of Wales’ largest hydroelectric projects – the Dinorwig pumped-storage hydroelectric scheme, which was constructed in the abandoned Dinorwig slate quarry. The Ffestiniog Pumped Storage Scheme is to the south-east.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
Here we go…
Back in a day, the North of Scotland Hydro Board surveyed all the possible Glens that would be suitable for Hydropower and EXCLUDED ALL where the natural beauty would be destroyed and cause local resentment.
I wonder how many sites are in the Lake District, or in the Peak District of England – I bet none!!!!
Stick ’em all in the Pennines and wait for the god almighty row !
We could adopt the technology here in Wales but only to suit local communities who might prefer it to monster turbines all over the place.
Plenty of water in the Lake District.
They really really hate us
How did the jrm visit go
Tory smiles rhyme with wiles…tricks, ruses, ploys, schemes, dodges, manoeuvres, gambits, subterfuges, artifices, guile, devices, contrivances, cunning and craftiness. Just saying…
Cunning is very similar to a word I’d use to describe them
Although I agree that there is (almost) always an air of the nefarious with the Tory Party (and appreciate some nice word play – good stuff), I don’t see them, or any avowed unionist party that way right now. They’re often quite explicit, quite brash, boorish even. They tend to just come out and say what they mean nowadays. Llafur Cymru’s current flirtation with the fringes of the indy movement seems closer to your statement (until I’m – hopefully – proving entirely wrong). Hate the Tory stance, thank the gods that they trumpet it loud and proud.
I thank you for your reply and there is much of merit in your post. His words in the Guardian today, however, support my ‘good stuff’.
You do realise that Llyn Celyn was a Labour project?
A Tory project, initiated under McMillan.
Are you saying a large part of the Yes Cymru membership are National Socialists?
I’ve been “of the left” my whole life,never joined a political party,because I never liked the “true believer” element that comes with it.To gain independence Wales has to convince Labour voters of its validity,some people coming from the Labour party into Yes Cymru feel the movement must therefore “become like labour” it’s a very navel gazing attitude typical of true believers.Yes Cymru is group dedicated to Independence it’s a pressure group aiming to spread this word into the community ,including political parties! The modern discourse in Welsh politics mirrors the rest of the world unfortunately, soundbites,empowering words that are basically… Read more »
If that is your opinion of Yes Cymru, may I suggest you cite some evidence to back it up.
I have a (sinking) feeling that one reason Welsh independence will never be realised is precisely what has been alluded to here.
If, as has been widely predicted by Climate Scientists, that conditions across the world and our own island change drastically over the next Century, H2O will become an increasingly valuable resource. It’s one of Wales’ most important natural resources. What chance is there that the UK/English Government will allow such a precious resource to be taken out of their sphere of influence? Watch this space.
Ssssshhhhhh! Environment (Wales) Act 2016 and the Wales Act 2017 already go some way to handing power from Westminster to the Sennedd on natural resources including water.
Cairns promised faithfully that he would give up the SoS right of veto over the environment.
“Cairns promised faithfully…” Ha Ha that’s an oxymoron, or just the moron ? Boy is a big time fabricator
Well, please remember that it’s not just us who monitor England’s moves, but Europe and the World. Any aggression is around the world in a flash.
My mamgu said 30+ years ago ‘We can live without oil but will always need water, so I’d rather a water well than an oil well on my land’. More true now than ever.
We need to properly guard against profits from water going the same way as the coal and slate money did. Interestingly many English immigrants are angry that water rates here are higher than in England and some of the most ‘aggressive’ Welsh nationalists I know are the offspring of English parents or grandparents. We must not go quietly under the waters, again.
Do we not all share and profit from each other’s resources? This world is becoming so seperatist that we are all in danger of failing! Work together for the common good!
If these a-holes try this again, its war.
STFU you sorry idiot. You have all been riled up by Ifan Bach putting a picture of a black man and a dam on a complete non-story.
All so that you all come here and make nasty comments and see his clickbait links and earn him money.
He playing you ignorant snide morons for the pathetic clueless people you are!
Yeh, right. Because absolutely no-one was aware of the condition of Wales before Nation.Cymru was established? Nation.Cymru does a good job of bringing these issues to a still-wider Welsh public, in the absence of a national print media.
No mention of Tidal power then? Is there not some useful Geothermal energy available from some of our older mine workings too?
Cymru is a great site for tidal power, of various forms. And reliable and predictable output, unlike some renewables. But let’s have a good mix, with maybe some pumped storage to act as batteries.
First separate Pumped Storage from free-flow hydro…one makes electric and money the other is expensive and for emergencies only…putting the kettle on at half-time during the World Cup etc.
The Thames valley would be an excellent site.
Soon will be for tidal power given the rate London and parts of South East are sinking !
Is that why they opened-up the Fenns……….instead of the Nederlands?
Obviously a different ‘Yes Cymru’ to the real life one.
Love how having an opinion on trans that doesn’t meet the new liberal standards makes you homophobic or racist, it will always remain a mental health issue for me , exploited by attention seekers.
