Former First Minister blocked from voting in Senedd debate from car
Emily Price
Former First Minister Vaughan Gething has been blocked from attempting to cast a vote in a Senedd debate whilst sat in a car.
During voting time in Plenary on Wednesday (October 1), Deputy Presiding Officer David Rees told the Chamber that one Member appeared to be voting from a vehicle.
He said: “There is a Member that is voting – seems to be – from his car and therefore I will not be accepting that vote in accordance with guidance that has been issued.”
Although the Deputy Presiding Officer did not name the politician, Nation.Cymru was later told by a Senedd Member who did not wish to named that the MS in question was Labour’s Vaughan Gething.
‘Checked out’
The anonymous Senedd Member told Nation.Cymru that the Cardiff South and Penarth MS had attempted to blur the background that was visible on his computer link to the Chamber – but that “it was still very obvious he was sat in a vehicle”.
They added: “Vaughan has totally checked out from his job at the moment.
“He barely turns up as it is, all he has to do is log in once a week to vote and he can’t even do that properly from home.”
Leader of the Welsh Conservatives, Darren Millar, branded Mr Gething “disrespectful”.
He said: “The voters of Wales elect MSs to the Senedd, not their sofas, armchairs or cars. Trying to vote from a motor vehicle is totally disrespectful.
“The pandemic is long over and it’s time that virtual attendance and participation in Senedd proceedings was brought to an end.”
Mr Gething had been trying to log a vote on a debate brought forward by his Labour colleague Mick Antoniw on a legislative proposal for a Bill on fly-tipping.
Members taking part in Plenary proceedings via video link are able to cast their votes individually using an electronic voting application.
Those intending to vote remotely must notify the Chamber Secretariat in advance and must have their cameras switched on when they cast their vote.
However, Senedd guidance states that, “Members must not vote whilst in a vehicle or public transport, or whilst travelling”.
Controversies
A spokesperson for the Llywydd said: “In accordance with guidance issued by the Llywydd, Members must not vote while in a vehicle or public transport or whilst travelling.
“Members were reminded of this in Plenary last week.
“On this basis, the Deputy Presiding Officer did not accept one Member’s vote at Voting Time yesterday evening.”
In September 2024, Mr Gething announced he would not be standing for re-election in 2026.
In July that yer he had stepped down from his role as Wales’ First Minister just four months after getting it.
During his short time in office, the Labour politician had been embroiled in several controversies including a £200,000 campaign donation from a businessman convicted of dumping toxic sludge in a nature reserve.
Mr Gething was invited to comment but did not respond.
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.
He should resign and just leave quietly.
He blatantly and publicly broke the rules when he first came into politics (electioneering at polling booths), so he’s not going to change the habits of a lifetime.
The one positive is that his name now goes before him, so maybe a long journey is required to evade this for whatever he’s trying to line himself up for, hopefully in a country other than Cymru.
Sorry Gethin. I know you think rules don’t apply to you anymore, and unless you’ve got a valid reason for not being there as highlighted, have got to be physically present to vote in the Senedd chamber. Oh, and turn up for work more often too. You know, the position you were elected to by your constituents, the ones who pay your wage.
Saying yesterday that parents WFH had contributed to poor school attendance, but allow these shenanigans not the first faux pas by this MS.
In a modern democracy there is a place for remote voting similar to rules in UK parliament, illness, govt overseas business i.e. pairing, parenting or caring but you would expect them to be at home or caring location.
You have to wonder how many picking up a substantial salary from Senedd are getting renumeration at same time elsewhere, like some advisers in past.
Most of them are working at reduced speed. Getting them up to 20mph would be a “win”
So sad, Still thinks he’s a special case.
High time he went
About par for the course for Villainous Vaughan. He wants the salary but won’t do the work, leaving Cardiff South and Penarth unrepresented. Roll on May when Anna Brychan and Keira Marshall from Plaid will replace him
He’s now driving his taxi around Cardiff and the Vale, it’s very difficult to fit it all in. And then there’s the digger at the landfill on the weekends. Radio Wales are after him to do the weather and continuity and the it usual Christmas panto is looming… “Rachel and the Beanstalk”. Book early.
Old habits die hard. If this man hasn’t realised that he has to stick to the rules especially after he has drawn a great target on his own head he must be a complete idiot and is definitely in the wrong job. If he wants to stay in politics he’d better join Reform where they have little regard for rules and don’t care about what people think.
Does this guy get an annual payment similar to an ex prime minister?
Perhaps he was driving to the tip, sorry, walk on the Gwent levels.