Support our Nation today - please donate here

Inspector says planned 5G mast in a built-up area would be an ‘alien installation’

18 Jan 2024 2 minute read
Photo by mikecogh is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0

Richard Youle Local Democracy Reporter

A 5G mast planned in a built-up area would be “overbearing” and “an alien installation”, a planning inspector said.

Penny Davies rejected an appeal for the 16m mast at Cwmbwrla Square, Manselton, after Swansea Council’s planning committee turned the scheme down last year.


Applicant CK Hutchinson Networks (UK) Ltd appealed the decision, and Welsh Government planning inspector Ms Davies said she did not question the need for 5G coverage for the area.

However, Ms Davies said the mast would be considerably taller than nearby properties and would cause substantial harm to the character and appearance of the area.

Her decision report said the grey mast “would result in a visually intrusive and alien installation” that would dominate the street and be particularly overbearing for the closest house – probably visible even from its back garden and conservatory.

Ms Davies added that on the evidence before her, she was not persuaded that the availability of more suitable sites for the mast had been satisfactorily considered.


People living close to the proposed mast staged a protest and submitted a petition of opposition before councillors on the planning committee debated the application last January.

Planning officers recommended the scheme for approval, saying the impacts would be predominantly localised and would not adversely affect the wider area. They said other sites had been considered and discounted by the applicants and that a site had to receive a signal level which would make the mast operationally effective.

But the committee turned the application down by seven votes to three. Councillors heard from resident Kay Richards, who said her “forever home” on Pentregethin Road she has lived in for 52 years would have been five metres from the “monstrosity” and its three accompanying cabinets.

Cwmbwrla councillor Peter Black, who is a member of the committee and said the mast would severely impact Mrs Richards’s home, has welcomed the inspector’s decision. “We need 5G, but we’ve got to put masts in the proper place – right next to residents’ homes was completely unreasonable in my view,” he said.

Support our Nation today

For the price of a cup of coffee a month you can help us create an independent, not-for-profit, national news service for the people of Wales, by the people of Wales.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Richard Davies
Richard Davies
5 months ago

An intelligent decision, and the right one.

5 months ago

> “We need 5G, but we’ve got to put masts in the proper place – right next to residents’ homes was completely unreasonable in my view,” Er… OK… so if you can’t put them near homes, then where can you put them…? They *do* need to be near to where people are, sticking one up the top of a mountain miles from anyone is pointless – and I suppose people would complain about having a mast at the top of a mountain as well. Bunch of bloody luddite NIMBYs… given half the chance they’d probably protest against motor carriages or… Read more »

Our Supporters

All information provided to Nation.Cymru will be handled sensitively and within the boundaries of the Data Protection Act 2018.