Hydro electric dams at sea are the answer our tidal power is massive and extremely predictable. It could also help boost sea defence. No more farmland or valleys should be flooded especially in Cymru, we’ve got more then our fair share.
Good idea, but will the money it makes remain here?
The Crown estates would take their cut – absolute theft.
How strange to see a comment that ridicules the ‘culture war’ in one part and ends with a full-blown salvo aimed inwards. Sorry, not strange, achingly predictable. This Anglo-American construct – the culture war – has no truck within our movement and, I would argue, in Wales generally. EVERYONE is welcome, EVERYONE has a right to speak and EVERYONE will be covered by good pathways for complaints and grievance as YesCymru undertake a necessary professionalisation (in the manner the organisation conducts itself). This comment, although unlikely to be so, is the EXACT type of messaging that those who wish for… Read more »
…And where are the solar panels on houses in England’s Home Counties? I know of one “village” (a small town in practical terms) where dozens of houses have been demolished in the last 25 years and replaced by grandiose dwellings with few, if any trees, hardly any green garden and NO solar panels. Local MP is none other than Oliver Dowden.
I feel that you are mistaken””so many”,even in the twittersphere,not really that many Cathy.Do they exist , undoubtedly,just as that bastion of woke values the Welsh Labour party,has voters that are all of those with a healthy dose of self hating Welsh people.I hear the arguments from I’m guessing your part of this argument” if Welsh independence means non inclusive fascist future ,I want no part” ,Suprise suprise Cathy I’m on the opposite side of this “culture war” and don’t want that either.The left in politics( I consider myself of the left btw,even though fascist seems to be the common… Read more »
Flood the Thames Valley you arse.
But what would estuary English sound like then? Some sort of blubglug language?
Wales probably has a lot of potential for small hydroelectric schemes, of similar size to Mary Tavy Power Station in Devon (supplying 1700 homes), or Fonthill Lake in Wiltshire (supplying 11 homes).
What’s needed is LOCAL thinking, perhaps including community ownership. We already have individual households selling solar power to the grid on sunny days, so it can’t be difficult!
There is plenty ofpotential capacity for community owned hydro in Cymru (which should be exempt from business rates) and as other posters have made clear plenty of potential for tidal, no dams required see the Orbital O2 in Orkney, or pumped storage (Glyn Rhonwy 100MW scheme given consent) which can utilise old industrial sites, or heat pumps using water in old mines. Control of the resource should remain in Cymru.
I’ve warned this many times in previous posts that the Tories are indeed planning more dam building Wales. Crooked Boris Johnson indicated so years ago as London Mayor, And this news should raise alarm bells as Minister Kwasi Kwarteng can overruled our Senedd Cymru as done with Home Secretary Priti Patel did when she bypassed the our Welsh Government and the people of Pembrokeshire when she place hundreds of desperate migrants in terrible dehumanising Covid incubating conditions. Tory diktat Kwasi Kwarteng must realise that the Welsh nation will not take lightly another Tryweryn forced on us by Whitehall. Not one… Read more »
That is why they want to keep Wales in the UK. If England had to pay a fair price for Welsh water Wales would be a very rich country 🏴
Dwr Cymru owns 91 reservoirs in Wales
United United Utilities and Severn Trent operate 2 – they pay for the maintenance and the wate
Dwr Cymru’s turnover for water charges for the entire country is approximately £350 000 000.
So in what world would Wales be very rich?
In a world where Wales is an independent state, fully able to negotiate and set rates for our own international trade. That’s the key sticking point in the economic debate over indy – those who are against or sceptical continually fall into the trap of considering how Wales operates now. We operate as part of a UK market. Our contention is that Wales would be better off if we did it ourselves, so any contemporary examples of how things work should be moot. We won’t be Ireland, we won’t be Switzerland, we won’t be Denmark, but these are all examples… Read more »
You said Wales would be rich from water.
How so? It is important you clarify for everyone’s sake.
In exactly the same way that many other independent states are able to monetise their natural resources, a way we are currently unable to do. Could it be bungled, could it prove to be a terrible way to generate capital, could it be mismanaged? Yes (and that is the current situation) but it’d be our responsibility, both our achievements and the failures. Right now, we’re subject to the whims of the elected officials voted in by the vast population next door. I cannot understand why the perpetual scepticism are about things we cannot know for sure and not the broader… Read more »
This may sound like a joke but I wouldn’t be surprised at all if it really was Tory thinking – flood the valleys rather than build barrages off the coast. They have no love of Labour voting communities. Undoubtedly, muscular unionism on steroids.
Wales can vote 100% Labour and it won’t affect an UK election outcome. There are no Scottish Labour MPs to boost English/UK Labour numbers so it’s permanent Conservative governments until the end. UK Labour has to support the union or accept it will never win another election. Checkmate.
Yes, why does Welsh Labour still believe in this tooth fairy?
There were plans to build reservoirs in West Yorkshire and south Oxfordshire, but were abandoned after strong local opposition. they will not have to worry about this in Wales.