Inquest report on Welsh Labour’s election defeat gets it wrong, says ex-minister

Martin Shipton
A report on how Welsh Labour can regain support misinterpreted the polling data it used to analyse the party’s heavy defeat in May’s Senedd election, according to former Minister Lee Waters.
Professor Anand Menon of King’s College London led the review, which the party published at the weekend. He is a former member of the advisory board of Labour Together, the centrist Labour think tank close to Keir Starmer.
The report argued that Welsh Labour’s campaign focused too much on constitutional issues.
Writing on Substack, Mr Waters, the former Llanelli MS, said the report’s own polling showed that voters the party needed to win back cared about powers for the Senedd and fairer funding for Wales.
“That’s the re-wiring of the State they consistently voice support for,” he said.
Mr Waters pointed to a Welsh Labour campaign staff member quoted anonymously in the report, who said: “I just don’t think we really connected with our audience.”
He said the report implied that Eluned Morgan had “got lost in the constitutional weeds and should have stuck to ‘bread and butter’ issues”.
Mr Waters argued that Welsh Labour MPs and MSs had spent years saying Westminster was letting Wales down on rail funding and resources, only for the new Labour Government to repudiate those claims once in office.
He also said Vaughan Gething’s handling of a major campaign donation had damaged the trust Mark Drakeford had built during the Covid pandemic. He argued that Ms Morgan’s inconsistency in standing up for Wales had weakened her credibility.
“Voters had stuck with Labour in the hope that things would get better,” he said. “Keir Starmer killed that hope and Welsh Labour leaders were perceived to be excusing it.”
Election
Mr Waters also questioned why a graph in the report tracking Welsh Labour’s decline started in July 2024. He said starting it four months earlier would have shown that the fall in support coincided with Mr Gething’s election as leader.
He said Welsh Labour had done well under Rhodri Morgan, Carwyn Jones and Mr Drakeford, who represented different traditions within the party and made room for voters who identified as both Labour and Welsh. He said the party had fared less well under Alun Michael, Mr Gething and Ms Morgan.
“Ken Skates seems confident he can buck the trends and that the recommendations of the report set out a ‘road back to victory’,” Mr Waters said. He added that voters would have their say at May’s council elections.
‘Local insight’
A Labour source said: “Lee Waters is right. This report ducks the difficult questions Welsh Labour desperately needs to answer.”
The source questioned how heavily the review relied on paid staff who had run the campaign and why it had been led by someone they felt lacked a strong enough connection to Wales.
“This needed independence, local insight and the willingness to challenge the party,” the source said.
The source said the review’s own findings showed that voters who switched to Plaid Cymru had a stronger sense of Welsh identity and wanted a party that stood up for Wales.
“Welsh Labour cannot win back trust by acting as a branch office of UK Labour,” the source said. “It must rediscover its Welsh identity, have the confidence to challenge Westminster and put Wales first.”
“You cannot rebuild a party by avoiding its uncomfortable past, marking your own homework or failing to understand the country you are asking to represent.”
Support our Nation today
For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.


“Mr Waters argued that Welsh Labour MPs and MSs had spent years saying Westminster was letting Wales down on rail funding and resources, only for the new Labour Government to repudiate those claims once in office.”
I agree with a lot of Waters’ argument.
Labour also created an expectation that once there was a Labour government in both Cardiff and London, they would reform the funding injustices.